1 Jim McMahon
2 Ty Detmer
3-Steve Young
4-Marc Wilson
5-Robbie Bosco: Won the Natty, so I'll give him the bump over Nielsen. 2-time Heisman finalist, but injuries slowed performance Sr. year
6-Gifford Nielsen: College HoF, consensus All-American
7 Steve Sarkisian: Top passing efficiency winner, Sammy Baugh Trophy, went 31-34 for 399 as a junior and 14-1#5 team as a senior
8 John Beck: At his best, I just think he was slightly better than Hall, Wilson
9-Max Hall: Winningest ever. But it's an elite group vs. whom he's being compared
10-Zach Wilson: Was flat out dealing his senior year. Elite arm talent and great athleticism. Only 1 great year + quality of competition keeps 2nd round NFL draft pick from moving up the ranks
11-Jaren Hall: Had he been healthy more....
12-Taysom Hill: Positive attributes are well-known and amazing. Injuries and what might have been
13-Gary Shiede: May be too low for a Sammy Baugh winner. Admittedly, I just didn't see him play
14-John Walsh: One great season. Terrific arm. Mobility challenges
15-Virgil Carter
16-Kevin Feterik