But BYU didn't have the opportunity to "prove it" against ISU. So that doesn't

Jan 1, 2025
1:08:55pm

Plato All-American

work. BYU earned the CCG on the field (and also failed to earn it), but you have to have a tie breaker. And the conference is too big.

Report problem with this ad

Plato

Bio page: Plato
Joined: Mar 21, 2017
Last login: Jan 4, 2025
Total posts: 21,517 (520 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Big 12 needs a better system. I feel like having multiple teams with identical

westsidecoug

Jan 1, 1:04pm

I think the only solution is not to have crazy large conferences. It's going to

paulb

Jan 1, 1:05pm

Divisions are a solution but then you have the issue of a 7-5 winner of division

Kajdin

Jan 1, 1:07pm

Yup, choose your poison basically.

paulb

Jan 1, 1:09pm

Yep. Let's kick 2 or 4 teams out. Just hope it's not us

Plato

Jan 1, 1:07pm

Would divisions with some sort of scheduling for semifinals to the championship

westsidecoug

Jan 1, 1:07pm

I feel like it worked. ASU settled it on the field & beat byu head to head. If byu would’ve beat asu head to head they

RdF3

Jan 1, 1:07pm

I'm not talking about ASU. I'm talking about BYU and Iowa State.

westsidecoug

Jan 1, 1:08pm

Hard for me to base the system on being wrong because a team that lost 2 of its last 3 conference games didn’t get to

RdF3

Jan 1, 1:13pm

It seems like asu byu on a neutral would have been the best match up.

NYCougz

Jan 1, 1:17pm

Timing of the losses shouldn't matter.

westsidecoug

Jan 1, 1:28pm

But BYU didn't have the opportunity to "prove it" against ISU. So that doesn't

Plato

Jan 1, 1:08pm

Not much to be done for any of the conferences with 16 or more teams

byuTX

Jan 1, 1:07pm

Recency bias makes us think BYU is a better team than they were

lilpenny

Jan 1, 1:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad