RE: Rewatching the game it really stands out

Report problem with this ad

Nov 14, 2024
10:19:11am

OPINIONS I just love BYU so much

Report problem with this ad

OPINIONS

Previous username: sheriffcreg
Bio page: OPINIONS
Joined: Aug 25, 2011
Last login: Nov 14, 2024
Total posts: 22,947 (7,710 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Lisfranc surgery for Rose

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

9:00am

Well that helps explain some things

Akilleez

9:00am

Why not just put Wilson in?

2FarGone

9:01am

Amazed Wilson didn't enter the portal on Monday.

Hawk in the 303

9:05am

why? now he has three games to try and prove himself... if he thinks they'll go back to Rose, he can bail after the

ChinaFan

12:14pm

Apparently their 3rd/4th string QB with a busted foot was a better option

BYU Fan

9:11am

He had a few good throws so they thought he was better

Bobmarleyjr

10:37am

Because he's not healthy either. Is my guess.

byubyu

9:19am

That's trying to put lipstick on a pig. You'll see Saturday. He is fine.

2FarGone

9:22am

Exactly. If they were so close to even, rose can’t be better injured.

Boring

9:23am

That situation alone should push Isaac to enter transfer portal.

CT98

11:32am

Very responsible of KWhitt to drug him up and keep marching him out there.

BIG XII Coug

9:01am

Seriously wonder how he continues to do this kind of stuff.

O Gaucho

9:05am

To be fair, we did the same thing with Taysom. He tried to tough it out that

allaboutthegainz

9:08am

And to be further fair, we got rid of all those coaches the next year

rcbyufan

9:14am

Did they replace the ortho covering the game that injected him and sent him back

cowbellcoug

10:39am

This! And then Taysom had to have his midfoot joints fused the following week.

cowbellcoug

10:39am

Is it possible to cause further damage?

whoneedscorners?

10:45am

It absolutely would predictably cause further damage. That's why he had to have

cowbellcoug

10:56am

Very much depends on the extent of the initial injury

StantonMac

11:33am

However you classify the initial Lis Frac injury, play a violent sport on it for

cowbellcoug

12:24pm

It’s possible to cause more damage. Just depends on the severity of the injury &

LakeshowCougs

11:07am

It's what we did with Taysom. He was injured early 2nd quarter, finished the qtr

Ghost of Peanut

9:55am

How on the Lord's green earth does this program keep getting QBs?!

Iki_Balam

2:06pm

I assumed it was in the 2nd Q. He was limping pretty bad in 2nd Q

JoeExotic

9:01am

Holy cow. No wonder he stunk so bad in the 2nd half. Why didn't

FrankenCoug

9:02am

Whittingham to offensive skill position players:

d-coug

9:02am

RE: Whittingham to offensive skill position players:

EEcougar

9:09am

RE: Whittingham to offensive skill position players:

Powerbait DPM

10:31am

I am now almost positive their RB played with a concussion, what a cesspool

Big12Yfan

9:03am

He definitely looked concussed

Iman23

9:05am

It definitely makes you wonder - I thought for sure Bernard was done

BYU Fan

9:09am

He walked to the wrong sideline once after a play. Took about 5 or 6 steps that

byubyu

9:21am

Yup, he slammed the side of his head to the turf. Helmets are designed to absorb

ChiCityCoug

9:42am

100%

IGlowInTheDark

10:09am

Shoot em up and push him back out on the field. Not a great look for Whitt or the Utah program.

WDaddy

9:03am

Meh. Taysom played through his too. Rose is a competitor. #respect

Lalau

9:06am

Taysom didn't try to play the second half against Nebraska with a Lisfranc. It's

osbooks

9:09am

He tried to play again in the second quarter after the injury.

Marvelous

9:40am

The doctor at the game told Taysom that playing wouldn't make it any worse, so

bluescholar

10:14am

We did the same thing with both Taysom and Riley Nelson...

cougarBee

9:13am

Taysom didn't play the 2nd half against Nebraska with that injury. We didn't do the same thing.

spugeddy24

9:16am

I'm pretty sure he played into the 3rd and possibly even briefly in the 4th.

byubyu

9:44am

Mangum came in with 12 minutes left in the 4th.

molodyets

9:58am

Wrong. Hill played almost a whole quarter before Mangum came in.

Virginia Ute

10:07am

There’s a reason they have medical staff on the sidelines. Keep kids from making dumb decisions with long term

WDaddy

9:27am

False narrative. Taysom or medical staff didn't even try to play 2nd half

osbooks

9:30am

Yes he did. Magnum didn't replace him until the 4th.

byubyu

9:44am

Yup, it wan't until BYU got the ball with about 12 minutes left in the 4th

Ungoy

9:58am

Yep. Taysom played the first four series of the 2nd half.

byuTX

10:00am

I stand corrected. I just went back and watched snap to tackle for the game and

osbooks

10:11am

FWIW I didn't remember him playing in the 3rd either. I think he tore it doing that dumb stomping motion as he scored

byuTX

10:29am

Taysom tore it as he planted to escape the pocket on that run

StantonMac

10:57am

Hopefully

byuTX

11:33am

That’s twice they have kept a player in with a season ending injury instead of

cougaman

9:06am

Whitt's confidence level in Wilson displayed in stock prices:

Ungoy

10:06am

I think it happened when he was over celebrating his TD.

kotacoug

9:06am

My thought too on hearing of his injury. It would be interesting to see if the

ledfoot

10:04am

If I was a ute fan I'd be pissed about this. Whitt kept him in through an entire

delux_247

9:06am

Players sometimes insist on playing.

RoboKayne

12:23pm

And that is why there is a grown adult man with more perspective on the sidelines that's supposed to tell him that he

Black Diamond Bay

12:42pm

Children sometimes demand candy.

Brandoblueblood

4:24pm

I have every confidence Kalani would never do that.

YSMACK

9:08am

KWhitt

acougfan

9:16am

Here's the rest of the cut off part: "...forced to play in such a condition, but that's Kyle for you"

byuTX

9:18am

Great, another excuse for that fanbase.

coug10278

9:22am

This is either hilarious ute lore or extreme malpractice, one or the other.

Brandoblueblood

9:22am

Cuz he's Kryalz personal "Un Doctor". He should be sued for malpractice.

ledfoot

10:07am

Rewatching the game it really stands out

buckeyecougarguy

9:31am

I would have been like him I think. That’s a hugely exciting moment.

Dr MoBYU

9:41am

Yeah if you celebrate a touchdown you deserve your season ending injury. What a fun take!

Virginia Ute

10:12am

I didn’t want him to get a season ending injury. I wanted him to lose. I also

buckeyecougarguy

11:10am

lol his attitude was the main reason why the first half went as well as it did. Strong disagree there.

Virginia Ute

11:19am

Exactly. I wish I had seen more of that from our team.

Christopsomo

12:29pm

I think his play definitely ignited the team. But a little more emotional

buckeyecougarguy

2:21pm

He got hurt at the end of the first half. Otherwise lol at the rest of your post.

Virginia Ute

3:42pm

You really don’t think your team and coach and AD got overly emotional?

buckeyecougarguy

4:15pm

We are talking about Rose here.

Virginia Ute

4:20pm

Kid gets his break after years of work. Makes some big plays. Let him get fired up. This is football.

Longhaul

11:57am

From my view it was weird. Just my opinion. I’m all for being fired up and

buckeyecougarguy

2:40pm

Also, he literally hadn't been there before. Wasn't this his first career start?

RoboKayne

12:21pm

1st start and 1st real playing time for the team.

dut99002

12:23pm

RE: Rewatching the game it really stands out

OPINIONS

10:19am

No sympathy, just a hope that it humbles him!? Lame!

GoodBetterBestBYU

11:33am

You must have missed it.

buckeyecougarguy

4:14pm

Didn’t let it bother me. Feel bad for the kid. Our guys get chippy sometimes too.

GoodBetterBestBYU

5:33pm

RE: Rewatching the game it really stands out

IGlowInTheDark

4:06pm

I noticed him limping near the end of the half.

kansascougar

9:42am

Tells you how much they like Wilson...yikes. Kid has to want to transfer now

vabeachcoug

10:08am

Wow, that's nuts. What does that say about what Whit thinks about Wilson?

SausageKing

10:08am

Honestly, if the Doctor says playing won't make the injury worse, and player can stand the pain, let him play.

JayOwen

10:14am

This is how you start a pain killer pill addition.

Iki_Balam

2:08pm

And really,what is the sum of these types of actions?

RoaroftheCougartails

3:37pm

Wish him the best.

OldFogey

10:29am

he seemed to have been crying at the post-game press conference. Understandable

oilman

10:30am

I applaud the kid for toughing it out to the best of his abilities. What is odd

Bluedarts

10:34am

Lost in all this is the fact that players typically WANT to play through injury

reddead

10:50am

It’d be cool if Taysom reached out to him to encourage him. The rivalry needs

Q-grr

11:02am

I call victimy, legend-making-wannabe BS on this story.

Brandoblueblood

11:11am

He was clearly limping during the game. So he’s going to have surgery and miss

cougaman

11:14am

Then why would Whittingham play him when he has a healthy QB2?

Brandoblueblood

12:18pm

He did the same with Rising. I don’t know why he played him over Wilson. The

cougaman

12:21pm

Many reports that lil' Wilson has been injured for weeks.

NYC and Japan

12:25pm

Many BYU fans in the comments pulling for him. Love this.

SaturdaySpecialDay

11:15am

This is how we should be! Kid was such a competitor and almost turned their season around. Glad he didn’t. Sad for him.

GoodBetterBestBYU

11:35am

Takes some toughness, hope he wasn't pushed to do it by Utah

Projectoor

11:32am

Why would any QB consider ever playing for Whittingham?

Pangare

12:43pm

There are so many misinformed posts in this thread

Medute

4:14pm

I think you mean it's their call to "clear" them to go back in, but...

Brandoblueblood

4:30pm

I mean, I watched the game. He was clearly able to walk and jog with a limp

Medute

4:59pm

Good write-up. Also, Taysom Hill continued to play in the Nebraska game...

oilman

4:40pm

Precisely

Posting on CougarBoard