You can't leave Giff, Wilson, or Bosco off.

Report problem with this ad

Aug 26, 2024
8:58:06am

shakarocks All-American

Report problem with this ad

shakarocks

Bio page: shakarocks
Joined: Dec 2, 2004
Last login: Sep 17, 2024
Total posts: 15,038 (409 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Mount Rushmore of BYU football 🏈 ….Taysom Hill 🏈

44C

Aug 25, 10:33pm

Unfortunately, Taysom isn't even on the Mt Rushmore of BYU QBs.

d-coug

Aug 25, 10:36pm

I’d put John Beck and Max Hall above Taysom as well. Taysom is a heck of an athlete but BYU has had better QBs from a

Zach Morris

Aug 25, 10:37pm

Impossible to say, but maybe he would be had he stayed healthy.

Trent

Aug 25, 10:39pm

Marc Wilson and Gifford Nielsen are both higher than Hall and Beck

AF Cougar

Aug 25, 10:40pm

Wouldn’t disagree.

Zach Morris

Aug 25, 10:41pm

if you’re strictly going, BYU QB…JMac, Ty, Steve, Marc, Giff

44C

Aug 25, 10:53pm

Definitely leave out the one that won our one and only Natty.

Cougarbib

Aug 25, 11:51pm

Wasn’t our best team, wasn’t our best QB

44C

Aug 26, 7:16am

Yeah 23 consecutive wins wasn't our best team. How many drafted by NFL?

Les IsMore

Aug 26, 9:43am

Not a popular opinion, but I agree

Hill4Heisman

Aug 26, 11:13am

Logic fail. QB wins NC supported by good but not great team playing with leg

Cougarbib

Aug 26, 12:29pm

Yeah but...

RebelScum

Aug 25, 10:41pm

No doubt about it, Taysom was and is a phenomenal runner and athlete. Always just an ok to good passer but never great.

Zach Morris

Aug 25, 10:44pm

More than anything he was limited by injury. Who knows what would have happened if he stayed healthy. Especially in 2014

mvtoro

Aug 26, 12:35am

I agree, I wouldn’t put him in the top 10 of best BYU QBs

D.T. Survivor

Aug 25, 10:52pm

didn’t ask Mount Rushmore of QBs

44C

Aug 25, 10:45pm

How do you put them ahead of Taysom... Easily

jpesk2

Aug 25, 11:08pm

Impact on BYU has to do with on and off the field at BYU and after BYU

44C

Aug 26, 12:10am

Changing the goalposts to justify your Taysom crush?

Les IsMore

Aug 26, 9:46am

I would agree …..there are probably 10 QBs better than Taysom at BYU

44C

Aug 26, 5:05am

Totally agree. Giff and Marc are also ahead of Taysom

VB2

Aug 26, 9:50am

RE: Mount Rushmore of BYU football 🏈 ….Taysom Hill 🏈

Eddie

Aug 25, 10:37pm

love him but he's not sniffing that mtn, sad he got hurt as often as he did.

4mack

Aug 25, 10:42pm

Are we judging on college or NFL careers? If NFL, then here's the top 5 IMO

runnincoug

Aug 25, 10:45pm

Fred Warner is building a strong case to get on that Rushmore

GlutealGuy

Aug 25, 10:48pm

Puka is too soon but agree Fred could make the case too

runnincoug

Aug 25, 10:50pm

Agreed, just saying Puka is certainly on track to crack the list

GlutealGuy

Aug 25, 11:18pm

sometimes it’s easy to get caught up in the thrill of the moment.

44C

Aug 25, 10:50pm

Jason Buck, John Tait, and Pitta would be pretty high, as well

Mabuhay Coug

Aug 26, 1:44am

You left off Andy Reid

AF Cougar

Aug 26, 6:51am

Deserves to be there too!

runnincoug

Aug 26, 9:19am

You have a great point

44C

Aug 26, 9:40pm

Stahlie was a beast

Blueto

Aug 25, 10:49pm

Who is this Stahlie guy?

BYU Grounds

Aug 26, 1:20am

I'd put McMahon, Detmer, Collie, Jamaal, and TA on offense. Van Noy, Buck, Jorgensen, Dewey, and Rob Morris on

ManicBlue

Aug 25, 10:56pm

I don’t think NFL success counts toward College Career impact

wildwilderness

Aug 25, 10:57pm

The 1984 Championship doesn't happen without BYUs strong NFL presence.

ParentingNotForSissy

Aug 26, 9:32am

100 percent correct. College success vs NFL is completely different. I wouldn’t

bookofdaniel

Aug 26, 9:46am

KVN?

WhyaskY?

Aug 25, 11:02pm

Tri B D

44C

Aug 25, 11:57pm

He may be the most "what could have been" player BYU football has ever had.

Incentivize

Aug 25, 11:11pm

Taysom still had the 12th highest career passing yardage and easily the best rushing stats by a QB in BYU history.

ManicBlue

Aug 25, 11:18pm

Tied with Ben Olson

vagabonder

Aug 26, 12:07am

I put him way over Olson on this. Taysom proved and continues to prove he was elite at that level and elite in his own

mvtoro

Aug 26, 1:04am

Of current NFL guys? his college career was just injuries and wrecking Texas

vagabonder

Aug 26, 12:08am

Taysom?

TheHop

Aug 26, 4:40am

The first four on the list are your Mt Rushmore. LaVell, Jimmie Mac, Steve, Ty

SouthernCoug

Aug 26, 6:39am

My Rushmore of BYU athletes, not QBs. Not an insult at all. He might be the

MormonThug

Aug 26, 6:54am

Max Hall forever

nybyblue

Aug 26, 6:57am

Taysom is one of the greatest "What ifs?" in BYU football history

RockyBalboa

Aug 26, 7:02am

KVN 100%

ImuaKahuku

Aug 26, 7:19am

Maybe in some BYU fan and teammate eyes TH not 1 Pro Bowl. Seems definitively no

NYC and Japan

Aug 26, 7:20am

Luke should be on there too.

coolblue

Aug 26, 7:25am

Your first four are the answer

Tuskaloosa Cougar

Aug 26, 7:28am

Jimmer too. He was so big he deserves to be on every BYU sports Mt Rushmore. 🙂

ImuaKahuku

Aug 26, 7:35am

Not Gifford. He got injured too early in his senior year.

Brisco

Aug 26, 8:42am

You can't leave Giff, Wilson, or Bosco off.

shakarocks

Aug 26, 8:58am

Only room for four, so....

Happy As Larry

Aug 26, 11:08am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad