12 game reg season is way too small a sample size to say who the best teams are

Jan 2, 2025
4:00:12pm

Mr. Scoobs All-American

OSU just barely lost in a stinker to Michigan and then blew out #1 oregon.

Why was SMU more deserving than BYU? Did the regular season matter then?

Report problem with this ad

Mr. Scoobs

Previous username: Alm
Bio page: Mr. Scoobs
Joined: Sep 8, 2011
Last login: Jan 4, 2025
Total posts: 12,405 (188 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I think my favorite playoff suggestion is 20 team playoff.

cougarfann888

Jan 2, 3:48pm

24 in FCS works really well.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:49pm

Doesn’t the playoff get too long? It would be half as long as the season.

TarCoug

Jan 2, 3:53pm

5 weeks compared to the 4 now.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 4:03pm

Ok, maybe I slightly exaggerated haha

TarCoug

Jan 2, 4:05pm

No, 12 is enough. They just need to tweak the seeding and it will be fine.

DudeBro

Jan 2, 3:50pm

I don't think the seeding is the problem...it's the rankings we're just wrong!!

Xenon

Jan 2, 4:01pm

You realize Clemson had to be in right? Via winning the ACC?

arcawley

Jan 2, 4:04pm

No they didn't!!! Top 5 ranked champs.... Could have been army or someone else

Xenon

Jan 2, 4:05pm

In no way did Army deserve to get in over Clemson…that’s laughable

arcawley

Jan 2, 6:14pm

Army ranked above Clemson most of the year.....

Xenon

Jan 2, 6:25pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 6:28pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 6:37pm

Not in the CFP. Army’s best win is a 9-win Tulane. Not good enough at all

arcawley

Jan 2, 6:31pm

quit trying to expand the playoffs, makes season meaningless

Count Cougar

Jan 2, 3:53pm

how? it makes the season actually mean something for far more teams than

FieroCoug

Jan 2, 3:54pm

12 game reg season is way too small a sample size to say who the best teams are

Mr. Scoobs

Jan 2, 4:00pm

This is the dumbest reasoning of any argument that has ever been had.

kcca

Jan 2, 4:08pm

says you, why give teams a second chance?

Count Cougar

Jan 2, 4:09pm

Generally speaking, you need more than one game to determine who the better team

kcca

Jan 2, 4:34pm

glad you brought up baseball

Count Cougar

Jan 2, 4:41pm

You are making my point for me.

kcca

Jan 2, 4:48pm

its wrong in baseball and basketball

Count Cougar

Jan 2, 5:05pm

If you are not top 3 in your conference you have no business playing for a NC.

Turn and Cough

Jan 2, 3:57pm

I don't like any playoff scenario where anyone gets a bye... it's clear a bye is a disadvantage

Coug

Jan 2, 4:00pm

Just do 16 with no buys. Wouldn't really have to change anything.

ochobeeguy

Jan 2, 4:02pm

I just think those 13-20 games would be fun. It would give teams a chance to win

cougarfann888

Jan 2, 4:12pm

16, no byes, 10 conf champion auto bids, 6 at larges, values the reg season

CrashMcLarson

Jan 2, 4:06pm

Within 5 years you would have 17 conferences of 8 teams.

cougarfann888

Jan 2, 4:14pm

and what is wrong with that

Count Cougar

Jan 2, 4:26pm

Do you then expand to 17 with no at larges.

cougarfann888

Jan 2, 4:51pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 5:24pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad