My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 7, 2024
2:36
:27
pm
kimdaddy35
Former Fly Half
RE: Still a moronic take.
https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=33024519
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
kimdaddy35
Bio page
kimdaddy35
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Last login
Nov 13, 2024
Total posts
50,914 (1,535 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I am genuinely curious. What are compelling reasons why you feel confident in
TheMediator
May 7, 1:38pm
I don't think there are any posters here who are truly confident in Kalani as HC
Beggar
May 7, 1:42pm
They would be in the minority and are in denial or they don't care about on field results as much as most fans
byuTX
May 7, 1:50pm
There are plenty. Don’t fool yourself.
Idacoug
May 7, 1:55pm
There is a difference between confidence and contempt. I wouldn't call myself
spidercoug
May 7, 2:15pm
Nobody hates him. He's as likeable as it gets for a CFB HC. I hope he turns it around but right now he's not P4 caliber
byuTX
May 7, 4:04pm
I am one of many who are confident in Kalani Sitake as BYU's Head Coach!
MadHawaiian
May 7, 2:55pm
RE: I am one of many who are confident in Kalani Sitake as BYU's Head Coach!
Mathew
May 7, 3:30pm
He just needs to get back to the office and check the film, right?
byuTX
May 7, 4:03pm
Kalani is NEVER going to throw anyone under the bus, so expect that answer
BYURider
May 7, 4:28pm
RE: Kalani is NEVER going to throw anyone under the bus, so expect that answer
byuTX
May 7, 4:52pm
well, we've heard that response how many time now???
BYURider
May 7, 4:58pm
And each time it's 100% accurate.
gopman
May 7, 6:43pm
Ouch!
gopman
May 7, 5:29pm
How many more losing seasons should be tolerated?
gopman
May 7, 5:28pm
I find it odd that you make a very specific definition of what is success
kimdaddy35
May 7, 1:42pm
Success should be defined or else you live in a purgatory-state of apathy, like
TheMediator
May 7, 1:51pm
In 8 years he's had teams finish #11 and #19. he's gone
cougarfann888
May 7, 1:43pm
Yes, they are far off
HairyCougar
May 7, 1:46pm
It's literally the same
spidercoug
May 7, 1:49pm
He said he would expect in 10 years
cougarfann888
May 7, 1:50pm
<< Deleted >>
Benfica1
May 7, 2:02pm
Let’s take out the 11-1 season. That was playing against North Dakota school
Chefcurry
May 7, 2:03pm
It's not that much worse than some of the early wac years
cougarfann888
May 7, 2:09pm
17 players on that team made it to the NFL. That was a good team.
spidercoug
May 7, 2:12pm
Raw talent doesn't always guarantee a good team.
ldssdl
May 7, 2:29pm
I don't see 17 players from that team in the NFL.
coolblue
May 7, 3:58pm
At some point they did make it to nfl
niqmadu
May 7, 6:47pm
<< Deleted >>
Benfica1
May 7, 2:16pm
Worst schedule in program history.
kimdaddy35
May 7, 2:18pm
<< Deleted >>
Benfica1
May 7, 2:26pm
RE: Still a moronic take.
kimdaddy35
May 7, 2:36pm
I am always concerned about people who fear high expectations
2FarGone
May 7, 1:50pm
My thinking is that it took 3 straight bad seasons
BlueFever
May 7, 1:50pm
Yep. He was innoculated from firing these 1st 2 B12 seasons: you gotta give the
Forzaitalia
May 7, 4:01pm
How many more losing seasons should be tolerated?
gopman
May 7, 5:31pm
0 more b/c of the 3 in-season collapses. Make Sitake some sort of public-facing
Forzaitalia
May 7, 5:52pm
I get ya but firing Sitake isn't as difficult as many think here.
gopman
May 7, 6:26pm
Nice point and hope those money men can exert influence. I'll believe it when
Forzaitalia
May 7, 6:45pm
I want to see what the 2nd year in the BIG12 looks like. He's been at
BYURider
May 7, 1:52pm
How many more losing seasons should be tolerated?
gopman
May 7, 5:32pm
first year in the BIG12 gets a pass. If he has a loosing season in 24, the heat
BYURider
May 7, 7:25pm
Regardless of coaching, do you see any bump BYU can get as a B12 member?
m1k3l33
May 7, 1:53pm
I don't. But we dont have other LDS options.
AltTabbins
May 7, 1:53pm
There are lots of n options.
cougarfann888
May 7, 1:58pm
We'll see how Jay does this year. He's unproven at P4 level.
AltTabbins
May 7, 2:08pm
Uhm.....with Big 12 money we can now afford the following:
gopman
May 7, 5:36pm
My understanding is that this years class of recruits/portal pickups is much
PhilPete
May 7, 1:55pm
BIG12 / P4 bump!
BYURider
May 7, 1:58pm
RE: My understanding is that this years class of recruits/portal pickups is much
imdocrob
May 7, 2:00pm
RE: My understanding is that this years class of recruits/portal pickups is much
imdocrob
May 7, 2:04pm
Hillstead is a great pickup. I’m also not a fan of A-rod’s play calling.
