The point is BYU could be 5-0 and ranked and people would still be calling for

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 30, 2024
7:14:29am

Pepe All-American

The point is BYU could be 5-0 and ranked and people would still be calling for

Coaches to get fired. Sometimes it is justified but there will always be a coach that the fans are upset with and think isn’t good enough. The low hanging fruit is gone so now it’s Arod everyone has decided to be upset with. I’m trying to remember the last time CB was happy with an OC, I don’t think it has happened in my lifetime.

Report problem with this ad

Pepe

Bio page: Pepe
Joined: Dec 21, 2019
Last login: Sep 30, 2024
Total posts: 4,333 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Trying to understand the ARod hate. BYU scored more points than any opponent

NYC and Japan

Sep 29, 9:59pm

Bad play calling in the 2nd half against Baylor

WJCougar

Sep 29, 10:02pm

I went back and rewatched the game. His play calling was fine. Aggressive even.

PJMort

Sep 29, 10:09pm

The worst play call was the third and 2 that resulted in a pick. That should

RalphWiggam

Sep 29, 10:25pm

Uuuh, it wasnt just a single game— its been years of head scratching competence

Sep 29, 10:35pm

The play calling was fine, it was the execution that was the problem.

TempeCoug

Sep 29, 10:38pm

Tuiaki and Funk are gone, there has to be a new CB whipping boy.

Pepe

Sep 29, 10:02pm

So they didn’t deserve criticism?

vegas guey

Sep 29, 10:08pm

Yeah I think CB criticism of those two coaches has held up extremely well

bythenumbers

Sep 29, 10:10pm

Yet there are dozens of Cougarboarders riding in like knights in shining armor

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:25pm

The point is BYU could be 5-0 and ranked and people would still be calling for

Pepe

7:14am

I don’t believe I was calling for him to be fired. But I was and am criticizing

Helm Hammerhand

8:25am

We should not want to strengthen our weakest points? I am not calling for a

SoBlueitHurts

3:17pm

Arod is not our weakest point at all.

TempeCoug

3:19pm

Easy to defend an OC that is scoring lots of points and winning. Those are 2 of

NYC and Japan

7:23am

So, 3 games against quality-ish competition has produced about 41 points on

SoBlueitHurts

3:26pm

BYU has the 2nd best Strength of Record. BYU is winning against tough teams.

NYC and Japan

3:33pm

That does not mean the offense has performed to par either. I love 5-0 and the

SoBlueitHurts

3:55pm

Those guys are gone and, what do you know? Things got better

Beggar

Sep 29, 10:26pm

things like running 96% of the time on 2nd and long.

cruiserhead

Sep 29, 10:02pm

…and then throwing on 3rd and short when we need to run clock

cougarblue

Sep 29, 10:04pm

And I believe that ended in interception.

Sep 29, 10:24pm

I mean 96% of OCs do this to get to more manageable 3rd downs

B Blue

Sep 29, 10:06pm

I agree. Coaches are avoiding 3rd and 10. I think this is common.

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:07pm

Fair point.

cruiserhead

Sep 29, 10:11pm

Nice arbitrary number. He deserves criticism.

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:21pm

You know the 96 percent was the from the poster that says we run on

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:26pm

My bad, I’ll take the L on that one. You are right.

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:30pm

What percentage is it really? I’m curious what the average rate is of running

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:06pm

3 points in the 2nd half against Baylor - Complaints are about his tendencies after getting a nice lead.

cougXor

Sep 29, 10:06pm

Would have loved to have less injuries at lineman and RB.

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:10pm

Yes…prevent offense. That could be as much Kalani tho too.

cruiserhead

Sep 29, 10:12pm

Two underthrown trick plays that could have been TDs and a dropped basically TD

Boring

Sep 29, 10:37pm

Because fans don’t know what each play should look like vs what happened. And

macdizzle

Sep 29, 10:09pm

Alabama would be saying the same thing about their coaches if it weren’t for

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:12pm

They were saying the same thing, my in laws are from Alabama, their group text

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:17pm

Stupid comment, a lot of fans know football.

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:18pm

What OC in our history hasn't gotten flak? That's human nature.

Genghis Spreads

Sep 29, 10:12pm

I’m guessing most OCs get this treatment

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:14pm

I'd says all that I can remember.

Genghis Spreads

Sep 29, 10:15pm

My dad yelled "C'mon NORM" at Norm Chow for 20 years whenever a play didn't get

Bald Eagle

Sep 29, 10:30pm

It’s not hate, it’s criticism. There is a difference. He doesn’t need CB’s

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:20pm

Many are obsessed with twisting win after win with BYU scoring THIRTY FOUR or

NYC and Japan

Sep 29, 10:52pm

That’s not me and several others. Criticism is warranted. I don’t want him fired

Helm Hammerhand

8:30am

I want him to be better. However, there are many that post regularly that ARod

NYC and Japan

10:17am

Let's not let data cloud the conversation here. Stick with the approved narratives please

Bob Vance

Sep 29, 10:24pm

What data, like 3 points in the 2nd half? Is that the kind of data you speak of?

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:28pm

So does Arod get super duper lots of credit for 31 points in the first half?

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:31pm

Sure, but you’ve got to finish the game. That’s the rub, the first half showed

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:38pm

BYU is 74th in total offense and 119th in 3rd down conversion

Beggar

Sep 29, 10:31pm

Good data points but we showing progress on offense the last two weeks

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:33pm

I’ll agree their is progress, but still room for criticism. Constructive

Helm Hammerhand

Sep 29, 10:40pm

No argument there. Everyone needs to step up play callers

NYCougz

Sep 29, 10:42pm

The first stat is misleading because of the K-State game which the offense

wildeone

1:34am

He really tends to panic, doing things in high pressure situations that don't

Sep 29, 10:42pm

A team scored more points on SIU than we did?!! Fire A-Rod!

andrewg3

Sep 29, 11:17pm

I’m convinced that some on here would complain if BYU squeaked out an NC.

ImuaKahuku

5:43am

You’ve got blinders on. There’s always room for improvement and criticism.

Helm Hammerhand

8:34am

Not blinders. Truth. There are many on CB that would still be complaining about

NYC and Japan

10:20am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad