This is the problem ranking WRs. It all depends on the QB and the system

Apr 26, 2022
6:21:50pm

Gorgias Playmaker

But it also goes to show how great Hoffman was considering he only ever had fair to good QB, but never really anything great.

Report problem with this ad

Gorgias

Previous username: BoilerCoug
Bio page: Gorgias
Joined: Oct 8, 2009
Last login: Mar 14, 2025
Total posts: 2,514 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Rank the following WR duos

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 4:45pm

Glen Kozlowski and Mark Bellini

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 4:46pm

Gosh, they were something else.

ebv

4/26/22 5:14pm

Probably as good as any pair, but neither is Puka Nacua.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:29pm

Kozlowski and Bellini were actually better than Nacua.

BleedCougarBlue2

4/26/22 8:53pm

Neither of them had the physical presence of Nacua.

Belboz

4/26/22 8:59pm

But there is a good argument that they're the best pair as I hinted below

Belboz

4/26/22 9:06pm

Puka and Gunner are likely the best assuming they stay healthy with Watkins and Collie right there

kimdaddy35

4/26/22 4:47pm

RE: Puka and Gunner are likely the best assuming they stay healthy with Watkins

ebv

4/26/22 5:15pm

Gunner is way over rated. Collie/Watkins…. Both had special elite level skills.

kotacoug

4/26/22 6:21pm

Gunner is going to finish minimum in Top 10, possibly top 5 all time BYU rec yds

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:30pm

If Watkins would have played 4 yrs and averaged his average he would be the #2

kotacoug

4/26/22 6:39pm

Austin Collie is at the top

sailorcoug11

4/26/22 4:52pm

Collie with any other of those receivers is the best duo.

juantoad

4/26/22 7:49pm

Danny Plater/Clay Brown

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 4:52pm

TE, but sure.

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 5:17pm

And if we do that, Mili and Lewis are the best pair ever.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:48pm

They were rarely on the field at the same time

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 6:14pm

I recall them on the field together many times.

Belboz

4/26/22 7:27pm

Doubt the ran double TE often.

SoValleyCOUG

4/26/22 8:58pm

Well then you're wrong. They did.

Belboz

4/26/22 9:00pm

Watkins and Collie, Nacua and Romney, Hoffman and any #2 reciever, Milne and Romney, Hooks and Pittman,

PJMort

4/26/22 4:54pm

^^^ THIS ^^^

cambo

4/26/22 5:34pm

What about Collie and Michael Reed? Two strong seasons together

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 4:58pm

Did Andy Boyce and Eric Drage ever start together? I know their careers overlap

Captain Stubing

4/26/22 5:05pm

They did in 1990. But Drage only had 6 rec during Boyce’s senior year.

Fake Gary Sheide

4/26/22 5:15pm

Austin Collie may be my favorite BYU player ever.

provoprodigy

4/26/22 5:06pm

Might be my favorite BYU receiver ever, but...that field is getting pretty

84 natlchamps

4/26/22 6:01pm

Manning threw him into those concussions

SwanSong

4/27/22 12:31am

After this year? Puka and Gunner

D.T. Survivor

4/26/22 5:17pm

1 - Watkins/Collie 2 - Nacua/Romney 3 - Hoffman/Ridley 4 - Milne/Romney 5 - Hooks/Pittman

Pimpin4Paradise

4/26/22 5:19pm

That looks about right. Of course, #7 and #11 from 84 and 85 aren't on list.

Belboz

4/26/22 5:27pm

1) Collie/Watkins 2) Koz/Bellini 3) Puka/Gunner 4) Hooks/Pittman

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:01pm

Puka and Gunner have potential to be #1 if they both are healthy this year

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:02pm

Puka Nacua could be the best to ever play receiver at BYU

Belboz

4/26/22 9:14pm

Hooks/Pittman was really good combo in 99 and 00. wish they had better QBs

arizonacougarfan

4/26/22 6:03pm

This is the problem ranking WRs. It all depends on the QB and the system

Gorgias

4/26/22 6:21pm

Or Mahe/Hooks Mahe/Pittman were very good

Posting on CougarBoard