My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 21, 2024
3:18
:04
pm
garyfan
All-American
Which was BYU’s only good win. So much for the argument that the B12 deserved
more than one playoff spot…
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
garyfan
Bio page
garyfan
Joined
Sep 19, 2013
Last login
Dec 23, 2024
Total posts
40,346 (4,155 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I know you all hate it but the P2+Notre Dame are in fact better and deserve more
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:08pm
Notre dame is decent this year, but got smoked in prior playoffs
Hsaru
Dec 21, 3:09pm
Same with Florida St, Washington, Auburn, etc. The teams come and go but the top
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:11pm
Strike Florida St....
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:11pm
And got beat by NIU at home this year. Terrible take
docrick
Dec 21, 3:11pm
Ok.. what else?
775coug
Dec 21, 3:24pm
Yewts suck
docrick
Dec 21, 4:50pm
RE: Yewts suck
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 5:55pm
Poor opinion until we see TX & ASU next week. All we know so far is the ACC was
YbeatsU
Dec 21, 3:10pm
Which was BYU’s only good win. So much for the argument that the B12 deserved
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:18pm
It was still a good win. At SMU and they didn’t gift pick 6’s to start the game,
YbeatsU
Dec 21, 3:22pm
RE: It was still a good win. At SMU and they didn’t gift pick 6’s to
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:36pm
Then get the heck out of the NCAA and play with yourselves. Have fun
docrick
Dec 21, 3:10pm
They played Indiana. Just wait until they have to play Georgia.
TerpCoug
Dec 21, 3:11pm
Really wish ND could get more teams in.
Ghost of Peanut
Dec 21, 3:11pm
Yes, it's been proven. Thank you for your wisdom.
coug10278
Dec 21, 3:12pm
8 of 10 CFP champions, Clemson the other 2. I'm not sure how you could argue
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:15pm
Every year should be viewed individually. Other years shouldn't matter.
coug10278
Dec 21, 3:20pm
Yes, but the committee has to gauge the difficulty of the schedule. It's a
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:24pm
But is that because they are inherently better by divine grace?
DanSmith
Dec 21, 3:12pm
Sure, like the Dodgers and Yankees. But they are better.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:16pm
That’s the American system we all love isn’t it ?
Polecat
Dec 21, 3:27pm
nah they should have to prove it every year. and if it ends up the same way
FieroCoug
Dec 21, 3:14pm
I'm not saying they deserve more than what they got this year. Just that what
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:18pm
Well... I mean, yeah. Nobody is saying the SEC got too many teams in
NGB
Dec 21, 3:22pm
Yes, nobody on this board was upset with that group getting 8 bids. Nobody.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:27pm
Uhh... what SEC team got in who shouldn't have
NGB
Dec 21, 3:28pm
We're on the same page. Ask CB. It's all I heard all year was how the SEC/Big12
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:33pm
why is ND in your elite group? They made the 4 team CFP once and got beat
cwilke1
Dec 21, 3:14pm
Cause that's the group they belong in and would be if they wanted.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:21pm
I thought you were talking deserve. now you're just talking fan appeal? ok
cwilke1
Dec 21, 3:31pm
Fan appeal? How did your draw that conclusion?
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:36pm
“Poor postseason performance used to be strong evidence that the PAC-12 sucks,
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:16pm
Let me clarify. They deserve the "more" that they got. Not more than they got.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:19pm
That's fine. 4 SEC, 4 B1G, 2 ACC, 2 Big12, ND, 1 highest ranking G5 champ
Zerigke Ally Zerigke
Dec 21, 3:20pm
So far this isn’t a good year to argue that we need more playoff teams.
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:22pm
So ND gets a guaranteed spot every year? Seems kinda…stupid
775coug
Dec 21, 3:27pm
No. Only if they are top 16. It's just implied that they will be almost always.
Zerigke Ally Zerigke
Dec 21, 3:34pm
I wouldn't say always, but certainly often
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:37pm
Almost always because they don't usually play more than one or two hard games
Zerigke Ally Zerigke
Dec 21, 3:44pm
They've been to 4 CFP/NY6 games in the 10 years of the CFP.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 4:28pm
I'm the biggest proponent. 24 for me. But that's a different discussion.
Methusaleh22
Dec 21, 3:29pm
People disliking really just hate reality
775coug
Dec 21, 3:26pm
A large portion of CB will argue very strongly for whatever helps BYU and
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:38pm
Let’s see how ASU does first
Dr MoBYU
Dec 21, 3:37pm
Would ASU winning suggest the B12 should have gotten another playoff team?
garyfan
Dec 21, 3:39pm
If we played the National Champ to the last play of the game And lost bc of a stupid onside kick, yes.
Dr MoBYU
Dec 21, 4:20pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad