Yep, we’re in n the same page. Maybe poorly designed is more accurate to say

Nov 19, 2024
8:07:48pm

morningcalmcougar Playmaker

Than poorly executed. But, yes, should have been run to the wide side with a WR that can make the play in the ball and give the QB more room for error.

Report problem with this ad

morningcalmcougar

Bio page: morningcalmcougar
Joined: Apr 24, 2011
Last login: Nov 19, 2024
Total posts: 1,508 (14 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Gross - sorry if already been circulated here.

Gunga Galunga

7:46am

He’s gotta be hurt

KYU

7:46am

He’s hurt so we don’t give him redzone touches? And injured players can play

Ron Mexico

8:06am

Ok, bummer. Put in Moa who’s been an absolute beast. Or Ropati for that matter

bornbyu93

9:36am

That’s what I would do

KYU

9:54pm

I've been saying that since UCF. Seems like he's on a pitch count

MaximusMeridius

11:25am

It's what the defense was giving them. Just gotta go with it. The defense has only given the offense 3 opportunities

foofcoug

7:49am

RE: It's what the defense was giving them. Just gotta go with it. The defense

BYUfannonLDS

7:58am

I’ve noticed this, it’s crazy. He’ll play between the 20s and get pulled

palangi

7:51am

He was in on a read option play and would have walked into the end zone if

stansburycoug

10:07am

We just need to watch the film, love one another, etc

byuTX

7:52am

Oh, and a quick timeout

byuTX

8:17am

How many total plays inside the 10 did we run the last two games?

shoganai

7:52am

That's what I don't know but I can think of one game altering situation vs KU

Gunga Galunga

7:53am

Sample size is pretty important.

shoganai

7:54am

Throwing a fade on 1st & goal from the 5 for an INT does limit the amount of potential plays.

foofcoug

8:12am

Throwing an interception does. The route, itself, isn't really material.

shoganai

8:18am

The fact that an INT was thrown on the same route for a 2 point conversion the previous week means that it should not

foofcoug

8:22am

"This play failed last time, so we should never run it again," doesn't seem like

shoganai

8:28am

"I've seen this QB play for 2 years now and I know he struggles mightily with touch passes and hasn't gotten better...

foofcoug

8:38am

Retzlaff or ARod:

byuTX

8:44am

I think you're pretty much just making stuff up now.

shoganai

8:45am

Retzlaff's 2 known struggles - accuracy and touch passes. If it's not something that needs to be burned in there or

foofcoug

8:52am

I just think you're exaggerating and using a lot of hyperbole to jump to a

shoganai

9:01am

You're right, they shouldn't all be removed

stansburycoug

10:10am

Retzlaff hit Keanu Hill on that same play against SMU. I don’t recall you being outraged so maybe you missed that game.

Conan

10:59am

So he does it one time in a season and we are supposed to be thinking it is the

imdocrob

11:05am

Uh, yes. The matchup was there and the play has been successful in the past. Jake has shown that he can make that

Conan

11:23am

Ok by your standards...he has made that throw one time for a TD against

imdocrob

11:45am

Yes, I'm in favor of running successful plays until they aren't successful anymore.

Conan

12:22pm

A one time success does not equate to being successful...but yeah if we ran the

imdocrob

12:33pm

<< Deleted >>

NYC and Japan

1:21pm

You're logic also follows, just because the play failed against Utah, it isn't

NYC and Japan

1:26pm

I understand what you are saying but I think given the situation we were

imdocrob

2:56pm

I don't think the call was the issue (although i would have preferred we ran it on that down). The execution was poor.

BYUgoslav

12:24pm

Another reason why you don't call that play...you are going against a 4 year

imdocrob

12:34pm

They seemed to be running the ball so well on that drive, I would have liked to

BYUfannonLDS

8:20am

A different decision by the QB results in a TD. For an offense to be successful

shoganai

8:36am

It is also true of literally all pro, P4, G5, FCS, High school... QB and any

NYC and Japan

1:29pm

Three possessions worth on Saturday

BYU '80

9:01am

Looking at the play by play again, more than I remembered. Hinckley has been

JuicyJam

9:09am

Probably a combo of factors.

shoganai

9:19am

I love Ropati but he is not as good as LJ. From the small sample size I’ve

Coug98

11:58am

ARod absolutely loses his mind in the redzone.

maxpowers

8:31am

Until the 2nd half of the UCF game BYU was one of the top teams in the country

NYC and Japan

1:33pm

AMEN! Been screaming this since the last two games. Makes no sense. LJ is

Cougs2012

9:27am

And if it’s not LJ, put in Moa

TwinsRight

9:32am

Yes, why does Moa only get 1 carry, which he turned into a tough 12 yard gain,

robin

10:22am

That’s part of what made me so mad. Run it if you don’t get in you get a field goal before

NonmormonYfan89

9:34am

I’m more in favor of Moa inside the 10yd line

MHOP

9:53am

He’s been back for two games and gotten 2 carries both for over 10 yds a carry

Cougz19

11:08am

Patterns of Arod's idiocy. He needs to go, should have been gone years ago.

CObluezone

10:19am

How about Moa...every time that guy touches the ball he runs over guys...runs

imdocrob

10:46am

Wow! Just wow! Can't blame Jake when Arod doesn't know the best call to make.

Coug Dude

11:07am

I would hope we aren't blaming Jake for that play...it should have never been

imdocrob

11:47am

Fades are great inside the 10, if executed correctly. The TE was open, but the

morningcalmcougar

1:31pm

Again I say why throw it to the short side of the field...throw it to the far

imdocrob

2:58pm

Agree, that is why I made that the last sentence in my post. It is a good play

morningcalmcougar

3:12pm

By poorly executed I hope that means that you think they should have gone

imdocrob

3:18pm

Yep, we’re in n the same page. Maybe poorly designed is more accurate to say

morningcalmcougar

8:07pm

I was at the UCF game and noticed in crunch time when the offense was trying to

Coug98

11:27am

Hinkley and LJ are almost identical in YPC. 5.5 vs. 5.6 this season

NYC and Japan

1:38pm

But it’s not coaching

2FarGone

11:50am

We need to clean up his execution.

md7Coug

2:16pm

There is a good explanation for this

indocoug

5:28pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad