Wait, are you serious?

Dec 4, 2024
11:16:54am

HRCougar Truly Addicted User

ARod chose Jack Tuttle over Wilson but he gets that win?
ARod recruited Jaren Hall but he chose someone else, yet he gets that win?
Tyler "Poo-poo" Huntley is your shining star example?

What am I missing?

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 4, 2024 at 11:16:54am

Message modified by HRCougar on Dec 4, 2024 at 11:17:24am

Report problem with this ad

HRCougar

Previous username: rnormangardner
Bio page: HRCougar
Joined: Nov 22, 2004
Last login: Dec 4, 2024
Total posts: 13,778 (2,003 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The narrative that "A-Rod can't recruit QBs" is demonstrably false, and it is

dYrtbYkerYder

11:02am

By the way, I was surprised to see the CB hate for A-Rod originated long before

dYrtbYkerYder

11:04am

Why do you assume Arod is hated? Feeling that someone is not getting the job

Hinta

11:26am

Read some of the posts from that 2016-2017 timeframe.

dYrtbYkerYder

12:03pm

That part might be that he was not that good at Utah, not that he coached there.

SoBlueitHurts

11:32am

RE: The narrative that "A-Rod can't recruit QBs" is demonstrably false, and it is

Coug

11:06am

LOL at this quote

cougarmeister

11:08am

Mangum had one play he liked: roll right and throw

mudpupper

11:10am

<< Deleted >>

HRCougar

11:14am

Mangum was mostly good in 2015 in hindsight he should've followed Anae and Beck

CameronG

11:34am

In some ways yes, but even though I liked him I recognize that he had some

SoBlueitHurts

11:44am

I agree, he wasn't great but he was good for a freshman who didn't expect to

CameronG

11:49am

That’s a lot of effort to defend him. Agent? Wife? Gotta be someone close

Bluforever

11:14am

Wait, are you serious?

HRCougar

11:16am

I'd actually love an answer here since you were bold enough to proclaim:

HRCougar

12:07pm

Main point is that A-Rod should get a lot of the credit for Zach coming to BYU.

dYrtbYkerYder

2:25pm

I can understand that argument, even if I disagree with it

HRCougar

2:32pm

If Zach loved Arod so much, why did he direct his brother to Utah because they

foofcoug

11:20am

His knowledge of how NFL teams ran their offense was the Jets....soo.....

LeonMarek

11:21am

I suspect Zach was just supporting his brother that wanted to go to Utah

letthewookieewin

11:28am

Thanks Mrs Rod.

Longseason

11:22am

I just looked in the QB cupboard and your write up doesn’t fit with what I saw.

WDaddy

11:26am

It is telling that the OP does not discuss the current QB room or situation. Worst QB situation at BYU

Baron

11:31am

And that's after fairly successful careers with Jaren and Zach. You'd think it would be easy to attract QBs with that

WDaddy

11:33am

I would say 2017 QB Room was worse but yeah it's not good now

CameronG

11:37am

You must have a really bad memory.

dYrtbYkerYder

12:14pm

Whole bunch of nothing here lol. That was some serious stretching to try to

kotacoug

11:42am

People are saying that he didn't bring in any of the QBs he has had. I think it

dYrtbYkerYder

12:10pm

I think the overwhelming evidence is that he struggles to bring in great Qbs

kotacoug

12:35pm

And why can't some just say that he's missed on some good ones too? Bad take

vabeachcoug

11:56am

I'm fine with that. I'm also fine with saying that QB recruiting matters less

dYrtbYkerYder

12:12pm

QB is the most important position. Yes, the transfer portal messes up

vabeachcoug

12:15pm

Umm recruiting now IS the portal. That’s where you have to be every year. So

kotacoug

12:35pm

"Here's a million dollars. Want to come play for a guy who develops NFL QBs?"

dYrtbYkerYder

12:51pm

Zach has been gone since 2020. So what has ARod done since then? Don't say Jaren, because he was offered by BYU over 2

unctoothman

1:07pm

RE: The narrative that "A-Rod can't recruit QBs" is demonstrably false, and it

Beregond

1:30pm

Clearly ARod was part of the change that brought ZW to BYU. ZW knew ARod

NYC and Japan

2:15pm

Wilson didn’t just support Isaac going to Utah he literally came out and said

kotacoug

5:52pm

Lol, that's not what was said.

Posting on CougarBoard