I think you confuse execution with play calling.

Nov 19, 2024
6:36:07pm

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

Case in point; the play call at the end of the first half when A-Rod called a perfect play and Retzlaff made a bad read and a worse throw.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 19, 2024 at 6:36:07pm

Message modified by kimdaddy35 on Nov 19, 2024 at 6:38:17pm

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Nov 19, 2024
Total posts: 51,179 (1,537 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It is amazing to me that this has upvotes. First off, if you believe you were the only one calling for Tuiaki to go

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

11:32am

But Drake Toll sees it.

JuicyJam

11:34am

I like Drake. . . But a football expert he is not. . .

Zoobieman

12:45pm

3 of those seasons were against indy schedules. And one was pretty much BYUs

Beggar

11:38am

Actually every season I put on there was against an Indy schedule except a couple. Your point?

kimdaddy35

11:40am

2020 - 2024 were listed. 2 were not Indy. As for 2020…

Beggar

11:43am

Yep which is why 2016-19 we absolutely dominated on offense....oh wait.

kimdaddy35

11:53am

and they made a change

Beggar

12:00pm

Which one? We have had lots of coordinators since 2010 which is when the data went back to.

kimdaddy35

12:13pm

So when comparing backward this year is even more impressive?

chilawcoug

11:48am

I, for one, think we should completely clean house every year that does not end

Bostonblue

11:42am

There is no chance he is a top play caller in the country. Just because our offense was worse before him..

Deleted

11:43am

I don't have the time, but the funniest part was saying that his red zone is

chilawcoug

11:49am

Before 2nd half of UCF BYU was one of hte most efficient Red Zone offences

NYC and Japan

1:42pm

I'm only interested in the last two years since that's when we entered the

BlueFever

11:53am

RE: I'm only interested in the last two years since that's when we entered the

kimdaddy35

11:56am

OK, guys.

BlueFever

12:06pm

Limit to that set of data points and clearly ARod is improving dramatically

NYC and Japan

1:45pm

He's either improving dramatically, or the players improved dramatically.

BlueFever

1:56pm

And ARod is responsible for the players in the offense

NYC and Japan

2:05pm

We've seen overall improvement this year, but the O is breaking down again.

BlueFever

2:12pm

Actually you don’t average those years, you’d show a 50 point YoY improvement, which is amazing

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:11pm

He has a few tendencies that I really hate, but he’s a pretty dang good OC,

cougaman

11:57am

true, but don't turn a blind eye and say there arent any better options than him

realisticCoug42

12:27pm

To me, the worst part about Tuiaki was he couldn't call a decent blitz.

Zoobieman

12:55pm

Solid OC. Really good at developing QBs. I hope he levels up but I think he's

pinolero

12:56pm

Arod gets raked over the coals by CB whenever Jake throws a bad pass, makes...

icecougar

1:04pm

Tuiaki was the defensive corrinator. What are we even talking about?

BYUfreak

1:26pm

I think you're missing the difference between play calling and play design

stansburycoug

4:06pm

I didn't confuse anything. LOL

kimdaddy35

4:29pm

Tell me where I'm wrong. A great play caller shouldn't have 2 years in a row

stansburycoug

4:51pm

I think you confuse execution with play calling.

kimdaddy35

6:36pm

Sometimes people also forget we have highly skilled and trained opponents and players make mistakes. It’s a game.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:13pm

Are you saying the fade was perfect or the play designe

stansburycoug

8:57pm

RE: It is amazing to me that this has upvotes. First off, if you believe you

Posting on CougarBoard