I did not say the odds were slightly good. It was her job. Nobody bats 1.000,

Apr 29, 2024
9:43:36pm

Cougarbib Intervention Needed

but roster retention was not as good as expected. Coaching her daughter made it even tougher. Maybe she should have hired Shaylee’s mom as assistant head coach. That would have retained Shaylee if she also fought for a large enough bag for her.

Report problem with this ad

Cougarbib

Bio page: Cougarbib
Joined: Jul 28, 2003
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 40,950 (111 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Easy for negative pundits on CougarBoard to "rate" & "downgrade" Coach Whiting

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:31pm

Coach Whiting and her staff are building this program and they will get the

WallaX2

Apr 29, 6:40pm

Calling out CB for something that isn't happening is reaching. Pls show sources.

Ripliancum

Apr 29, 9:08pm

Amen! The success of the program has nothing to do with the head coach!

RdF3

Apr 29, 6:40pm

That's not what I said & you know it - I don't appreciate you twisting my words

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:43pm

Who are you even arguing against? Everything I've ever seen is almost all positive about her.

RdF3

Apr 29, 6:47pm

There has been some hard criticism about her, especially with her HS background

arcawley

Apr 29, 9:13pm

I admit criticizing her eyelashes and the blue gum she chews. I have been

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:19pm

RE: Amen! The success of the program has nothing to do with the head coach!

TheSpiker

Apr 29, 6:47pm

<< Deleted >>

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:49pm

<< Deleted >>

TheSpiker

Apr 29, 7:03pm

I haven't seen her or the program mentioned in days.

Eddie

Apr 29, 6:42pm

Exactly. Everyone knows she hasn’t met expectations but not all her fault

VirginiaPeanut

Apr 29, 8:19pm

What do you mean that she hasn’t met expectations? They were picked 13th

TempeCoug

Apr 30, 1:33am

Hope she can build it. Hopefully, the 2 new transfers help but their shooting

CougGolf

Apr 29, 6:44pm

Maybe, it was me.

jlhazlewood

Apr 29, 7:32pm

RE: Maybe, it was me.

tjerbear

Apr 29, 11:24pm

Who knows what happened with Falatea? It seems she has hung up the sneakers.

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 1:28am

Transferring to Ore.

Soupie

Apr 30, 7:28am

Is she still engaged to the new KC Chiefs 2nd round draft pick?

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 11:48am

IDK but she was in his draft day video hugging him so I'd assume so.

Soupie

Apr 30, 11:52am

Does anyone know what really went down with Falatea?

CougGolf

Apr 30, 6:58am

If you're all-state and from 3A, I get it.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 1:55pm

Another big who specializes in 3pt shooting!

SinkingQuffa

May 1, 6:44am

Look at season stats for those 2. Those are not the losses that hurt. Gustin,

Cougarbib

May 1, 7:52am

I have supported Whiting since Day 1 & still do. She has struggled some adapting

Forzaitalia

Apr 29, 6:44pm

Do you have a link to reference? Guess I may have missed it.

Soupie

Apr 29, 6:48pm

Wait a minute. I thought CB did not care about women's basketball?

Hoopster

Apr 29, 6:50pm

Posts like this are so strange. ANY coach ANYWHERE is going to have some detractors. I'm sure even SC's coach has some

jacobugath

Apr 29, 7:12pm

Her team is in big trouble next season if they can’t get more and capable bigs.

LeGrandBleu

Apr 29, 7:30pm

So true. Big12 has some big ladies… we don’t need ISU’s big, but Gustin’s build with more height

Cougarpride

Apr 29, 9:55pm

LakeshowCougs

Apr 29, 7:33pm

She's struggled (as expected), but she needs more time. Her recruiting continues to impress.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 29, 7:33pm

She definitely made a splash with her first recruiting class

cajuncoug

Apr 29, 9:09pm

Her claiming of Gibb from the yewts was a pretty big deal. Yewts are legit under Roberts

SinkingQuffa

Apr 29, 11:23pm

Juddy was an excellent coach and usually had the team in contention. Juddy

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 1:30am

No disrespect intended but Juddy was a lazy coach the last two

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 1:58pm

“Admitted as much”, LoL. Link? I would be very interested in his exact words -

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:40am

I like her. Also haven't seen the criticism. Also, why is none of the turnover

Incentivize

Apr 29, 7:37pm

Because she had to start 2 Freshman guards right away because the 2 starters

CMAC38

Apr 29, 7:48pm

It was her job to retain Shaylee, Nani, etc., and replace the no shows. Tough

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:32pm

For Shaylee to stay it could not have been Whiting’s job. 😂

Soupie

Apr 29, 9:37pm

I did not say the odds were slightly good. It was her job. Nobody bats 1.000,

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:43pm

You have it wrong.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 8:33am

It was her job to retain and make it work or replace with better. Nobody bats

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 11:55am

My problem with your comment is that the program was already built.

andrewg3

Apr 29, 8:56pm

Are these negative pundits in the room with you now? Haven't heard them.

Ripliancum

Apr 29, 9:02pm

I know nothing about how she'll do here but I have a question for you.

Mitty

Apr 29, 9:22pm

Yes. She often played her starters at the end of blowouts. Made no sense

VirginiaPeanut

Apr 29, 9:35pm

When she did try subbing the other team went on runs.

CMAC38

Apr 30, 8:28am

I feel asleep once I realized you were talking WBB

D.T. Survivor

Apr 29, 9:37pm

When she accepted the BYU Women’s Head Coach she became a public figure.

Bullrider

Apr 29, 10:35pm

In fact, vast majority of us were confused by this post it's been so light. I'm sure she's a big girl & can handle it

Soupie

Apr 29, 11:07pm

I just hope her leading scorer next year can shoot more than 50% FTs.

BW84

Apr 29, 11:49pm

I hope they all improve to the 80's. Seriously improve.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 2:02pm

you cited the late 3 game win streak as proof of her coaching ability, but we

cwilke1

Apr 30, 4:44pm

Gosh! Aren't you the pessimist? We finished ahead of where

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 6:42pm

You seem to get upset by facts. He simply stated facts. BTW, I support Coach

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 8:34pm

I think generally I'm pretty fair to her. I'm not overly pessimistic. You can

cwilke1

Apr 30, 9:11pm

Kalani and Pope have both seen large numbers of transfers out at times

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:09pm

I think she ought to be judged by a quite different standard. She inherited a

cwilke1

Apr 30, 10:27pm

Sounds like extreme assumptions embedded there based on very small sample size

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:33pm

assumptions about what? My post didn't include assumptions. We can see the

cwilke1

Apr 30, 10:37pm

It sounds like implications about “can’t get along with players…”

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:58pm

Whiting faces the challenge any coach faces when they coach their own kid

Cougarbib

May 1, 1:00am

BYU WBB has as good of support as a typical WBB team - probably better

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:58am

yes but its not comparable to the men. Men are top 25 for home attendance.

cwilke1

May 1, 6:44am

Juddy regularly fielded very competitive teams.

Cougarbib

May 1, 7:54am

and I think Coach Whiting will too given enough time. Judkins by no means had a

cwilke1

May 1, 8:04am

“If”. I would be happy in year 3 with a team comparable to the last 2 Juddy had.

Cougarbib

May 1, 8:09am

When they happen you fix it. We are going into year 3. Will it be fixed?

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:55am

Some if the transfers are not that talented and should be quite replaceable if

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:45am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad