Quite accurate. I might move Virgil Carter up to 13.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 27, 2024
9:22:03am

AF Cougar All-American

Quite accurate. I might move Virgil Carter up to 13.

Report problem with this ad

AF Cougar

Bio page: AF Cougar
Joined: Jan 26, 2002
Last login: Nov 27, 2024
Total posts: 13,838 (314 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This thread is one of the worst ratings of BYU QBs that I’ve seen

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 9:53pm

Those 2 have more NFL starts than all other BYU QB's minus Steve Young probably

g$

Nov 26, 10:02pm

Does Taysom Hill count as a QB?

Mikey

Nov 26, 10:07pm

Yes, and I think he is better than #11

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 10:10pm

Hill at 11 might be high. He is a great player, was not a great QB

kimdaddy35

Nov 26, 10:53pm

As a football player, yes. As a QB, no.

LakeshowCougs

8:14am

LOL BYU has 4 QBs in the college HOF. 2 of them didnt crack the top 12

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:10pm

Which ones were Heisman finalists? Detmer (won), Young & McMahon. Any others?

Nov 26, 10:19pm

Marc Wilson was 3rd in Heisman voting

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 10:25pm

But lower than Jake Retzlaff in BYU history

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:28pm

Bosco was a finalist twice

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:26pm

I had Marc Wilson at #9 in 2022. The problem is BYU has had a lot of really good QBs.

kimdaddy35

Nov 26, 11:28pm

Wilson should probably be 4 or 5

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 11:53pm

Lol. Good one.

kimdaddy35

12:01am

Props to you on putting your opinion out there and putting some thought into it

cajuncoug

7:26am

The laugh emoji was funny. Made me smile. Well played.

cajuncoug

9:12am

Bosco is a clear #4. For you to even float that Wilson could be higher than he is made me lol.

kimdaddy35

11:28am

You are under valuing 1st team AA and college football HOF/2 things Bosco

stansburycoug

12:15pm

So for you the most important attribute is passing in a time period when no one else was passing?

kimdaddy35

2:15pm

You seem to like to lol. That’s good. Probably healthy.

cajuncoug

12:23pm

In 1985, Wilson was 11-2 as an NFL starter.

AF Cougar

1:02pm

He was awful in 1978.

kimdaddy35

2:16pm

Exactly

Cougrluvr

7:27am

Unrelated, but BYU should bring back those Marc Wilson helmets for a game or two

Cougs'16

6:26am

We did for Washington 2018 or 2019. Home game.

Y05

6:31am

Oh cool, I'd forgotten

Cougs'16

7:06am

Actually, just looked that up and those are not quite the same as the one

Cougs'16

7:08am

Wow. Not sure where that's from, but that's awful

cajuncoug

7:15am

What is an accurate list look like? Here’s my off the top of my head.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

8:02am

Took the day off, so I'll try

cajuncoug

8:30am

Solid.not too far off yours

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9:08am

Quite accurate. I might move Virgil Carter up to 13.

AF Cougar

9:22am

Admittedly, not fair assessment of Shiede/Carter. And totally forgot Doman

cajuncoug

9:34am

I was still pretty young when Virgil was playing but his play changed BYU

AF Cougar

10:08am

Zach was a Jr. in 2020 & left early.

gopman

10:04am

Just recency bias

RGGeemer

9:43am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad