Each player is required to return the ball without touching the net with racket or body. Point goes to Iga Swiatek.

Report problem with this ad

Jan 5, 2025
10:42:09pm

Crowgar All-American

Report problem with this ad

Crowgar

Bio page: Crowgar
Joined: Sep 10, 2001
Last login: Jan 8, 2025
Total posts: 13,502 (53 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

ASU got robbed

Heinz57

Jan 5, 9:47pm

RE: ASU got robbed

rainorsnow

Jan 5, 9:48pm

Not sure if you’re serious, but that isn’t the rule.

RalphWiggam

Jan 5, 9:49pm

It's ridiculous. The vid cites the correct NCAA rule, but applies it wrong

reddead

Jan 6, 9:11am

RE: ASU got robbed

Longseason

Jan 5, 9:49pm

RE: ASU got robbed

Fatalplacebo

Jan 5, 9:50pm

thats the worst voice over I've ever heard

Deleted

Jan 5, 9:50pm

RE: ASU got robbed

ATX

Jan 5, 9:51pm

Heinz clearly knows football

Sid Vicious

Jan 5, 9:53pm

*Ketchup. Heinz clearly knows Ketchup

ATX

Jan 5, 9:56pm

They're pretty much the same thing. If you know one, you know the other.

squidmark

Jan 6, 6:28am

RE: ASU got robbed

Nikomedes

Jan 5, 9:53pm

ASUDGR

machete

Jan 5, 10:04pm

It hit the ground. Play is dead the second that happens just like a forward pass.

Soupie

Jan 5, 10:04pm

How would you k ow? U ever ref a game? The FG should have counted

Forbidden Fruit

Jan 5, 10:40pm

Also not true.

shimmy

Jan 6, 12:31am

Field goals are live balls until they leave the field of play. If tipped or

morningcalmcougar

Jan 6, 8:35am

Okay, I might see that (yes was Auburn but didn't touch ground there) but don't think the FG counts. It would

Soupie

Jan 6, 8:51am

Just did some quick research. Looks like the rules say this is NOT a field goal

morningcalmcougar

Jan 6, 9:04am

Take that Mr Shimmy! 🙂

Soupie

Jan 6, 9:20am

Wait, do you think this makes your post correct?

shimmy

Jan 6, 9:21am

How does it not? Play is dead part is wrong but fact it can't be a FG is right.

Soupie

Jan 6, 9:32am

Doesn’t apply if it’s behind the line of scrimmage

Fatalplacebo

Jan 6, 9:38am

Correction. You said the play is dead once it hit the ground. A blocked FG

Fatalplacebo

Jan 6, 9:47am

Can be recovered by the kicking team only if touched by the blocking team beyond the LOS.

shimmy

Jan 6, 9:55am

Of course it can’t be a FG. Thinking it could be a FG after a bounce is idiotic.

shimmy

Jan 6, 9:41am

That's what was suggested though & I said couldn't be once it touched ground.

Soupie

Jan 6, 9:47am

You said dead ball. The kick is no longer good for a FG because it touched the

Fatalplacebo

Jan 6, 9:49am

You also said it was dead just like an incomplete pass, which is way off and you’ve already acknowledged that. After you

shimmy

Jan 6, 9:54am

Maybe if you explained which part was wrong & which was right but response made it sound like you

Soupie

Jan 6, 9:56am

I couldn’t see into the future where you parsed your wrong post into 2 distinct points, 1 of which was blatantly

shimmy

Jan 6, 10:20am

There's also the 🙂 on my "dunk" showing far more light hearted nature than you seem to be reading

Soupie

Jan 6, 10:42am

If that was the intent of the smiley face it was totally lost on my and this whole interaction is to my shame

shimmy

Jan 6, 11:42am

Well if you can't guess the future, that's on you

byuTX

Jan 6, 12:01pm

So if you just ignore the actual words of your post, you were right.

russkiejedi

Jan 6, 12:07pm

Except the part abt it not being a FG bc it hit the ground. Just the dead play part.

Soupie

Jan 6, 12:14pm

RE: ASU got robbed

CougarGuy84

Jan 5, 10:11pm

RE: ASU got robbed

WJCougar

Jan 5, 10:14pm

Check this out. In tennis, what should be the ruling here…

Crowgar

Jan 5, 10:14pm

Wow! Nobody knows?

Crowgar

Jan 5, 10:33pm

Each player is required to return the ball without touching the net with racket or body. Point goes to Iga Swiatek.

Crowgar

Jan 5, 10:42pm

Correct. And this is the only instance you can reach over net and contact ball.

zerome4sooners

Jan 6, 6:10am

This is not nearly as unusual

Darthcookies

Jan 6, 12:43am

Most of the time they can return the ball if they’re quick enough. It is much more uncommon to see an unreturnable ball

Crowgar

Jan 6, 2:55am

It happens in pickleball a lot too. I've had it happen to me

jellyfish

Jan 6, 10:00am

My goodness, it's like people can't read. The rules are clear, no pts, no good

reddead

Jan 6, 8:59am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad