You're right, Oates should be on there

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 3, 2025
3:35:45pm

Ja'Crispy 3rd String

You're right, Oates should be on there

Report problem with this ad

Ja'Crispy

Previous username: Burgandy?
Bio page: Ja'Crispy
Joined: Jul 23, 2010
Last login: Jan 5, 2025
Total posts: 307 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Other than Steve Young, who is the best NFL player to come out of BYU?

Ja'Crispy

Jan 3, 3:25pm

The amount of recency bias in these results is crazy.

LSUcougar92

Jan 3, 3:28pm

Could be true, who else you got?

Ja'Crispy

Jan 3, 3:29pm

Paul Howard was a fundamental piece to his team forever

LSUcougar92

Jan 3, 3:34pm

Lee Johnson

Jdoc

Jan 3, 3:48pm

Historically yes. Longest career with huge impact.

LSUcougar92

Jan 3, 3:51pm

Taysom is a better player at several positions that others that only play that position. Hes the best "NFL Player".

AltTabbins

Jan 3, 3:28pm

Did you not watch football in 1985?

LSUcougar92

Jan 3, 3:30pm

Well I was 2 years old so tell me how it was

Ja'Crispy

Jan 3, 3:34pm

fuzzy

Jan 3, 3:39pm

VGA

franklyvulgar

Jan 3, 3:43pm

I watched Reading Rainbow and Sesame Street in 1983.

AltTabbins

Jan 3, 3:51pm

Taysom Hill is not near the 2nd best pro to come out of BYU. Unique to our time period when everything

kimdaddy35

Jan 3, 3:39pm

He's not a better TE than other BYU TEs, not a better QB than many BYU WBs, not

Plato

Jan 3, 3:42pm

No, but he's a better TE than anyone else from BYU who wasn't a TE. He's a better RB than anyone else from BYU who isn't

AltTabbins

Jan 3, 3:56pm

*Vai

foofcoug

Jan 3, 3:29pm

He should respect his GA's!

kimdaddy35

Jan 3, 3:41pm

Here's the top 10 by AV and where some other players of interest end up

krindorr

Jan 3, 3:29pm

I don’t see Chad Lewis at all on that list

bubbastats

Jan 3, 3:34pm

Added him, he just wasn't one of the ones I'd chosen to list first

krindorr

Jan 3, 3:36pm

Well you took off my vote of 5 time pro-bowler and 2 time champion Bart Oates.

kimdaddy35

Jan 3, 3:30pm

He didn't have any All Pros though

Jan 3, 3:33pm

You're right, Oates should be on there

Ja'Crispy

Jan 3, 3:35pm

he'd have my vote

Cougarclaw

Jan 3, 3:46pm

According to NFL.com, here is what they say...

Ja'Crispy

Jan 3, 3:33pm

<< Deleted >>

DudeBro

Jan 3, 3:40pm

The QB who won Chicago’s only Super Bowl? Seems like a no-brainer.

DodgerCoug

Jan 3, 3:52pm

If Pura stays healthy

McMax

Jan 3, 4:25pm

Fred Warner and it really isn't close

CaliWG

Jan 3, 5:27pm

I think Oates has a bit of an argument based on Warner being incomplete

krindorr

Jan 3, 7:04pm

<< Deleted >>

IUCougar

Jan 3, 11:16pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad