If we took KY's 4 highest rated recruits in the last 3.5 months, and took Sitake's 4 highest recruits in the last 9 years, which group of 4 would be higher rated?

It just might be KY's guys wouldn't it? I don't know if Sitake has ever had a true 5 star recruit (in fairness it's not like his predecessors had a bunch of them either).

I'm not a Sitake hater - I think he's a phenomenal human being and exactly the right kind of disciple of Christ to represent BYU well - but I'll admit I've been a little underwhelmed with his recruiting classes and I think it might be possible KY has done more in 3.5 months when it comes to elite recruits than Sitake has done his whole 8 or 9 years.