I am a bigger dude and do my best to accomodate my fellow fans, but I'm not going to go spread eagle and inconvenience those next to me because you think you, in your canvas-back chair, want to watch the game from my lap.
I have enjoyed getting to the know the people around me at games over the years, most of whom have made the game experience that much more enjoyable. But if you're recliner guy, your back and my knees are going to be ones who get acquainted.
It'd be fine by me if BYU were to knock the price of the seats down a bit and put in a policy--possibly with the exception of the visitor's section--that you use our chairs or don't bring them at all.