My argument is to pick one criteria and stick to it. Either SOS or W/L. The

Report problem with this ad

Dec 21, 2024
12:32:36pm

TerpCoug All-American

Constant switching depending on the year is maddening.

Report problem with this ad

TerpCoug

Bio page: TerpCoug
Joined: Oct 7, 2017
Last login: Dec 21, 2024
Total posts: 2,484 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Everyone here is forgetting we lost to a bad Kansas team at home

RealTaysomHill Truly Addicted User

Dec 20, 9:53pm

And ND lost to a terrible NIU team at home.

TerpCoug

Dec 20, 9:55pm

Who else did they lose to?

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 9:55pm

Bravo, they beat up on Service Academies, Miami of Ohio and Purdue

TerpCoug

Dec 20, 10:04pm

They won their games. What more do you want? If BYU had lost to two good teams, we would have an argument. We lost to

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 11:33pm

This is the exact same argument they used against us for forever. Either it’s

TerpCoug

Dec 21, 10:30am

This is a new format though. At some point, you have to keep teams out, right? That’s true with the BCS, four team

RealTaysomHill

Dec 21, 10:46am

My argument is to pick one criteria and stick to it. Either SOS or W/L. The

TerpCoug

Dec 21, 12:32pm

Who else did they play?

ochobeeguy

Dec 20, 10:15pm

At Texas A&M.

Japan Coug

Dec 21, 2:18am

And Bama lost to two awful game

HimmerFredette

Dec 20, 9:56pm

They aren’t in the playoffs so who cares?

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 9:56pm

No I think every time we turn on the playoffs we all remember

stansburycoug

Dec 20, 9:55pm

They beat iowa state and Colorado. Btw, asu lost to TT and cincy.

Idacoug

Dec 20, 9:56pm

ASU won the conference, remember?

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 9:57pm

they won the conference championship game

ochobeeguy

Dec 20, 10:19pm

Thus, won the conference.

DudeBro

Dec 20, 10:28pm

There was a 4 way tie for conference champions.

ochobeeguy

Dec 20, 10:30pm

Lmk when we hang our banner

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 11:33pm

Sic'Em Beers

Dec 21, 3:52am

And wouldnt have made the playoff if they hadnt won the title

stansburycoug

Dec 20, 9:58pm

And Indiana didn’t beat any ranked teams and lost to the 2 they played

docrick

Dec 20, 9:56pm

You’re suggesting a 1 loss P4 team should be left out?

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 9:57pm

Yes if they played no one. Another P4 team with 2 losses but wins over ranked

docrick

Dec 20, 9:58pm

Who is that?

NGB

Dec 20, 10:02pm

Who is what?

docrick

Dec 20, 10:10pm

Are you suggesting all one loss P4 teams should get in? That’s interesting.

NYCougz

Dec 20, 10:06pm

They always will

NGB

Dec 20, 10:06pm

Always? Wow that’s a big claim especially with the size of conferences and only

NYCougz

Dec 20, 10:09pm

Yes. Always. At least under the current system.

NGB

Dec 20, 10:10pm

Not guaranteed

docrick

Dec 20, 10:11pm

Guaranteed? No. But it's so likely it's almost a certainty.

NGB

Dec 21, 8:39am

Nice backtrack. So the no answer is correct

docrick

Dec 21, 10:56am

I didn't backtrack, but okay.

NGB

Dec 21, 11:39am

"Likely & almost" don't usually go together with certainty, lol

CLCougar

Dec 21, 11:06am

No.

NYCougz

Dec 20, 10:12pm

Lol..no

CLCougar

Dec 20, 10:16pm

Maybe?

docrick

Dec 20, 10:11pm

Yes, I am

RealTaysomHill

Dec 20, 11:32pm

You know you can have lots of 1 loss teams in a given year so your theory would

NYCougz

Dec 20, 11:37pm

I’ll risk it. But a one loss team this year, who’s only loss was at #3, deserves to be in

RealTaysomHill

Dec 21, 1:14am

I don’t think anyone has forgotten we lost to Kansas.

NYCougz

Dec 20, 10:03pm

RE: Everyone here is forgetting we lost to a bad Kansas team at home

BW84

Dec 20, 10:08pm

Kansas has more top 25 wins than Notre Dame

Charles Darwin

Dec 20, 10:32pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad