You can have all the beautiful play design in the world, but if your guys can't execute them, it doesn't matter one bit

Nov 17, 2024
10:11:58pm

jaromp All-American

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 17, 2024 at 10:11:58pm

Message parent changed from https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=34256227 to https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=34253290 by jaromp on Nov 17, 2024 at 10:12:14pm

Report problem with this ad

jaromp

Bio page: jaromp
Joined: May 31, 2012
Last login: Nov 18, 2024
Total posts: 5,376 (171 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Some of you guys are WAY WAY too hard on your offensive coordinator

Medute

Nov 17, 10:39am

Jake was the bigger issue last night

BYUnerd

Nov 17, 10:40am

We’re too hard on our OC? You guys just ran yours out of the program.

BigGulps

Nov 17, 10:41am

Our offense is just so so so bad

Medute

Nov 17, 10:42am

I would agree with you. Arod designs a good offense. My issue is with the

Boring

Nov 17, 9:08pm

We actually have expectations on offense

Dryfire

Nov 17, 10:42am

Right, but the issue is why are those expectations not being met

Medute

Nov 17, 10:44am

The 2 point conversion attempt against Utah was enough to show ARod deserves the

bluecougar1985

Nov 17, 10:47am

How do you explain 2 touchdowns last 2 games.

BYU71

Nov 17, 10:43am

I only watched the first half of last night in details so can't comment

Medute

Nov 17, 10:45am

The fade play was absolutely a bad

BYU71

Nov 17, 10:49am

It’s quite possible they have executed that play very well in practice

Medute

Nov 17, 1:57pm

He did the same thing last week against the Utes. Did you not watch?

Huge Manatee

Nov 17, 2:34pm

I buried that game in the depths of my mind

Medute

Nov 17, 3:04pm

You want to take him back?

foofcoug

Nov 17, 10:43am

I would take him in a heartbeat right now

Medute

Nov 17, 10:45am

Feel free.

foofcoug

Nov 17, 10:48am

Is this some attempt to encourage your rival to keep somebody you know is very

bluecougar1985

Nov 17, 10:45am

Our QB has had two really rough outings. Saturday was bad.

Benfica1

Nov 17, 10:47am

You can't help yourself can you, seriously though, it was about as bi-polar

stansburycoug

Nov 17, 10:56am

He's not wrong.

Benfica1

Nov 17, 10:56am

On your point 1 and point 2

Medute

Nov 17, 11:26am

You dont throw the fade with Retzlaff..he has no touch. Its as bad a call

stansburycoug

Nov 17, 11:37am

I agree with this post. Well designed offense. And most of the issues were with

bob falfa

Nov 17, 11:06am

He is doing it with players who were projected to finish last in conference

Medute

Nov 17, 11:08am

Two things that bother me that have killed us this season:

crazY

Nov 17, 12:58pm

This makes sense. Issue is player execution

Resurgens

Nov 17, 5:42pm

Just look at your recruiting rankings and projections

Medute

Nov 17, 5:53pm

I suspect we will need to start recruiting better to have staying power in the

Resurgens

Nov 17, 5:56pm

Yep. Although I tend to think this conference will be pretty equal in talent

Medute

Nov 17, 6:04pm

The problem with your post, is ARod is also the QB Coach

slatecoug

Nov 17, 6:42pm

But what if Ratzliff isn’t good? Is that ARod’s fault?

Medute

Nov 17, 6:45pm

It's still his fault. He put Jake in positions where Jake has shown he struggles

slatecoug

Nov 17, 6:48pm

Has any coach ever found a way to avoid all bad situations for an average QB?

Medute

Nov 17, 7:08pm

Retzlaff missed terribly on the fade route the week before, so you give him that

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:13pm

I’m no expert but someone said Retzlaff called that play and made the read

Medute

Nov 17, 7:15pm

The play call came in from ARod. It's a play that gives Jake multiple options...

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:24pm

I see. It seems Jake made the wrong read but there is criticism for the player

Medute

Nov 17, 7:28pm

If Retzlaff isnt that good thats doubly ARods fault

stansburycoug

Nov 17, 7:34pm

Recruiting is a fair criticism. But BYU hasn’t let the football team pay the QBs

Medute

Nov 17, 7:46pm

BTW, if you go back and watch the Kansas D, it was almost like they knew what

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:06pm

I wonder if BYU is trying to use too many players. So that when personnel groupings come in it is tipping off what type

Spiff

Nov 17, 7:07pm

I believe that is a big part. I also think BYU needs to do some self scouting.

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:11pm

I do agree with you that ARod is very good at play design, but that is only one

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:15pm

I think he called a nearly perfect first 30 minutes

Medute

Nov 17, 7:19pm

Retzlaff is not calling plays. He's being given a play that has multiple options

slatecoug

Nov 17, 7:25pm

Ok. But he made the wrong read and there was a guy open on that play

Medute

Nov 17, 7:30pm

Yes, Jake did make the wrong read

slatecoug

Nov 17, 8:14pm

I get it. But you can only protect a mediocre player so much

Medute

Nov 17, 8:37pm

I agree with some of that, but when you are the guy responsible for recruiting &

slatecoug

Nov 17, 10:23pm

Thanks for taking a break from running the Big 12 to tell us

byuTX

Nov 17, 8:18pm

Gotta watch something other than our dumpster fire

Medute

Nov 17, 10:27pm

Appreciate the insights and kind words. Thank you!

ColonelMustard

Nov 17, 9:21pm

You can have all the beautiful play design in the world, but if your guys can't execute them, it doesn't matter one bit

jaromp

Nov 17, 10:11pm

Right. But perhaps it’s just a matter of who gets the blame

Posting on CougarBoard