PhilPete
May 7, 2:12pm
RE: Hillstead is a great pickup. I’m also not a fan of A-rod’s play
imdocrob
May 7, 2:16pm
I wouldn't call it abyssmal. The TE from California was a big get. Tei Nacua
BYURider
May 7, 2:20pm
I like Kalani and am glad he’s at BYU. I think he’s assembled a good staff.
WallaX2
May 7, 2:02pm
If BYU doesn't make a bowl he is gone, I think even if they do
CougLyfe
May 7, 2:04pm
I doubt it. He will be around at least 2-3 non bowl seasons before actions taken
AltTabbins
May 7, 2:09pm
I disagree. I can see him keeping his job one more year if he
gopman
May 7, 5:43pm
please make it so
MrSandman
May 7, 3:28pm
It seems that Kalani is meeting your definition of high-level success
BYU Fan
May 7, 2:10pm
RE: It seems that Kalani is meeting your definition of high-level success
imdocrob
May 7, 2:14pm
Personally I don't believe Kalani can turn things around again
BYU Fan
May 7, 2:17pm
Try to keep in mind that BYU has been at a recruiting disadvantage compared to other P5 teams by being an Indy program.
ManicBlue
May 7, 2:22pm
But has BYU been at a recruiting disadvantage because of their coach?
kimdaddy35
May 7, 2:25pm
IMO, most of that falls on Lamb & Tuiaki's recruiting. Fortunately, both are gone. Let's see what happens going forward.
ManicBlue
May 7, 2:35pm
That he is slow to learn is well established and a permanent feature
vegas guey
May 7, 2:52pm
I don't think he's slow to learn at all. He was just slow to fire one of his best friends/family member.
ManicBlue
May 7, 2:58pm
That was a bad hire to begin with, so just bad executive instincts
vegas guey
May 8, 8:39am
RE: IMO, most of that falls on Lamb & Tuiaki's recruiting. Fortunately, both
imdocrob
May 7, 3:53pm
Guys from small schools get drafted into the NFL all of the time. Not every P4 reject player does. Just saying, you
ManicBlue
May 7, 4:00pm
RE: Guys from small schools get drafted into the NFL all of the time. Not every
imdocrob
May 7, 4:12pm
Sure most are from P5 schools but not normally the guys transferring from P5 schools. There is a difference you know.
ManicBlue
May 7, 4:28pm
you get what you pay for, and those coaches were the best BYU could get for what
BYURider
May 7, 4:32pm
I don't disagree but I'm also betting Kalani could have found better than those two for what BYU was paying even if they
ManicBlue
May 7, 4:37pm
You don’t even know who was doing the “heavy lifting” dude. Stop pretending
puntersarepeople
May 7, 4:14pm
so why didn't Jay Hill recruit like this at Weber?
BYURider
May 7, 4:34pm
How many more losing seasons should be tolerated?
gopman
May 7, 5:44pm
What compelling evidence do we have that any BYU coach can consistently rank in
Southpawn
May 7, 3:22pm
Your premise is laughable. Essentially saying he's not competent, then prove you
OldFogey
May 7, 3:24pm
He was hamstrung with a low coaching budget
donnerstag
May 7, 3:39pm
RE: He was hamstrung with a low coaching budget
imdocrob
May 7, 4:10pm
Did you notice that we got a new tight end coach and Oline coach?
donnerstag
May 7, 4:15pm
RE: Did you notice that we got a new tight end coach and Oline coach?
imdocrob
May 7, 4:59pm
RE: Did you notice that we got a new tight end coach and Oline coach?
imdocrob
May 7, 5:00pm
Grimes left after the 2020 season, so the 2021 season was ARod's
donnerstag
May 7, 5:11pm
RE: Grimes left after the 2020 season, so the 2021 season was ARod's
imdocrob
May 8, 9:04am
ARod has been the OC since halfway through 2019 per Criddle
puntersarepeople
May 7, 5:16pm
Reasons to be confident
MadHawaiian
May 7, 5:20pm
RE: Reasons to be confident
imdocrob
May 8, 9:05am
Kalani's teams have averaged 8 wins/season in 7 seasons. How does that compare?
Happy As Larry
May 7, 5:51pm
It's recency bias plus a few fans are still traumatized from 2017
donnerstag
May 7, 6:11pm
RE: Kalani's teams have averaged 8 wins/season in 7 seasons. How does that
imdocrob
May 8, 9:09am
He scores off the charts in some categories. Others like leadership, vision, recognition of problems and course correct
Blue2thebone
May 7, 6:23pm
IMO, you are ignoring all of the negatives Kalani had to deal with before BYU finally got the Big 12 invite.
slatecoug
May 7, 6:59pm
How about this…
Pretorian
May 7, 7:07pm
RE: How about this…
imdocrob
May 8, 9:12am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad