Let’s hear examples and saying Boise is a recruiting competitor does not

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 22, 2024
1:38:47pm

johnnybyu All-American

Let’s hear examples and saying Boise is a recruiting competitor does not

Discount that our bigger concern is the sec and big10 separating. Boise beating them is better for us.

I am not arguing that Boise is not a competitor. They are just not a big competitor. No one has even provided one example in the past 20 years. I just keep hearing they are a recruiting competitor which is true but the impact is minimal

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 22, 2024 at 1:38:47pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on Dec 22, 2024 at 1:39:30pm

Message modified by johnnybyu on Dec 22, 2024 at 1:40:54pm

Report problem with this ad

johnnybyu

Bio page: johnnybyu
Joined: Jun 6, 2002
Last login: Dec 22, 2024
Total posts: 16,402 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

From strictly a BYU FB fan perspective, I’m confused why so many on CB are

Traveshamockery

12:11pm

I just want James Franklin to lose

WJCougar

12:13pm

Does that overpower your BYU FB fandom?

Traveshamockery

12:14pm

There is some but not that much crossover in recruiting. It is not like Utah and

johnnybyu

12:20pm

I don't think BSU winning will have any effect on our recruiting.

Colorado

12:22pm

Very minimal if any

johnnybyu

12:23pm

Agree. Our rivals for top LDS rivals, are other P4s.

Everyman

12:26pm

I strongly disagree. Many of our recruits (LDS & non-LDS)

gopman

12:31pm

And when we offered Zach he turned down Boise and came to BYU. How many players

johnnybyu

12:32pm

There have been several (especially non-LDS) recruits that we've

gopman

12:46pm

The 3 examples you have given all ended up ay byu. Now with NIL BYU will lose

johnnybyu

12:52pm

Go back & look at 247 & Rivals the last 20 years & you'll see us

gopman

12:57pm

They are not going the way of Nebraska they are in the new pac 12 and will

johnnybyu

12:59pm

I said "it would make recruiting easier IF".....

gopman

1:03pm

Utah and now ASU. And any big 10 and sec team if they are deemed far superior to

johnnybyu

1:04pm

Utah yes. You forgot BSU. One can say Oregon as well.

gopman

1:06pm

Yes Oregon which is why we don’t want big 10 teams winning

johnnybyu

1:08pm

ASU is NOT in top three. BSU is. Go ask the experts.

gopman

1:09pm

Please name the top 5 players that spurned byu for Boise? That is going to

johnnybyu

1:20pm

I'll add USC. The four schools we've competed against in the last

gopman

1:19pm

USC as well again our biggest concern is the big10 and SEC separating not

johnnybyu

1:22pm

Go back the last 20 plus years on 247 & Rivals & you'll see that we've had

gopman

1:33pm

Let’s hear examples and saying Boise is a recruiting competitor does not

johnnybyu

1:38pm

I provided three examples of Zach Wilson, Jamaal Williams & Cravens.

gopman

2:04pm

Those 3 all played at byu. Do you want to add Tanner Mangum?

johnnybyu

2:14pm

Cravens played at Boise State before transferring to BYU. Does

gopman

2:27pm

If they were a major competitor, you could list multiple contributors we lost.

johnnybyu

2:34pm

Donte Deayon. Close friend of Jamaal Williams at Summit High in

gopman

3:34pm

Major does not mean minor which your examples are showing

johnnybyu

3:38pm

Does Boise State have a record of offering many of the same 3-star guys we

gopman

3:42pm

You provided one example from 10 years ago. That is what minor means

johnnybyu

5:28pm

Who cares? We care. I stated earlier that we've won some battles & lost

gopman

6:04pm

If they continue to get to the CFP and winning games, they’ll start stealing

Traveshamockery

12:55pm

In my experience BSU are about on par with Wyoming fans. That's why I want them to lose.

Jimo Dashen

12:26pm

LDS athletes are going to a ton of places other than Utah, USU, and Boise.

DudeBro

12:38pm

I hope BSU loses by 50

Sircumference

12:46pm

I think the narrative that the B1G and SEC are far superior to anyone else is worse by far for BYU than any minor

Colorado

12:51pm

Bingo

johnnybyu

1:05pm

The big 10 and SEC separating from everyone else hurts us more than a good

johnnybyu

12:57pm

This.

Benfica1

3:35pm

Correct. We not only compete with Boise State for LDS recruits but also

gopman

5:11pm

Does someone want to tell him we are now P4 and have more nil than many schools

johnnybyu

5:15pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad