so good in fact that we'd rather play an injured starter and lose than put the

Report problem with this ad

Nov 29, 2023
8:12:39am

bald man All-American

backups in. And when the back ups get in, they aren't really good at all.

Report problem with this ad

bald man

Bio page: bald man
Joined: Aug 2, 2002
Last login: Oct 17, 2024
Total posts: 26,544 (1,060 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Some observations based on performance and coaches comments

bald man

11/29/23 6:22am

A former WR is coaching the QBs, that is what's going on there

astroman

11/29/23 6:27am

Yeah he sucked at it with the last two guys.

A Drew Aitch

11/29/23 6:29am

Is that more to do with John Beck or ARod?

astroman

11/29/23 6:37am

All college QBs have an outside trainer.

A Drew Aitch

11/29/23 6:38am

Plus, the original post hinted as lack of development at backup QB, not starters

astroman

11/29/23 6:41am

thank you. To me, this is the biggest question mark. Why aren't the backups

bald man

11/29/23 7:33am

But Wilson and Hall both backups at one time and certainly progressed

viper

11/29/23 12:16pm

Was Romney a Back up under ARod, Jaren Hall? You mean back ups this year.

A Drew Aitch

11/29/23 12:55pm

It's funny how some want to assign blame without ever giving credit.

Unibro

11/29/23 8:01am

it's funny how some think you can't question the performance based on results

bald man

11/29/23 8:11am

Both those NFL QBs were backups… an NFL RB was a walk on…

Pretorian

11/29/23 10:27am

so basically arod can only develop nfl caliber guys.

bald man

11/29/23 11:08am

I believe only NFL caliber guys make it to… the NFL, regardless who’s coaching

Pretorian

11/29/23 11:57am

Not uncommon for former players to coach a position they didn’t play.

Metallicat

11/29/23 6:31am

I remember Jim McMahon once saying about Andy Reid

Belboz

11/29/23 8:03am

I remember hearing that too. So funny.

Metallicat

11/29/23 8:55am

Norm Chow coached QBs. Played guard in college.

BYU Statsman

11/29/23 6:32am

He coached WRs for years at BYU.

Les IsMore

11/29/23 12:14pm

Yes he did. And QBs.

BYU Statsman

11/29/23 12:25pm

For years I heard people complain about Norm Chow's play calling.

Benfica1

11/29/23 3:45pm

Nick Saban is calling and Mike Leach is rising from the dead

BYU Grounds

11/30/23 10:47am

Personally, unless recruiting does really, really well this offseason

PortlandCoug

11/29/23 6:36am

Granted KS hs to navigate some difficult things like

bald man

11/29/23 7:36am

It would take a 3 win season or less for Kalani to be gone after 2024

donnerstag

11/29/23 8:51am

Defensive talent though is a big issue, DL has to get much better

PortlandCoug

11/29/23 1:12pm

Good points, but this is BYU. I predict 2 more years.

CougarMandias

11/29/23 9:52am

I think he's a really good recruiter

deliciousmocha

11/29/23 2:50pm

100% agreed. If we have a repeat performance in 2024 I think Sitake is gone

TaysomJimmerEraCoug

11/29/23 2:54pm

It would take back-to-back seasons of 4 wins or less for KS to be gone.

Hammer15

11/30/23 12:19am

What do you mean Personally? Are you gonna fire him? You don’t have to worry

canofpicante

11/30/23 1:05am

Going to be a long off-season on CB

WJCougar

11/29/23 6:46am

it was a long season. 🙁

bald man

11/29/23 7:38am

We’ve had some good backup qbs last four years

niqmadu

11/29/23 7:48am

so good in fact that we'd rather play an injured starter and lose than put the

bald man

11/29/23 8:12am

I didn’t say this year. You paint with a wide brush and are forgetting that

niqmadu

11/29/23 8:18am

That is true, I wasn't thinking of them.

bald man

11/29/23 8:43am

I think the common disappointment is when the QB pipeline hits a dry spell.

niqmadu

11/29/23 11:02am

haven't we recruited 4 start guys? but they didn't pan out?

bald man

11/29/23 11:09am

I’d have to dig in to see but it’s not uncommon

niqmadu

11/29/23 11:45am

Not all 4* players pan out

Pretorian

11/29/23 11:59am

If true, Kalani's approach to the portal will be the final nail in the coffin.

Karl Poppin

11/29/23 8:17am

I took his quote to mean

RiseUp

11/29/23 10:30am

If true, that's fine, I suppose.

Karl Poppin

11/29/23 10:47am

Same here

runningfoo

11/29/23 10:47am

Same. And I agree. Recruit players but they can't be a drain or a distraction.

YOHONOMOTO

11/29/23 12:39pm

Same. And I agree. Recruit players but they can't be a drain or a distraction.

YOHONOMOTO

11/29/23 12:40pm

That is 100% the fault of program culture and Kalani is responsible for righting the ship

runningryan

11/29/23 8:48am

additional observations - grass is green and the sky is blue

AFitisemanu

11/29/23 11:56am

sometimes

jetycns

11/29/23 1:23pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad