They came out of their huddle and declared the official ruling on the field to be “TD” before the review started. No one

Sep 23, 2024
6:38:44pm

mvtoro Scrub

else was in the huddle where it happened. Who knows what was said?

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 23, 2024 at 6:38:44pm

Message modified by mvtoro on Sep 23, 2024 at 6:38:58pm

Report problem with this ad

mvtoro

Bio page: mvtoro
Joined: Nov 28, 2006
Last login: Sep 23, 2024
Total posts: 12,716 (803 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Still no explanation for that terrible review that gave KSU 3 points.

The Y's Insider

12:48pm

There was not a good video angle of where the ball was when his toe hit the sideline...

Coug

12:50pm

There were 2 angles that showed his foot on the line and the ball at ~ the 1/2

The Y's Insider

12:52pm

ESPN showed a very clear angle. Both commentators were shocked at the ruling

Saxa

12:52pm

Huh? They had the angle right on the goalline

The Dark Knight

12:54pm

This was the smaller problem. It was clear when his foot touched down that the ball was short. (You can use info from 2

mvtoro

12:56pm

Like this one?

fldnstrm

1:00pm

Looks like the shadow of the ball is clearly in the endzone. Touchdown!

JAGA97

1:02pm

Video replay of the refs on Saturday night:

Doogal McCougar

1:02pm

Yes, precisely like that one. Too bad no such picture exists.

Jacksonian76

3:14pm

I don't think that's crux of question. When was the TD called? If not called the

sah22

7:35pm

Regardless there was no call of a TD on the field. They made that up out of

VACOUGFAN

8:04pm

The crew from the 2005 TCU game made an appearance

Indy Coug

12:52pm

I was late for a date and in a bad mood because of that. Thanks for the reminder

BlueTroop

3:10pm

That was the first season of ByU football that I followed. That loss hurt bad

CougarEat

3:54pm

It’s the “stands” vs “confirmed”. Call on the field was apparently going to stand either way. But WHY did they

mvtoro

12:53pm

The change to the on the field call is what I don't understand

The Dark Knight

12:55pm

This is where it bugs me. If there’s no video review coming I doubt any ref has the balls to huddle and override the guy

mvtoro

1:00pm

Both

SoBlueitHurts

2:55pm

The only explanation that makes sense in my mind is that the official mis-spoke.

Mufasa

12:55pm

No. They actually called it a TD LONG after the play and while huddled.

The Y's Insider

12:57pm

Ah... I missed that part.

Mufasa

12:58pm

1) No. They announced TD as ruling on the field. 2) No way that video “overturns” a call that he stepped out.

mvtoro

12:57pm

Why? He was very clearly short

BYU '80

5:09pm

So if the official call on the field had been that he stepped out, there’s no way that video would have overturned it.

mvtoro

6:25pm

Maybe they were confused on the standard to overturn the call. They thought they needed something clearer

Bob Vance

1:01pm

The more egregious error IMO was overriding (in huddle) the call of the ref who was closest to the play. I don’t think

mvtoro

1:04pm

I’m not sure us getting the ball at the 1/2 yard line would have been the best outcome.

SpecialT

1:11pm

??? A turnover on downs at the 1/2 yard line is definitely better than giving up a field goal. I know there is risk of

mvtoro

1:16pm

The refs are allowed to huddle, ask each other if another had a better angle or

Corn Pop

1:17pm

The line judge right at the play showed us all his call with his signal. Whoever in the huddle overruled or convinced

mvtoro

1:21pm

I'm never a fan of a far away ref/ump overruling the closer one to the play, but

Corn Pop

1:26pm

I am never a fan of any ref overturning a call that hurts BYU...ever.

Pangare

2:19pm

Maybe the ref who called him out of bounds had 2nd thoughts in the huddle

BYUCLA

6:04pm

Shouldn't they have signaled that it was aTD then?

Great38

6:35pm

Does it matter? They huddled, discussed everything that happened on the play,

Corn Pop

6:49pm

I need the hands up. Haha.

Great38

8:16pm

If the call on the field had been, "out of bounds at the 1/2 yd line",

PacificNW

3:52pm

...and that WAS the call of the line judge at the spot.

The Dark Knight

4:15pm

Confirmed...terrible review.

PacificNW

4:44pm

Yeah, that was the call on the field and the video apparently wasn't

Great38

6:39pm

Bizarre is what was, he stepped out of bounds

Weagle Coug

5:41pm

Point #2 !!

Great38

6:33pm

They came out of their huddle and declared the official ruling on the field to be “TD” before the review started. No one

mvtoro

6:38pm

They announced that before the video review?

Great38

6:40pm

Yes. I always listen for it because of situations like this. Before any review they’ll declare what the offical “call on

mvtoro

6:46pm

I guess that makes sense. But I've seen refs signal a TD very late so I expected

Great38

8:19pm

They may have and we just didn’t see video of it, but I think it was not called a TD before they huddled together. The

mvtoro

8:40pm

Should been 38-6. We just couldn’t catch a break that game

Cooouuugs

7:48pm

If we performed like that in our jobs, we wouldn’t have jobs

44C

8:12pm

The touchdown was so that Avery could donate to his high school principal's care

Posting on CougarBoard