The CFP has been pretty reasonable in the past

Nov 3, 2024
10:24:44am

bythenumbers All-American

I have a hard time remembering a year where they absolutely missed. And this is the first year of 12. The reality is, the first team out this year will probably not have much of a shot to win it all anyway.

Report problem with this ad

bythenumbers

Bio page: bythenumbers
Joined: Mar 16, 2020
Last login: Nov 6, 2024
Total posts: 2,276 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU, you are our only hope.

Tesla Coug Lord of the Manor

Nov 3, 7:08am

I think if Iowa State wins out to the championship game and loses to BYU, they

Shinshin

Nov 3, 7:11am

Maybe if Texas tech can win out

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:17am

I think this is highly unlikely. I don’t think any 2-loss Big 12 team is going

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:27am

Not sure. But they would be 11-1 going into the CCG. An 11-2 team that only has

Shinshin

Nov 3, 7:32am

It’ll force the committee to show their cards. Do they put 10-2 Clemson who

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:44am

Clemson will end up 8-4 or 9-3

hdx57

Nov 3, 2:24pm

I don’t think Clemson gets an at-large bid with 2 losses. Their only chance now

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 3:04pm

If their loss had been to K-State or Colorado, then I would agree. But ISU lost

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:48am

There is still a lot of football left.

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 7:50am

Tuesday will bring a lot of clarity. Is Iowa state in the 15-18 range? Or 20-25?

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:56am

Historic CFP rankings show 11 win teams basically always in CFP and most 2 loss

NYC and Japan

Nov 3, 8:30am

I think there's also going to be more 11 win and 1-2 lots teams than ever before

Kajdin

Nov 3, 9:09am

But that's 11 win P5 teams. And there's a different environment now

krindorr

Nov 3, 9:20am

Don't buy into the P2 narrative. Big10 and SEC look just as bad/good as the Big

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 10:25am

And yet the B1G has 4 teams higher than any Big 12 team

krindorr

Nov 3, 12:41pm

Overrated. Sagarin has SEC #1, Big12 #2, Big10 #3, ACC #4

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 1:23pm

Sagarin also has BYU #3 in th Big 12

krindorr

Nov 3, 2:07pm

And I'm saying we shouldn't be buying into or furthering that false narrative

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 3:24pm

Fair, I'm trying to estimate what the committee will do, not what I think they should do

krindorr

Nov 3, 4:06pm

I've looked at this before. 11 win P5 teams would've generally always made it.

cougarfan84

Nov 3, 10:16am

I get where he’s coming from but he’s almost at that point where he’s asking

Don Carlton

Nov 3, 7:18am

He didnt ask us to root for a loss....

TheHop

Nov 3, 7:34am

That might be true and honestly I’m a huge conference fan and

Don Carlton

Nov 3, 8:01am

He knows we won’t cheer for a loss - just his way of saying what helps

truecougster

Nov 3, 9:42am

RE: He knows we won’t cheer for a loss - just his way of saying what helps

thirdgencoug

Nov 3, 10:25am

Yeah, he’s not wrong, yesterday was a bad day for the Big 12

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:19am

Go BYU!

Dark Forest Green

Nov 3, 7:25am

Having a home game in playoff will not be as good as you think…

BornBlue

Nov 3, 7:34am

It would be epic

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 7:35am

You have never been wronger

JimmyZ

Nov 3, 7:39am

The student section would still be maxed out

palangi

Nov 3, 9:00am

Would they still sell student section seats?

Dark Forest Green

Nov 3, 9:18am

I’m not sure how it works, but whether they sell them or student roc passes get

palangi

Nov 3, 9:58am

my son would absolutely make the 3 and a half hour drive back to Provo for game.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:51am

If only there were other fans in or around Utah that might attend a college FB

tony

Nov 3, 2:29pm

Drake doesn't get the BYU persecution complex yet. The committee would love an

Cheap Seats

Nov 3, 7:51am

To be fair, we haven't had a consistent team in a long time

JupiterJones

Nov 3, 8:43am

This is exactly it. Until we consistently put really good seasons together, then

brazilcoug

Nov 3, 9:35am

Maybe 5 programs that have been consistently good for any length of time.

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:06am

I get your point but you are confusing Vegas odds makers with pollsters

truecougster

Nov 3, 9:44am

Why do people keep saying this?

bythenumbers

Nov 3, 9:51am

Even ignoring BYU, why would you expect this?

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:10am

The CFP has been pretty reasonable in the past

bythenumbers

Nov 3, 10:24am

It gets more political with 12. WAY more money to conferences.

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:35am

How about look and see who is actually on the committee before making broad statements like this

DJROSS

Nov 3, 10:32am

I didn’t read any of that. Sorry

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:35am

I think there will likely be 3 bids in total for the Big 12 and ACC this year,

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 11:31am

we'll find out on Tuesday how the committee views BYU. Top 5-8 good. below bad.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:56am

Tuesday we'll know how they feel about a zero loss BYU. The point was how would

Cheap Seats

Nov 3, 1:55pm

if BYU starts out in the 5-8 range they will weather one loss in CCG.

qwerew

Nov 3, 3:39pm

That was a great segment. I agree 100%

boctabulous

Nov 3, 10:06am

Im pro byu first and B12 second. Byu needs to just win. In this day and age the

Magneto

Nov 3, 10:17am

He’s so wrong. B12 needs byu to win the NC

Dr MoBYU

Nov 3, 11:15am

So he’ll root for us until the championship game and then turn on us so the auto

byuinva

Nov 3, 11:43am

I won't hold that against him. He's a fan and rep of the Big12.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:54am

WIN THE CONFERENCE

ninja math

Nov 3, 1:43pm

I want to win out. Period.

runningryan

Nov 3, 3:15pm

RE: BYU, you are our only hope.

Cooouuugs

Nov 3, 4:55pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad