Because he was injured while playing an event organized by the university? It's

Nov 4, 2024
12:04:36pm

Incentivize All-American

not an unreasonable question. Possible his son signed his life away when he agreed to play though and they may wash justifiably wash their hands.

Report problem with this ad

Incentivize

Previous username: cvore
Bio page: Incentivize
Joined: Dec 18, 2001
Last login: Nov 5, 2024
Total posts: 7,186 (29 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

my son has a torn ACL injured playing intramurals at BYUI

gwill

Nov 4, 11:52am

Why should BYU cover ?

claw

Nov 4, 11:53am

Because he was injured while playing an event organized by the university? It's

Incentivize

Nov 4, 12:04pm

Son voluntarily played if they were responsible for every injury they would not

johnnybyu

Nov 4, 12:06pm

If you read my post I said the same thing. Guy's just asking...

Incentivize

Nov 4, 3:10pm

It is a completely unreasonable request for the school to pay.

DirtyWater

Nov 4, 12:10pm

Just asked if they do. No demands

gwill

Nov 4, 12:47pm

Understood. Was replying to a different post.

DirtyWater

Nov 4, 3:07pm

I seriously doubt it. I tore mine playing intramurals at BYU and it was all on my father's insurance.

Indy Coug

Nov 4, 11:53am

especially because intramurals are totally voluntary. Someone could argue for a

cwilke1

Nov 4, 11:55am

Same here. Looks like a few of us should have hung up the cleats lol

ChiCityCoug

Nov 4, 12:07pm

I did not make the claim that they did…just asked a question…I’m not putting

gwill

Nov 4, 12:51pm

Sorry about the injury. But I’d venture to say not a chance.

blackandblue

Nov 4, 11:53am

my guess is there was a waiver when he signed up for intramural’s

JOPE

Nov 4, 11:55am

Yup.

Viva Campeche

Nov 4, 11:55am

Waivers are almost never enforceable. The only way BYUI would be liable is if

reagan21

Nov 4, 11:57am

waivers of liability can certainly be enforceable, absent negligence

JOPE

Nov 4, 11:58am

I didn't say they are never enforceable.

reagan21

Nov 4, 11:59am

Most lawyers love to take on waivers. They’re more eye candy than people think

arcawley

Nov 4, 12:16pm

if there’s negligence or intentional conduct of course

JOPE

Nov 4, 12:23pm

This has been my experience. It helps deter some lawsuits, but they aren't 100%

morningcalmcougar

Nov 4, 1:44pm

Why would they pay for any of it?

Viva Campeche

Nov 4, 11:56am

That isn't going to happen

2FarGone

Nov 4, 11:56am

Doubt it. They’d shut down intramurals if they had to start paying for injuries.

Traveshamockery

Nov 4, 12:00pm

<< Deleted >>

Iman23

Nov 4, 12:02pm

geeze, what sort of insurance did you have?

TN_Coug

Nov 4, 12:04pm

<< Deleted >>

Iman23

Nov 4, 12:08pm

Sorry to hear about your son but also concerned why you would expect BYUI to

johnnybyu

Nov 4, 12:05pm

Where were the expectations?

gwill

Nov 4, 12:59pm

Assumption of the risk

BIG XII Coug

Nov 4, 12:09pm

Please don't. If every injured kid did this, the Church would stop putting gyms

runnincoug

Nov 4, 12:22pm

If they did that all intramurals would be cancelled for everyone. I’m sorry

Don Carlton

Nov 4, 12:22pm

Good opportunity to teach a YM too that when crap happens in life,

runnincoug

Nov 4, 12:51pm

My friend broke his leg playing intramurals years back. He paid his own bills.

Benfica1

Nov 4, 12:27pm

You sign a release of liability waiver before you can be put on a roster.

IGlowInTheDark

Nov 4, 12:31pm

not trying to force anything…just asked a question..no demands or expectations

gwill

Nov 4, 1:04pm

Fair question. My understanding is a school's liability only applies to official

Posting on CougarBoard