Yeah, I don't see the point OP is trying to make. Not supported by facts.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 14, 2021
4:58:31pm

Fargo Walk-on

Yeah, I don't see the point OP is trying to make. Not supported by facts.

Report problem with this ad

Fargo

Bio page: Fargo
Joined: Dec 13, 2020
Last login: Apr 12, 2021
Total posts: 1,040 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The state of UT is kind of an outlier when it comes to D1 football schools.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:12pm

Why are you calling programs like Nevada, Southern Miss, or Arkansas St 'Fake'?

ZacSeljaas'Stache

1/14/21 2:16pm

I'm calling USU fake

Indy Coug

1/14/21 2:17pm

I'm calling you fake

Sea Chicken

1/14/21 2:17pm

You’re not real

gmoney7

1/14/21 2:18pm

He finally admits Indy’s his dupe!

Odysseus

1/14/21 2:19pm

I love Aggie Ice Cream

BYU Grounds

1/14/21 4:07pm

Because I choose to call them fake. Call them what you want, but they are not

Mitty

1/14/21 2:39pm

Then why does Utah State count as a 'real' one?

ZacSeljaas'Stache

1/14/21 2:46pm

I don't understand the question. By the definition, they qualify as NOT fake.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:50pm

When has USU been in the same conference with BYU, Utah, or Colorado?

El Jefe

1/14/21 4:23pm

Change your definition to “10+ years in D1” and run the numbers. And be honest

StalwartBraveTrue

1/14/21 4:49pm

USU football is worse than Nevada. Your formula is as biased towards USU as the CFP was to Iowa St.

unctoothman

1/14/21 5:11pm

Fake D1 schools?

Sea Chicken

1/14/21 2:16pm

Utah produces an oddly high number of D1 recruits because all the schools have

BYUMizzou

1/14/21 2:20pm

That’s an interesting point. Never thought about it that way.

TADOW

1/14/21 2:23pm

You need to take a better look at who these schools recruits..

TheLost

1/14/21 2:36pm

The other thing that will have a big effect is how school districts are handled

BYUMizzou

1/14/21 2:41pm

That's a good point that probably accounts for a percentage of the discrepancy.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:45pm

Where is the evidence to support utah having a high % of D1 recruits?

Fargo

1/14/21 5:00pm

Here is the map showing Utahs number of recruits.

TheLost

1/14/21 2:21pm

How is Montana up that far?

lightmann

1/14/21 2:38pm

A few surprising things on this map, to me.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:47pm

You can thank the Polynesians for that, sure as heck ain’t the Caucasian kids.

1/14/21 4:26pm

<< Deleted >>

Odysseus

1/14/21 7:19pm

Lots of babies being born in Utah. More babies = more athletes.

zsmooth

1/14/21 2:32pm

CO has three D1 schools

ColoSpgs

1/14/21 2:36pm

Good point, I wasn't sure about AFA. Initially had considered them

Mitty

1/14/21 2:40pm

& 80% more population. That's the whole point.

RdF3

1/14/21 2:41pm

AZ also has three

TheLost

1/14/21 2:41pm

Per Wikipedia, just two.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:43pm

Weird.. since i've toured NAU's facilities. Somebody needs to tell the Big Sky.

TheLost

1/14/21 2:47pm

NAU is D1 but not FBS, original post was about FBS teams only

ZacSeljaas'Stache

1/14/21 2:48pm

He mentions FBS once.. He says 'Fake D1' (traditionally D2)

TheLost

1/14/21 2:51pm

Tell them what? You don't think they know they are 1-AA or whatever it's called?

Mitty

1/14/21 2:51pm

They are D1.. Maybe you want to change your rankings to P5 or not-P5.

TheLost

1/14/21 3:01pm

<< Deleted >>

RdF3

1/14/21 3:04pm

Read his posts.. what would be his Fake D1 then? What is traditional D2..

TheLost

1/14/21 3:08pm

If USU gets +1, so do Nevada, Southern Miss, Arkansas State, W. Kentucky...

Doogal McCougar

1/14/21 2:45pm

No, those are traditionally D2 and 1-AA AKA pre-FCS schools. That's why.

Mitty

1/14/21 2:54pm

So Nevada.. who beat a P5 Big10 team last year (2019)... is D2? OK..

TheLost

1/14/21 3:00pm

Pretty sure at least Nevada and Southern Miss are USU's equals or better.

Doogal McCougar

1/14/21 3:07pm

Being from Utah, Mitty naturally hears more about USU than Nevada/Southern Miss

krindorr

1/14/21 4:29pm

What school in NV earns your .5?

TheLost

1/14/21 2:45pm

Nevada & UNLV both get .25

BYU Fan

1/14/21 2:57pm

It would have to be .75.. since he gave NV 1.5

TheLost

1/14/21 2:58pm

Louisiana has 5 with a population of 4.65M, NC has 7 with population of 10M

AggieWeekendCougar

1/14/21 2:46pm

But OP will tell some of those are "fake," so he can make his point...

The Chelsea Dagger

1/14/21 4:31pm

Yeah, I don't see the point OP is trying to make. Not supported by facts.

Fargo

1/14/21 4:58pm

#7 in FBS/population

krindorr

1/14/21 3:26pm

Kindof sad that the only person presenting real data isn't getting thumbs up

AggieWeekendCougar

1/14/21 5:01pm

Similar to Air Force, did you leave BYU out of Utah because it is part of a

Bullrider

1/14/21 4:05pm

I think most people would only give USU .5; fans of P5 schools would probably

Fargo

1/14/21 4:56pm

Living in the Southeast, this is unfortunately absolutely true

krindorr

1/14/21 6:30pm

I'd imagine the state of Utah's prominence will continue to rise due to birth rt

Orem58thBall

1/14/21 5:59pm

<< Deleted >>

TrueBlue1

1/14/21 6:34pm

Would someone please redo this post with actual designations? It might be

1/14/21 7:04pm

See above - link included

krindorr

1/14/21 7:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad