If Watkins would have played 4 yrs and averaged his average he would be the #2

Report problem with this ad

Apr 26, 2022
6:39:08pm

kotacoug Truly Addicted User

Receiver by yards all time at BYU.

Report problem with this ad

kotacoug

Bio page: kotacoug
Joined: Jul 20, 2002
Last login: Mar 15, 2025
Total posts: 83,672 (4,838 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Rank the following WR duos

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 4:45pm

Glen Kozlowski and Mark Bellini

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 4:46pm

Gosh, they were something else.

ebv

4/26/22 5:14pm

Probably as good as any pair, but neither is Puka Nacua.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:29pm

Kozlowski and Bellini were actually better than Nacua.

BleedCougarBlue2

4/26/22 8:53pm

Neither of them had the physical presence of Nacua.

Belboz

4/26/22 8:59pm

But there is a good argument that they're the best pair as I hinted below

Belboz

4/26/22 9:06pm

Puka and Gunner are likely the best assuming they stay healthy with Watkins and Collie right there

kimdaddy35

4/26/22 4:47pm

RE: Puka and Gunner are likely the best assuming they stay healthy with Watkins

ebv

4/26/22 5:15pm

Gunner is way over rated. Collie/Watkins…. Both had special elite level skills.

kotacoug

4/26/22 6:21pm

Gunner is going to finish minimum in Top 10, possibly top 5 all time BYU rec yds

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:30pm

If Watkins would have played 4 yrs and averaged his average he would be the #2

kotacoug

4/26/22 6:39pm

Austin Collie is at the top

sailorcoug11

4/26/22 4:52pm

Collie with any other of those receivers is the best duo.

juantoad

4/26/22 7:49pm

Danny Plater/Clay Brown

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 4:52pm

TE, but sure.

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 5:17pm

And if we do that, Mili and Lewis are the best pair ever.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:48pm

They were rarely on the field at the same time

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 6:14pm

I recall them on the field together many times.

Belboz

4/26/22 7:27pm

Doubt the ran double TE often.

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 8:58pm

Well then you're wrong. They did.

Belboz

4/26/22 9:00pm

Watkins and Collie, Nacua and Romney, Hoffman and any #2 reciever, Milne and Romney, Hooks and Pittman,

PJMort

4/26/22 4:54pm

^^^ THIS ^^^

cambo

4/26/22 5:34pm

What about Collie and Michael Reed? Two strong seasons together

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 4:58pm

Did Andy Boyce and Eric Drage ever start together? I know their careers overlap

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 5:05pm

They did in 1990. But Drage only had 6 rec during Boyce’s senior year.

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 5:15pm

Austin Collie may be my favorite BYU player ever.

provoprodigy

4/26/22 5:06pm

Might be my favorite BYU receiver ever, but...that field is getting pretty

84 natlchamps

4/26/22 6:01pm

Manning threw him into those concussions

SwanSong

4/27/22 12:31am

After this year? Puka and Gunner

D.T. Survivor

4/26/22 5:17pm

1 - Watkins/Collie 2 - Nacua/Romney 3 - Hoffman/Ridley 4 - Milne/Romney 5 - Hooks/Pittman

Pimpin4Paradise

4/26/22 5:19pm

That looks about right. Of course, #7 and #11 from 84 and 85 aren't on list.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:27pm

1) Collie/Watkins 2) Koz/Bellini 3) Puka/Gunner 4) Hooks/Pittman

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:01pm

Puka and Gunner have potential to be #1 if they both are healthy this year

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:02pm

Puka Nacua could be the best to ever play receiver at BYU

Belboz

4/26/22 9:14pm

Hooks/Pittman was really good combo in 99 and 00. wish they had better QBs

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:03pm

This is the problem ranking WRs. It all depends on the QB and the system

Gorgias

4/26/22 6:21pm

Or Mahe/Hooks Mahe/Pittman were very good

Posting on CougarBoard