Why can’t an organization decide their own rules?

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 9, 2024
8:25:10am

Brigham Political Junky

Why can’t an organization decide their own rules?

Report problem with this ad

Brigham

Bio page: Brigham
Joined: Jul 6, 2001
Last login: Nov 12, 2024
Total posts: 23,507 (8 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

We're about one more case away from the NCAA losing all legal ability to enforce

shoganai

Nov 9, 7:49am

Where this will eventually land, imo: eligibility will be measured in games. Not sure how they handle post season, tho

Crazy Joe Davola

Nov 9, 7:59am

I doubt they could make that stand up legally.

shoganai

Nov 9, 8:50am

RE: We're about one more case away from the NCAA losing all legal ability to enforce

Crazy Joe Davola

Nov 9, 8:00am

The actual fix will have to come from congress. Just like NFL being a monopoly

maYbe

Nov 9, 8:12am

I think he'll lose on this one. it seems to me the reasoning behind his

cwilke1

Nov 9, 8:24am

I think part of the argument is that JUCO athletes aren’t governed by the NCAA. Why should the NCAA be allowed to care

TwinsRight

Nov 9, 8:44am

Would that same logic apply to someone who played overseas (see Boskovic)?

Odysseus

Nov 9, 8:54am

Good questions. Amateur status seems effectively already out the window. How long will there be a difference between

TwinsRight

Nov 9, 9:01am

<< Deleted >>

TwinsRight

Nov 9, 9:28am

because junior colleges work together with 4-year universities on academic

cwilke1

Nov 9, 9:09am

Ok. What about high school students that do dual enrollment and graduate with an associate’s degree?

TwinsRight

Nov 9, 9:29am

sure if the high school students play on the JUCO sports team then its totally

cwilke1

Nov 9, 9:34am

The NCAA has yet to successfully defend itself against any of these kinds of

shoganai

Nov 9, 8:48am

Why can’t an organization decide their own rules?

Brigham

Nov 9, 8:25am

It can, as long as its rules don't break existing law.

shoganai

Nov 9, 8:47am

and just because someone makes an antitrust argument doesn't mean they have a

cwilke1

Nov 9, 9:09am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad