If they were a major competitor, you could list multiple contributors we lost.

Dec 22, 2024
2:34:59pm

johnnybyu All-American

You listed 1 recruit and they ended up coming to BYU and never contributed much. The other two you listed chose BYU over boise.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 22, 2024 at 2:34:59pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on Dec 22, 2024 at 2:35:29pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on Dec 22, 2024 at 2:37:05pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on Dec 22, 2024 at 2:39:59pm

Report problem with this ad

johnnybyu

Bio page: johnnybyu
Joined: Jun 6, 2002
Last login: Dec 22, 2024
Total posts: 16,405 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

From strictly a BYU FB fan perspective, I’m confused why so many on CB are

Traveshamockery

12:11pm

I just want James Franklin to lose

WJCougar

12:13pm

Does that overpower your BYU FB fandom?

Traveshamockery

12:14pm

There is some but not that much crossover in recruiting. It is not like Utah and

johnnybyu

12:20pm

I don't think BSU winning will have any effect on our recruiting.

Colorado

12:22pm

Very minimal if any

johnnybyu

12:23pm

Agree. Our rivals for top LDS rivals, are other P4s.

Everyman

12:26pm

I strongly disagree. Many of our recruits (LDS & non-LDS)

gopman

12:31pm

And when we offered Zach he turned down Boise and came to BYU. How many players

johnnybyu

12:32pm

There have been several (especially non-LDS) recruits that we've

gopman

12:46pm

The 3 examples you have given all ended up ay byu. Now with NIL BYU will lose

johnnybyu

12:52pm

Go back & look at 247 & Rivals the last 20 years & you'll see us

gopman

12:57pm

They are not going the way of Nebraska they are in the new pac 12 and will

johnnybyu

12:59pm

I said "it would make recruiting easier IF".....

gopman

1:03pm

Utah and now ASU. And any big 10 and sec team if they are deemed far superior to

johnnybyu

1:04pm

Utah yes. You forgot BSU. One can say Oregon as well.

gopman

1:06pm

Yes Oregon which is why we don’t want big 10 teams winning

johnnybyu

1:08pm

ASU is NOT in top three. BSU is. Go ask the experts.

gopman

1:09pm

Please name the top 5 players that spurned byu for Boise? That is going to

johnnybyu

1:20pm

I'll add USC. The four schools we've competed against in the last

gopman

1:19pm

USC as well again our biggest concern is the big10 and SEC separating not

johnnybyu

1:22pm

Go back the last 20 plus years on 247 & Rivals & you'll see that we've had

gopman

1:33pm

Let’s hear examples and saying Boise is a recruiting competitor does not

johnnybyu

1:38pm

I provided three examples of Zach Wilson, Jamaal Williams & Cravens.

gopman

2:04pm

Those 3 all played at byu. Do you want to add Tanner Mangum?

johnnybyu

2:14pm

Cravens played at Boise State before transferring to BYU. Does

gopman

2:27pm

If they were a major competitor, you could list multiple contributors we lost.

johnnybyu

2:34pm

Donte Deayon. Close friend of Jamaal Williams at Summit High in

gopman

3:34pm

Major does not mean minor which your examples are showing

johnnybyu

3:38pm

Does Boise State have a record of offering many of the same 3-star guys we

gopman

3:42pm

You provided one example from 10 years ago. That is what minor means

johnnybyu

5:28pm

Who cares? We care. I stated earlier that we've won some battles & lost

gopman

6:04pm

If they continue to get to the CFP and winning games, they’ll start stealing

Traveshamockery

12:55pm

In my experience BSU are about on par with Wyoming fans. That's why I want them to lose.

Jimo Dashen

12:26pm

LDS athletes are going to a ton of places other than Utah, USU, and Boise.

DudeBro

12:38pm

I hope BSU loses by 50

Sircumference

12:46pm

I think the narrative that the B1G and SEC are far superior to anyone else is worse by far for BYU than any minor

Colorado

12:51pm

Bingo

johnnybyu

1:05pm

The big 10 and SEC separating from everyone else hurts us more than a good

johnnybyu

12:57pm

This.

Benfica1

3:35pm

Correct. We not only compete with Boise State for LDS recruits but also

gopman

5:11pm

Does someone want to tell him we are now P4 and have more nil than many schools

johnnybyu

5:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad