Bad example. Florida State hadn't beaten anyone. We beat ACC undefeated

Report problem with this ad

Dec 1, 2024
12:23:38pm

Threw and Through 3rd String

SMU and two 8-win Big 12 teams.

Report problem with this ad

Threw and Through

Bio page: Threw and Through
Joined: Aug 2, 2002
Last login: Dec 28, 2024
Total posts: 357 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

CFP committee makes my blood boil. Here’s the thing. I get it that BYU

Lefty24

Dec 1, 3:49am

Ranking Tulane higher last week is the biggest joke.

Yukon

Dec 1, 5:17am

No, ranking 3-loss Alabama coming off of a 24-3 loss to OU #13 was the biggest.

dYrtbYkerYder

Dec 1, 6:27am

EXACTLY

Lefty24

Dec 1, 8:03am

Oh man that one was annoying. If Miami is any higher than 15 this week that

gww687

Dec 1, 1:29pm

They will be.

chitownboy

Dec 1, 3:09pm

I know, and that is utter nonsense

gww687

Dec 1, 5:04pm

Yeah. . . BYU is not playing great football right now. . . CFP rankings are fine

Zoobieman

Dec 1, 7:01am

Both are true. CFP is a joke.

LateToTheGame

Dec 1, 1:37pm

Signed, Oregon scraping past Wisconsin by 3 points. 16-13.

MarylandFan

Dec 1, 2:58pm

We don’t pass the eye test. If we blow out Houston and AZ St blows out Iowa st maby the committee thinks twice but they

KYU

Dec 1, 7:06am

Which is the point. It’s not okay to accept the committee’s biased agenda of

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:35pm

Re:it’s not okay to accept the biased committees agenda

KYU

Dec 1, 1:08pm

Anyone who saw that game last night can see we don’t belong in the CFP. It would

WillsPitStop

Dec 1, 7:13am

The “eye test” fails a lot of teams, though.

Yukon

Dec 1, 7:17am

The eye test has failed Iowa State for 5 games in a row now

andrewg3

Dec 1, 10:25am

100% agree

Lefty24

Dec 1, 1:53pm

Anyone who watches college football knows that there are few dominant teams.

dYrtbYkerYder

Dec 1, 7:48am

And byu beat one of those teams SMU

Julius Pepperwood

Dec 1, 1:12pm

With that logic anybody watching Georgia in OT would say they don’t look like

boorad

Dec 1, 1:47pm

We only beat one ranked team and lost to unranked teams, slipping by bad teams

Adzo

Dec 1, 1:51pm

We beat Kansas st when they were ranked high. Miami hasn’t beat any ranked teams

chitownboy

Dec 1, 3:21pm

<< Deleted >>

chitownboy

Dec 1, 5:00pm

Do you watch all top 15 teams each week to confirm that bias?

BYUHgrad

Dec 1, 3:19pm

It’s like in MMA don’t leave it to the judges. Just win

Kolobrdm

Dec 1, 7:34am

Very true. And yet the guys who say this often savage the judges

cajuncoug

Dec 1, 8:46am

That’s nice, but why do we have to accept corrupt judges?

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:36pm

Big 12 was already weaker than Big 10 and SEC by any objective standard

Goliath

Dec 1, 7:41am

I agree, but it seems this is just a new form of the BCS. Same people, same

Blue chunks

Dec 1, 8:05am

Here’s an objective standard

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 8:24am

Lol no

Goliath

Dec 1, 8:32am

So what “objective standard” are you referring to?

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 8:34am

For starters, you can look at postseason play

Goliath

Dec 1, 8:50am

This will be the new crap narrative. The SEC will have 4x the chances of the

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:39pm

So wait, your “objective measure” is past postseason success?

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 2:12pm

"different era?" How did you decide to invent that nonsense?

Goliath

Dec 1, 2:32pm

NIL has changed things in college football.

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 4:50pm

Another conference finally wins a NC and it's suddenly a "new era"

Goliath

Dec 1, 4:56pm

What are Bama and Georgia ranked this year?

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 5:44pm

What is Texas ranked?

Goliath

Dec 1, 5:57pm

👍 if you can’t yet see that things are shifting, you will in a few more years

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 6:23pm

I know y'all are hoping for it desperately

Goliath

Dec 1, 6:44pm

Are you actually here repping Georgia after Friday night?

MarylandFan

Dec 1, 6:47pm

We are not up to standard. It's definitely a down year

Goliath

Dec 1, 6:51pm

Chortle.

MarylandFan

Dec 1, 6:54pm

If that's an objective standard, then we're not in the Top 25 and shouldn't be considered

krindorr

Dec 1, 8:49am

It’s one data point. I didn’t say it’s the gold standard.

CPAcoug87

Dec 1, 2:13pm

Winning playoff games is the key. That was the pac 12's problem. They talked

HonestTakes

Dec 1, 8:45am

“Winning playoff games” where we will be out represented 4 to 1.

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:41pm

You're right but if the team that represents the Big12 loses it's only game they

HonestTakes

Dec 1, 2:18pm

And if two of the SEC teams get beat first round, but one makes a run then we

ray ray

Dec 1, 2:25pm

Get all the B12 teams to schedule the weak teams in those two conferences.

ImuaKahuku

Dec 1, 8:17am

The "eye test" garbage is maddening. Just call it what it is: "Your bias"

cajuncoug

Dec 1, 8:46am

Last year a lot of us seemed to think it was OK when Florida St was dropped

krindorr

Dec 1, 8:47am

Bad example. Florida State hadn't beaten anyone. We beat ACC undefeated

Threw and Through

Dec 1, 12:23pm

They beat a 9 win LSU and 8 win Clemson... And more importantly they didn't lose to anyone

krindorr

Dec 1, 1:01pm

Bro, BYU hasn’t earned respect yet.

SoggyBB

Dec 1, 8:55am

The Indiana Hoosiers, OTOH, have proven themselves over the last 5-8 years…

Yukon

Dec 1, 10:24am

Nope but they play in the.

SoggyBB

Dec 1, 8:36pm

Nope, but they play in the BIG10, which has history.

SoggyBB

Dec 1, 8:39pm

This viewpoint is the problem (and that’s not an attack on you). That we have to

Lefty24

Dec 1, 1:00pm

Bro than neither are 3-5 ranked in the top 12 with all their good losses😂

Beetdiggercoug

Dec 1, 2:28pm

BYU isn't getting in. They blew it late season. Plus when has a commitee ever

SoValleyCOUG

Dec 1, 8:58am

That’s what I’m trying to get rid of. There should be no “favoring” at all

Lefty24

Dec 1, 1:04pm

But there is. You have biased humans making the decisions.

SoValleyCOUG

Dec 1, 2:04pm

Agreed. I don’t like it

Lefty24

Dec 1, 6:33pm

The sooner we all accept the CFP Committee's true agenda

RICoug

Dec 1, 9:03am

This is spot on.

KYU

Dec 1, 9:15am

Yes, I agree. It's not about the CFP folks using "mental hoops," and never has

jaba166

Dec 1, 2:26pm

Or the other conferences could decide to stop getting steamrolled by the SEC

Goliath

Dec 1, 9:24am

Other conferences need to adopt the 8 game conference play and the fcs team at

here's to hoping

Dec 1, 10:19am

The reason that happened is that the SEC rigged the system so any player who

BaseCoug

Dec 1, 11:33am

When do the other conferences get a chance? Not that often

ColonelMustard

Dec 1, 11:40am

You of all people should know how far the SEC has fallen this year

TigerTrack

Dec 1, 7:12pm

And don't get me wrong, it's not just the SEC

TigerTrack

Dec 1, 7:13pm

But this is exactly what frustrates me. I understand it, and it irritates me.

here's to hoping

Dec 1, 10:14am

Bro I feel you....

RICoug

Dec 1, 10:24am

Exactly

TNT

Dec 1, 12:05pm

I’ve accepted this, and yet not only does it make me unhappier, it builds hatred

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:45pm

Notre Dame ranked as high as they are defies all logic. They have played NOBODY

ColonelMustard

Dec 1, 11:35am

The CFP has decided college football is now a P2 (+ND & Clem & potentially 1 other ACC team) and their responsibility is

Spiff

Dec 1, 11:41am

I am amazed you think BYU is a really good team. Our team is average atm.

OGSuperfan

Dec 1, 11:47am

This truly isn’t about BYU, it’s about the Big 12 and college football

ray ray

Dec 1, 12:49pm

Didn’t say that at all.. my fight is not for byu but against the bias here:

Lefty24

Dec 1, 1:09pm

The cfp representatives at BYU have were wearing jackets from big10. Yeah, I

viper

Dec 1, 12:59pm

The new CFP poll hasn't even come out yet...are we just being pre-mad here?

MaximusMeridius

Dec 1, 2:04pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad