"Rookie QB's are successful pretty much every year" is your

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 8, 2024
12:00:34pm

gopman All-American

"Rookie QB's are successful pretty much every year" is your

argument. 50 years of NFL history says otherwise.

Report problem with this ad

gopman

Bio page: gopman
Joined: Feb 15, 2006
Last login: Oct 8, 2024
Total posts: 3,708 (16 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The way Saleh handled the Mike White situation with the locker room

maYbe

10:55am

100%. The dude is clueless

10:59am

He listened to the media way too much.

11:01am

Yep, Zach would not have been benched last year if not for the media. Saleh

Gente_Boa

11:31am

Rookie defensive HC. Rookie OC. QB coach dies in preseason. Overrated Oline with

Forzaitalia

11:02am

It's rare for a rookie to be successful with a good team around them much less likely w/ a dumpster fire.

Soupie

11:04am

No it isn’t. Rookie QBs are successful pretty much every year

11:06am

On teams with the top to bottom issues the Jets have had for years? Not really. Look at the QBs run off from Jets

Soupie

11:17am

The Texans, Bears, Commanders, and Bengals all come to mind immediately

11:22am

If you ignore the previous rookie QBs they started prior to now

Indy Coug

11:26am

Ok, so you’re saying previous rookie QBs didn’t work out, but later a different rookie QB worked out

11:30am

That's four teams out of 32. The last 50 years of NFL history

gopman

11:27am

How many teams have historical "top to bottom issues?" Certainly not 32.

rtNelson

11:41am

I gave four obvious examples. But you’re still wrong. First, not all 32 teams have these dysfunctional franchises like

11:50am

"Rookie QB's are successful pretty much every year" is your

gopman

12:00pm

Not when you actually look at the history. There’s a successful rookie QB most years, and when there isn’t, it’s usually

12:09pm

The bigger issue is rookie defensive HC, rookie OC, dead/no QB coach. Which

Forzaitalia

12:19pm

I agree with you, but I also think that those issues can also be overcome

12:29pm

I think we do mostly agree. With Rogers' current struggles as evidence, I doubt

Forzaitalia

12:40pm

See, I don’t think Rodgers’ struggles are really indicative one way or the other

1:43pm

Bo Nix is looking better as well. Denver has been a dumpster fire for years.

rtNelson

11:42am

He has Sean Payton, and a decent Oline, which are big pluses.

Forzaitalia

12:21pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad