I’ll take Ohtani over Judge any day of the week.

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 29, 2024
8:20:15pm

Jelly Man Playmaker

I’ll take Ohtani over Judge any day of the week.

Report problem with this ad

Jelly Man

Previous username: (Private)
Bio page: Jelly Man
Joined: Jan 5, 2005
Last login: Sep 29, 2024
Total posts: 1,423 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Aaron Judge didn’t really have a peer in the MLB this season. 2nd place in OPS

8:03pm

Aaron Judge just had the best season at the plate from a right handed hitter in MLB history. All-time. Ever.

TCuz

8:19pm

I’ll take Ohtani over Judge any day of the week.

Jelly Man

8:20pm

LOL. Ok

byujacob

8:21pm

If Judge could pitch I would go with Judge, but he can't

AZ Coug

8:26pm

Ohtani couldn’t pitch this year either, and let’s wait to see if when he does

8:43pm

That doesn't change the fact that Judge is a defensive liability at this point

AZ Coug

8:49pm

<< Deleted >>

9:09pm

I’ve watched almost every Yankees game. Any defensive liability is negligible.

9:11pm

The numbers tell a different story. He's significantly slower getting to

AZ Coug

9:14pm

I’m not seeing glaring mistakes when he plays, so I guess I’m saying bottom end

9:17pm

20 of 22 or 22 of 22 isn't bottom of middle. It's bottom of the bottom.

AZ Coug

9:18pm

I may not be following here… how are there only 22 with 30 teams?

9:21pm

There are only 22 players who have played over 700 innings in CF this season

AZ Coug

9:41pm

According to baseball savant Judge has been worth -3 runs in the field, but

9:31pm

Add the impact of a Cy Young caliber starter who is 2 years younger than Judge

AZ Coug

9:42pm

But that is to be seen… who knows if he will be as good post surgery.

9:46pm

Maybe they moved him to RF next year?

Spiff

9:19pm

That would make sense. He's 32. He's slowing down. Keeping him in CF is stupid.

AZ Coug

9:21pm

His defensive stats have been trending down. He used to be very good.

TCuz

9:14pm

Right field is where I think he belongs, but my baseball knowledge is nowhere

9:21pm

Yah he’s an atrocious defender. The fact that he’s only slightly below average this year

TCuz

9:24pm

Let me put this “defensive liability” in context. According to Baseball Savant, Judge has been worth -3 runs defensively

TCuz

9:27pm

Judge has been very disappointing in the postseason. He needs to change that

garyfan

9:10pm

Yep. Career 39% strikeout rate in the postseason.

AZ Coug

9:16pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad