Sep 27, 2022
12:50:31pm
12:50:31pm
Of course it’s debatable. We’re here debating it. I’m not saying Jaren isn’t great or even that his stats aren’t better.
You can make the argument that they are.
I’m saying having watched both live in HS and college, having attended practices for both at BYU, having watched all of their snaps at BYU and seeing the development of both over time… Beck is a better passer.
This isn’t a statistical argument I’m making. This is evaluating each in terms of arm talent and vision. Beck developed to throw a better, more accurate ball, see the field better, and to read earlier and better in his passing game. To make lesser receivers look better than they were. Hall could still become better at these things, but he hasn’t yet. But yes, you can certainly make the statistical argument that he has. That’s fine.
I’m saying having watched both live in HS and college, having attended practices for both at BYU, having watched all of their snaps at BYU and seeing the development of both over time… Beck is a better passer.
This isn’t a statistical argument I’m making. This is evaluating each in terms of arm talent and vision. Beck developed to throw a better, more accurate ball, see the field better, and to read earlier and better in his passing game. To make lesser receivers look better than they were. Hall could still become better at these things, but he hasn’t yet. But yes, you can certainly make the statistical argument that he has. That’s fine.
- Bio page
- mvtoro
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2006
- Last login
- Dec 25, 2024
- Total posts
- 13,702 (851 FO)
Messages
Time
9/27/22 10:12am
9/27/22 2:11pm
9/27/22 2:11pm
9/27/22 10:19am
i still don't have the confidence in him that I had with Wilson, Max, Beck (Sr. yr) or Sark. By the end of the year
9/27/22 10:30am
9/27/22 6:16pm
9/27/22 10:32am
9/27/22 10:56am
9/27/22 4:27pm
9/27/22 11:00am
9/27/22 11:07am
9/27/22 11:08am
9/27/22 11:08am
9/27/22 2:12pm
I wouldnt compare Hall to Detmer, I think he is a better, more athletic version of Senior Year John Beck.
9/27/22 11:53am
9/27/22 12:22pm
Of course it’s debatable. We’re here debating it. I’m not saying Jaren isn’t great or even that his stats aren’t better.
9/27/22 12:50pm
I mean, you can make fun of it, but literally anyone who evaluates players professionally can see the difference between
9/27/22 1:24pm
Sound good, bro. No one is saying they are the same. In case you missed the OP he was comparing Hall to Detmer.
9/27/22 4:00pm
I didn’t make an appeal to authority. I just explained where I’ve watched them and specifically said you *don’t* have
9/27/22 5:08pm
I would bet that Jaren Hall gets drafted similar to where Beck was drafted, but that he will have a better career.
9/27/22 6:25pm
9/27/22 2:13pm
9/27/22 1:16pm
9/27/22 1:27pm
9/27/22 1:35pm
9/27/22 2:10pm
9/27/22 2:14pm
9/27/22 2:16pm
9/27/22 4:29pm
9/27/22 5:39pm