Not a single personal attack there. All data driven and hard to argue. Good post

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 8, 2024
6:28:16am

blackandblue Truly Addicted User

Not a single personal attack there. All data driven and hard to argue. Good post

Report problem with this ad

blackandblue

Bio page: blackandblue
Joined: Aug 12, 2011
Last login: Sep 16, 2024
Total posts: 25,606 (2,684 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Jake Retzlaff: He is who we thought he was (or should have thought he was.)

tkh9

Sep 8, 1:54am

RE: Jake Retzlaff: He is who we thought he was (or should have thought he was.)

MarylandFan

Sep 8, 3:18am

The most promising guy is always the backup QB, right? That is until he turns...

GMGlenn

Sep 8, 8:12am

But if he never gets the opportunity to prove himself, how will we know? Gerry

Sep 8, 9:53am

I'll take an underdog win like that every day of the week and twice on Sundays,

Team Chaos

Sep 8, 5:27am

ummmm. We don't play on Sundays....

TheHop

Sep 8, 7:39am

Where did OP say that Retzlaff is the only problem? One problem at a time. Stay on subject.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Sep 8, 8:19am

At his best, he's an average or slightly above average QB. Factor in turnovers

tony

Sep 8, 5:39am

I think that is incredibly generous TBH

byuTX

Sep 8, 6:07am

He is not accurate enough to be average.

shimmy

Sep 8, 6:14am

Jake might have played the best in camp, but we all know Jake’s problems start

Short_Changed

Sep 8, 6:42am

Jake’s don’t like getting hit in games a guess… First a Heaps, now a Retzlaff..

cougarmikey

Sep 8, 11:36am

That’s the thing. Gerry has started lots of D1/P4 games. He isn’t the best but

BYU'01

Sep 8, 1:50pm

Jake is ranked in top half of The Big 12 in most categories in an article

Cougarbib

Sep 8, 3:25pm

Last yr only 1 D1 player threw as many passes as JR with a lower pass efficiency

BYU'01

Sep 8, 5:59pm

Nice deflection.

Cougarbib

Sep 8, 8:27pm

Deflection? Time will tell? Time has told pretty clearly Taking 1 FBS game and

BYU'01

Sep 8, 8:41pm

It was a deflection because you never even commented even though the ranking is

Cougarbib

Sep 8, 8:45pm

He is not an average P4 QB, not even close. Outside of SIU, he has barely been

Duke Silver

Sep 8, 6:42am

A 50% thrower is a bad qb, imo.

Sep 8, 11:45am

The coaches are fools if they don't play both QB's this Saturday. It's the last non conference game..

Coug

Sep 8, 6:21am

Didn’t they say it on one of our games that coaches asked JR if he was

Lefty24

Sep 8, 7:46am

Not a single personal attack there. All data driven and hard to argue. Good post

Sep 8, 6:28am

Not so fast with the fumbles, buddy.

Sep 8, 6:46am

Taysom Hill had 9 fumbles in 2016. 4 fumbles in 4 games in 2014.

MarylandFan

Sep 8, 7:02am

A few things.

Sep 8, 7:19am

#2 - a ton to make up for it? Like what?

MarylandFan

Sep 8, 7:23am

RE: #2 - a ton to make up for it? Like what?

Sep 8, 7:33am

Hill threw 4 interceptions and lost that game against Dallas in that GIF

MarylandFan

Sep 8, 9:27am

Also, running/ option QBs are intentionally in more situations likely to fumble

NYC and Japan

Sep 8, 7:22am

But so many qbs are running qbs and Jake doesn’t even run much

BYU '80

Sep 8, 8:56am

About a dozen times a game. Positive net yards every game. Not running focus,

NYC and Japan

Sep 8, 1:36pm

RE: Not so fast with the fumbles, buddy.

tony

Sep 8, 8:53am

Not so fast, my friend…

tkh9

Sep 8, 10:41am

We have a large sample size now. How many lost games are we willing to accept…

Lombardi

Sep 8, 7:02am

We were double digit underdogs and won on the field. What loss are we accepting

travelcoug

Sep 8, 7:07am

When you win DESPITE your offense, then

Sep 8, 10:49am

Does anyone know if the broken play he fumbled on was his fault or RB's?

MarylandFan

Sep 8, 7:16am

It was supposed to be a jet sweep. The snap was mistimed.

tkh9

Sep 8, 7:35am

Jake Y/A = 5.2 last year. Jake Y/A = 9.5 right now. I think the worst thing they could do right now is bottle

mokelembembe

Sep 8, 7:18am

Part of the problem is that Across reaction to the TO problem is to throw really

tkh9

Sep 8, 7:55am

How do you know it’s on ARod? We’ve seen multiple examples on replay

BYU '80

Sep 8, 8:57am

We can agree that not every underneath throw is called as the primary target.

tkh9

Sep 8, 10:45am

There is no such thing as overemphasized controlling TOs

DirtyWater

Sep 8, 1:10pm

So how did he get one TO if not a pick and wearing green/yellow/red jerseys?

ImuaKahuku

Sep 8, 7:59am

RE: So how did he get one TO if not a pick and wearing green/yellow/red jerseys?

tkh9

Sep 8, 10:56am

He’s also late on every throw. Even big yardage throws receivers have to come

Longseason

Sep 8, 8:30am

And he also doesn’t see the field well at all!

kahuna

Sep 8, 8:49am

Yes, he’s clearly not seeing downfield. He’s often just biding time to throw the

cougsareforreal

Sep 8, 2:06pm

I said this back a week before fall camp ended his fumbles are an issue

BulldogCoug79

Sep 8, 9:35am

This is Kalani's moment, I hope he too doesn't fumble it.

miblue

Sep 8, 10:29am

RE: Jake Retzlaff: He is who we thought he was (or should have thought he was.)

icecougar

Sep 8, 11:59am

Fixable. Needs to fix it fast. The picks need to stop - might be harder to fix!

Cougarbib

Sep 8, 12:56pm

RE: Jake Retzlaff: He is who we thought he was (or should have thought he was.)

JackieMoon33

Sep 8, 2:34pm

QBs can evolve. Young and Detmer had a lot of TOs. He's not them (yet) we'll see

Celeritas

Sep 8, 2:49pm

Lol He’s not even Matt Berry or Brett Engemann.

byuTX

Sep 8, 4:21pm

RE: QBs can evolve. Young and Detmer had a lot of TOs. He's not them (yet) we'll

JackieMoon33

Sep 8, 5:50pm

Young's 5 TOs cost BYU a win against a top 10 Georgia on the road.

Celeritas

Sep 8, 6:56pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad