Wait isn't Nolan Keeney in that same class?

Report problem with this ad

Dec 4, 2024
7:02:32am

NGB Intervention Needed

Report problem with this ad

NGB

Previous username: Natgasboy
Bio page: NGB
Joined: Dec 28, 2023
Last login: Dec 9, 2024
Total posts: 812 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Perfect example and primary reason Arod needs to be replaced and it’s not

Das_Countach

Dec 3, 11:33pm

Already his third school to commit to. Impressive.

JuicyJam

Dec 3, 11:50pm

Using 247 ratings, BYU has a commitment from the #66 QB in the country

StantonMac

Dec 3, 11:54pm

…almost identical rating to both Zach Wilson and Jaren Hall…

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 12:05am

And? That is completely irrelevant.

StantonMac

Dec 4, 12:23am

Not any more or less irrelevant than your initial comment

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 12:28am

It’s completely relevant to counter your assertion that ARod can’t recruit

StantonMac

Dec 4, 12:33am

Teams can only offer one QB a class. Offering 2 means not all in

Bobmarleyjr

Dec 4, 1:11pm

Arod is lazy. He needs to offer everyone 1 to 99.

sah22

Dec 4, 1:17pm

Noncommittable offers?

Cooouuugs

Dec 4, 2:01pm

I’m in full agreement that BYU needs better QB recruiting year in and year out but this kid isn’t the answer. There are

Zach Morris

Dec 4, 12:06am

…I don’t know man, threw for nearly 400 yds, 74% 5TD 0int vs Corner Canyon

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 12:11am

Fair point and normally a school like OU is a great barometer but I’ve seen them offer relatively low quality guys in

Zach Morris

Dec 4, 12:15am

Yeah can’t stand that Venables giy

Cooouuugs

Dec 4, 4:46am

CC D is not that great.

fattycoug

Dec 4, 10:10am

No idea, but OU has a new OC...potentially tracked him at WSU.

Cougstreak

Dec 4, 9:23am

Talking with Helaman - he never seemed like he was interested in staying in Utah

crack

Dec 4, 12:37am

Im sure $$ was a factor as well &definitely something that is difficult for BYU

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 12:51am

Kalani needs to change that mindset ASAP. Life is all about the Benjamin's

gopman

Dec 4, 5:18am

That is mandate by BYU and the BoT

Schultz is back

Dec 4, 9:18am

True, but there is something to it. I feel like there is a difference between

RoboKayne

Dec 4, 9:25am

It's a fine line. BYU/Kalani have valid points. Culture, integrity, perception

Buster Scruggs

Dec 4, 10:17am

I wouldn’t worry about this kid. He’s as flaky as the day is long.

Adwight

Dec 4, 2:40am

The same ARod that cooled on Isaac Wilson and decided not to pursue him, good choice.

TheLoneCougar

Dec 4, 5:27am

I don’t think that’s true

All-American

Dec 4, 6:21am

Im pretty sure it was the exact opposite, Isaac cooled on Arod, the confirmation

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 7:23am

Do you have inside info on this?

niqmadu

Dec 4, 7:29am

Who cares either way. Wasn’t coming to BYU and nobody is convinced it

stoils

Dec 4, 8:01am

No, there are plenty of people here that know the real story and situation. What happens on FO stays on FO.

TheLoneCougar

Dec 4, 7:23pm

Story I've always heard, Wilson was a sure-fire lock and the family asked BYU to stop recruiting Hammond, which they did

BIG XII Coug

Dec 4, 8:49am

Very true.

TheLoneCougar

Dec 4, 7:24pm

What is more important… getting big recruits or putting QBs in the NFL?

Pretorian

Dec 4, 6:23am

100% agree. Of all the ARod critiques, QB recruiting and development might be the worst.

cscougar

Dec 4, 7:25am

My kids go to Lehi & I have watched Jett play many times.There are better option

ElkhunterUT

Dec 4, 6:49am

Wait isn't Nolan Keeney in that same class?

NGB

Dec 4, 7:02am

A mid to low 3 star with a better rated QB in same class committed to BYU is

NYC and Japan

Dec 4, 7:09am

Or another way took at this is that oklahomas recruiting is so bad that

niqmadu

Dec 4, 7:33am

Just stop. Tell me that you don’t know the intricacies and nuances

Refugee

Dec 4, 7:56am

Would you like Arod to put hand cuffs on the kid and bring him to campus by

Polecat

Dec 4, 8:20am

Yea, with the reduced scholarship #s let’s fire our OC because he didn’t offer

BYU I Bleed Blue

Dec 4, 8:30am

He recruited that big time ginger recruit that Alabama wanted. Didn't work out

boctabulous

Dec 4, 9:03am

BYU is going to lose many head to head battles with SEC and B1G teams

reddead

Dec 4, 9:16am

I don't know the Niu and BYU history, but I know Casuga was never a real target for BYU (ie he did not have interest).

Cougstreak

Dec 4, 9:21am

Just sign Ryder Lyons and we are set.

Cougstreak

Dec 4, 12:46pm

I agree with the premise but this is not the example you are looking for.

Lifer

Dec 4, 12:10pm

...agree, Niu isn't the worst example, but this shows the scope of the issue

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 1:00pm

Why is it so difficult to some to see Arod’s virtue? He’s been great

gocougs719

Dec 4, 1:02pm

Some on here have a weird obsession with proving he stinks.

runnincoug

Dec 4, 1:42pm

and some have a weird obsession ignoring his less than stellar track record

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 1:46pm

to the contrary, I wasn't very optimistic about him before, but he's been great

runnincoug

Dec 4, 1:50pm

"this year"? ...the year that defense & special teams scored 1/3 the pts? lol

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 1:54pm

Yes, the year that he took a terrible QB, made him 3rd highest rated (PFF)

runnincoug

Dec 4, 2:34pm

…Arod, the reason there ARE only terrible QBs on the team that he HAD to make

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 2:50pm

I'm not sure we'll see eye to eye on this.

runnincoug

Dec 4, 3:19pm

haha, that one cooked you. Your arbitrary reasoning won't back you out of

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 4:18pm

I can tell you are completely unreasonable in your evaluation because

StantonMac

Dec 4, 4:37pm

I didn't concede anything. You're not really making sense at this point.

runnincoug

Dec 4, 4:46pm

Oh it makes complete sense, and you know what I am stating is accurate, but

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 4:55pm

No, I don't think you're accurate at all. But arguing with you any further

runnincoug

Dec 4, 5:00pm

lol, then tell me why he didnt have anyone better to go than Retzlaff- simple Q

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 5:08pm

Because recruiting isn't a draft. You don't just get to say "I pick you".

StantonMac

Dec 4, 5:14pm

lol, so you don’t have a response for it either, I see 😂

Das_Countach

Dec 4, 5:19pm

Honestly, it's a little hard to take you seriously when you started this

StantonMac

Dec 4, 5:46pm

<< Deleted >>

gocougs719

Dec 4, 6:22pm

BYU recruited Jake, the 3rd best QB in the Big12 with a year to play

NYC and Japan

Dec 5, 3:03pm

Ranked 10th out of 16 in QBR... behind Ok State's Bowman... you making up stats?

Das_Countach

Dec 5, 3:06pm

Nope. Shared the Big12 awards just announced. Actual link from Big12 website

NYC and Japan

Dec 5, 3:21pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad