Thumbs up on putting your opinion out there. Not everybody has to agree. That

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Aug 11, 2022
3:58:01pm

rcbyufan Truly Addicted User

Thumbs up on putting your opinion out there. Not everybody has to agree. That

said, your placement of Marc Wilson below Sark, Beck, and Hall

Report problem with this ad

rcbyufan

Bio page: rcbyufan
Joined: Aug 18, 2010
Last login: Nov 26, 2024
Total posts: 33,227 (1,170 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A deep dive into the greatest players of all-time at BYU. Let's start with QB.

kimdaddy35 Future Lions Scout

8/11/22 3:51pm

7 O's, that has to be my all time best.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 3:57pm

Thumbs up on putting your opinion out there. Not everybody has to agree. That

rcbyufan

8/11/22 3:58pm

I'm not sure anyone will 100% agree with my opinion which is OK. I did a fair amount of research into the stats and

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:00pm

I don't know what 'greatest' means in these kind of conversations

Avery

8/11/22 4:03pm

That is the thing. It is a combination of many things including, even to a lesser extent NFL history.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:07pm

I think you have Sheide too low. Dude started the whole thing.

Peter Venkman

8/11/22 4:05pm

That is fair, my rebuttal would be that yes he started it (well really LaVell, but he was the first QB) but others

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:09pm

If Lavell had a schlub QB for 73/74 he probably would've been fired

Peter Venkman

8/11/22 5:00pm

Riley Nelson shouldn’t even be sniffing this list.

kotacoug

8/11/22 4:10pm

I have positive memories of Nelson while I know many of you don't, that is where I cut the list off at.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:14pm

He’s so far below the others just leave him off.

kotacoug

8/11/22 5:30pm

Who would you swap Nelson with?

8/11/22 4:29pm

Jaren Hall

8/11/22 4:49pm

Jaren Hall would already be higher than Nelson as I said, but I am leaving him off my list until his

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:52pm

I skimmed and missed it. Thanks for compiling it.

8/11/22 5:10pm

Not quite eligible from how the OP is doing this.

8/11/22 5:03pm

Your list is pretty close to mine. 4-8 is the hardest to sort out.

Coop

8/11/22 4:27pm

It is very hard. You could make an argument for any of them to be higher or lower.

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:36pm

Good stuff. I do think Sark is high on this list

UVCoug

8/11/22 4:31pm

If you are looking at longevity stats then certainly Hall at 8 is way too low. He started 3 years which basically

kimdaddy35

8/11/22 4:39pm

Walsh is too high. He was the biggest weakness of the very good 94 team, drunk

88Coug

8/11/22 5:04pm

Detmer and Bosco

Y05

12/30/22 4:25pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad