We thought the same thing about Jake Retzlaff. I don't think it's fair to write

Nov 8, 2024
2:24:02pm

ldssdl Intervention Needed

off a freshman QB who was the backup then got thrust into a starter role due to injury, and struggled for his first 6 games. Especially when Whittingham has never proven he can produce a great offense.

Report problem with this ad

ldssdl

Bio page: ldssdl
Joined: Mar 3, 2013
Last login: Nov 8, 2024
Total posts: 31,442 (4,060 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Austin Collie on BYUSN: Starting Rose over Wilson would be the dumbest move

MaximusMeridius

2:01pm

I would love for Isaac to transfer to BYU and be a very successful quarterback.

Blue Ghost

2:03pm

I doubt he would come here

crablegs

4:25pm

If it's dumb, then do it. Frankly I don't think it's going to make any difference in the game

Indy Coug

2:03pm

I would not be sad if that turns out to be true.

HuskerFan2

2:04pm

Don't underestimate KWhitt's hubris. If he thinks he has a better chance to beat

TrueBlue67

2:04pm

I agree but I don’t know if it’s hubris - maybe just a different calculation

StoneyCurtis

6:45pm

Isn’t the story that he has lost the team and kinda forced their hand. That seem

Pepe

2:05pm

Who (allegedly) punched someone?

snowbird

2:13pm

Heard IW was involved somehow and police were called.

Soupie

2:22pm

You heard from a troll account that completely made it up as a joke

MaximusMeridius

2:22pm

Could be. Don't care enough to investigate hence the hedge.

Soupie

2:41pm

Thats why I'm letting you know

MaximusMeridius

3:09pm

Then don’t spread the rumors.

GoodGuyGary1

5:28pm

Hear this, Pepe? Quit spreading rumors.

Soupie

6:01pm

The locker room fight was made by a troll acct. There is no "if". It was a troll

MaximusMeridius

2:19pm

Maybe their philosophy is put the best QB on the field and maybe they’ve seen

Traveshamockery

2:06pm

They've seen three years of Rose and didn't see fit to give him a shot until

Jesse Pinkman

2:10pm

And Rose didn't look good. I'd go back to Wilson.

Madam Pattirini

2:13pm

Wilson has lost the locker room. They don't have a choice

runnincoug

2:09pm

Yep, this is it

Coug

2:10pm

Big if true.

Madam Pattirini

2:13pm

Exactly what I think too and I've posted it nearly word for word

MaximusMeridius

2:14pm

If true, Wilson is already going to transfer. No matter what else happens.

Lance71

2:15pm

Kind of similar to Zac loosing the Jet's locker.

BYURider

4:17pm

Didn't hear about that ... He performed poorly but was he a hot head too?

runnincoug

4:55pm

he lost the locker when he said he didn't disappoint the defense

BYURider

5:20pm

If there is one thing in this world that you can count on

kccougar

2:09pm

^^^this!^^^^***

theonick

5:28pm

I don't think Wilson is healthy.

byubyu

2:10pm

Also my theory. Hurt or at least banged up enough to not be effective.

Soupie

2:23pm

As a side note, Austin Collie is one of the best on air talents at BYU

MaximusMeridius

2:12pm

He's on the complete opposite side of the spectrum from Blaine Fowler, for sure.

cosmohio

3:03pm

Also, Wilson's a better QB. Rose is baaaaad.

Mostlyaccurate

2:12pm

Is that just based off the snaps he got last game? Or is there something

MaximusMeridius

2:16pm

My assessment is only based of past game. Interception to give the game away

Mostlyaccurate

2:25pm

If Wilson is truly their best QB on the roster then Utah is in trouble for 2-3 seasons.

Zach Morris

2:20pm

We thought the same thing about Jake Retzlaff. I don't think it's fair to write

ldssdl

2:24pm

I’ll bet you $500 Jefe bucks that Wilson never finds himself in the top half of national QB ratings. And while that may

Zach Morris

2:41pm

Maybe. I'm not saying Isaac will ever be as good as Zach, but in college,

ldssdl

2:52pm

Players make or break OCs — it’s not the other way around which is why you see an OC have a stellar year or two and

Zach Morris

3:05pm

No we didn't. Speak for yourself

MaxxPower

6:24pm

I actually didn't write Jake off in the offseason, if you care to check the

ldssdl

6:26pm

They truly have a Heaps/Nelson situation on their hands.

kccougar

3:08pm

Especially since he’s a freshman and is 21 points higher in efficiency than Retzlaff was last year. He could improve.

byuTX

3:11pm

Retzlaff had a far more difficult strength of schedule and virtually no run game backing him up. Wilson has had a fairly

Zach Morris

3:23pm

JR also wasn’t a true freshman and he definitely played worse than Wilson has this year

byuTX

3:47pm

JR was also not evaluated as a 4 star HS QB which is essentially a certification that your development is such that

Zach Morris

4:02pm

Wilson has been better this year than JR was last year. You might recall JR had the worst efficiency at BYU in 50 years

byuTX

5:18pm

I’m not “crapping” on IW. I’m sharing the same opinion I’ve had since I started watching him play his Jr. year of HS. I

Zach Morris

5:29pm

Wilson is bad. Retzlaff was worse last year

byuTX

5:33pm

Way to play with their heads, Austin! And underhandedly mock them too.

SinkingQuffa

6:32pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad