I'm not saying they deserve more than what they got this year. Just that what

Report problem with this ad

Dec 21, 2024
3:18:50pm

Methusaleh22 Truly Addicted User

they got is justifiable. I'm good with SMU in over Alabama but they're not better.

Report problem with this ad

Methusaleh22

Previous username: Wash Hogwallop
Bio page: Methusaleh22
Joined: Jul 3, 2003
Last login: Dec 23, 2024
Total posts: 14,035 (36 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I know you all hate it but the P2+Notre Dame are in fact better and deserve more

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:08pm

Notre dame is decent this year, but got smoked in prior playoffs

Hsaru

Dec 21, 3:09pm

Same with Florida St, Washington, Auburn, etc. The teams come and go but the top

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:11pm

Strike Florida St....

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:11pm

And got beat by NIU at home this year. Terrible take

docrick

Dec 21, 3:11pm

Ok.. what else?

775coug

Dec 21, 3:24pm

Yewts suck

docrick

Dec 21, 4:50pm

RE: Yewts suck

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 5:55pm

Poor opinion until we see TX & ASU next week. All we know so far is the ACC was

YbeatsU

Dec 21, 3:10pm

Which was BYU’s only good win. So much for the argument that the B12 deserved

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:18pm

It was still a good win. At SMU and they didn’t gift pick 6’s to start the game,

YbeatsU

Dec 21, 3:22pm

RE: It was still a good win. At SMU and they didn’t gift pick 6’s to

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:36pm

Then get the heck out of the NCAA and play with yourselves. Have fun

docrick

Dec 21, 3:10pm

They played Indiana. Just wait until they have to play Georgia.

TerpCoug

Dec 21, 3:11pm

Really wish ND could get more teams in.

Ghost of Peanut

Dec 21, 3:11pm

Yes, it's been proven. Thank you for your wisdom.

coug10278

Dec 21, 3:12pm

8 of 10 CFP champions, Clemson the other 2. I'm not sure how you could argue

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:15pm

Every year should be viewed individually. Other years shouldn't matter.

coug10278

Dec 21, 3:20pm

Yes, but the committee has to gauge the difficulty of the schedule. It's a

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:24pm

But is that because they are inherently better by divine grace?

DanSmith

Dec 21, 3:12pm

Sure, like the Dodgers and Yankees. But they are better.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:16pm

That’s the American system we all love isn’t it ?

Polecat

Dec 21, 3:27pm

nah they should have to prove it every year. and if it ends up the same way

FieroCoug

Dec 21, 3:14pm

I'm not saying they deserve more than what they got this year. Just that what

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:18pm

Well... I mean, yeah. Nobody is saying the SEC got too many teams in

NGB

Dec 21, 3:22pm

Yes, nobody on this board was upset with that group getting 8 bids. Nobody.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:27pm

Uhh... what SEC team got in who shouldn't have

NGB

Dec 21, 3:28pm

We're on the same page. Ask CB. It's all I heard all year was how the SEC/Big12

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:33pm

why is ND in your elite group? They made the 4 team CFP once and got beat

cwilke1

Dec 21, 3:14pm

Cause that's the group they belong in and would be if they wanted.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:21pm

I thought you were talking deserve. now you're just talking fan appeal? ok

cwilke1

Dec 21, 3:31pm

Fan appeal? How did your draw that conclusion?

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:36pm

“Poor postseason performance used to be strong evidence that the PAC-12 sucks,

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:16pm

Let me clarify. They deserve the "more" that they got. Not more than they got.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:19pm

That's fine. 4 SEC, 4 B1G, 2 ACC, 2 Big12, ND, 1 highest ranking G5 champ

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Dec 21, 3:20pm

So far this isn’t a good year to argue that we need more playoff teams.

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:22pm

So ND gets a guaranteed spot every year? Seems kinda…stupid

775coug

Dec 21, 3:27pm

No. Only if they are top 16. It's just implied that they will be almost always.

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Dec 21, 3:34pm

I wouldn't say always, but certainly often

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:37pm

Almost always because they don't usually play more than one or two hard games

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Dec 21, 3:44pm

They've been to 4 CFP/NY6 games in the 10 years of the CFP.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 4:28pm

I'm the biggest proponent. 24 for me. But that's a different discussion.

Methusaleh22

Dec 21, 3:29pm

People disliking really just hate reality

775coug

Dec 21, 3:26pm

A large portion of CB will argue very strongly for whatever helps BYU and

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:38pm

Let’s see how ASU does first

Dr MoBYU

Dec 21, 3:37pm

Would ASU winning suggest the B12 should have gotten another playoff team?

garyfan

Dec 21, 3:39pm

If we played the National Champ to the last play of the game And lost bc of a stupid onside kick, yes.

Posting on CougarBoard