Actually, just looked that up and those are not quite the same as the one

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 27, 2024
7:08:40am

Cougs'16 All-American

Actually, just looked that up and those are not quite the same as the one

Marc Wilson is wearing in the OP. Those were like a block Y, whereas Wilson's is the stretch Y.

Report problem with this ad

Cougs'16

Previous username: currentbyustudent
Bio page: Cougs'16
Joined: Jun 25, 2015
Last login: Nov 27, 2024
Total posts: 2,103 (6 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

This thread is one of the worst ratings of BYU QBs that I’ve seen

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 9:53pm

Those 2 have more NFL starts than all other BYU QB's minus Steve Young probably

g$

Nov 26, 10:02pm

Does Taysom Hill count as a QB?

Mikey

Nov 26, 10:07pm

Yes, and I think he is better than #11

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 10:10pm

Hill at 11 might be high. He is a great player, was not a great QB

kimdaddy35

Nov 26, 10:53pm

As a football player, yes. As a QB, no.

LakeshowCougs

8:14am

LOL BYU has 4 QBs in the college HOF. 2 of them didnt crack the top 12

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:10pm

Which ones were Heisman finalists? Detmer (won), Young & McMahon. Any others?

Nov 26, 10:19pm

Marc Wilson was 3rd in Heisman voting

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 10:25pm

But lower than Jake Retzlaff in BYU history

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:28pm

Bosco was a finalist twice

stansburycoug

Nov 26, 10:26pm

I had Marc Wilson at #9 in 2022. The problem is BYU has had a lot of really good QBs.

kimdaddy35

Nov 26, 11:28pm

Wilson should probably be 4 or 5

AF Cougar

Nov 26, 11:53pm

Lol. Good one.

kimdaddy35

12:01am

Props to you on putting your opinion out there and putting some thought into it

cajuncoug

7:26am

The laugh emoji was funny. Made me smile. Well played.

cajuncoug

9:12am

Bosco is a clear #4. For you to even float that Wilson could be higher than he is made me lol.

kimdaddy35

11:28am

You are under valuing 1st team AA and college football HOF/2 things Bosco

stansburycoug

12:15pm

You seem to like to lol. That’s good. Probably healthy.

cajuncoug

12:23pm

Exactly

Cougrluvr

7:27am

Unrelated, but BYU should bring back those Marc Wilson helmets for a game or two

Cougs'16

6:26am

We did for Washington 2018 or 2019. Home game.

Y05

6:31am

Oh cool, I'd forgotten

Cougs'16

7:06am

Actually, just looked that up and those are not quite the same as the one

Cougs'16

7:08am

Wow. Not sure where that's from, but that's awful

cajuncoug

7:15am

What is an accurate list look like? Here’s my off the top of my head.

Tuskaloosa Cougar

8:02am

Took the day off, so I'll try

cajuncoug

8:30am

Solid.not too far off yours

Tuskaloosa Cougar

9:08am

Quite accurate. I might move Virgil Carter up to 13.

AF Cougar

9:22am

Admittedly, not fair assessment of Shiede/Carter. And totally forgot Doman

cajuncoug

9:34am

I was still pretty young when Virgil was playing but his play changed BYU

AF Cougar

10:08am

Zach was a Jr. in 2020 & left early.

gopman

10:04am

Just recency bias

RGGeemer

9:43am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad