Dialogue is more than half of what makes a good movie….

Jan 28, 2022
10:30:40pm

ByuImaginesDragons Truly Addicted User

I don’t get all the hate for her writing. It’s not like it’s horribly cheesy like the ever popular Star Wars…they had some baaaaad dialogue. Sure there’s some cheesy/bad lines but most of them are fine.

Report problem with this ad

ByuImaginesDragons

Previous username: Byu Badger
Bio page: ByuImaginesDragons
Joined: Sep 18, 2001
Last login: Jun 8, 2022
Total posts: 35,487 (181 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Internet Explorer

1/28/22 10:14pm

I don’t know about that. But definitely the best trilogy.

Tim to some

1/28/22 10:16pm

The ending of Return of the King could have been its own movie….it just kept going

Finestcitycoug

1/28/22 10:17pm

Exactly, they really shouldn't have cut the Scouring of the Shire. Ending needed to be longer.

durandal

1/28/22 10:20pm

For a movie it wouldn’t make sense to have a big ending where the battle is “won

ByuImaginesDragons

1/28/22 10:24pm

My HCBW couldn't stop laughing at the end when I diagnosed Frodo with PTSD

libertycoug

1/29/22 1:04am

RE: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Magathis

1/28/22 10:17pm

RE: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

DieHarder

1/28/22 10:20pm

^^parents told him Santa wasn’t real when he was two^^

ByuImaginesDragons

1/28/22 10:26pm

I never watch the theatre versions anymore. The extended ones are better

ByuImaginesDragons

1/28/22 10:21pm

They did a mostly credible job of translating an epic story to the screen and

oxcoug

1/28/22 10:25pm

Dialogue is more than half of what makes a good movie….

ByuImaginesDragons

1/28/22 10:30pm

Agreed - and as long as she stuck primarily to Tolkien's dialogue it was great

oxcoug

1/28/22 10:33pm

How do you know he “defaulted”. Maybe he honestly just likes how she writes

ByuImaginesDragons

1/29/22 12:24am

It's openly known in the industry that there was zero recruiting or vetting of

oxcoug

1/29/22 12:10pm

Too bad he blew it with the hobbit.

NVCougar

1/29/22 1:16pm

If Tremors would have stopped after the 4th movie it would be Tremors. The 5th

BYUheaven

1/28/22 10:28pm

Of his many roles, this role was the most ideal for KB.

Q-grr

1/29/22 6:48am

I love Lord of the Rings but I will have to give the original

FT487

1/28/22 10:30pm

Best movie?

Joe Banks

1/28/22 10:35pm

Are you sure you don't have a brain cloud?

Ted Lasso

1/28/22 10:48pm

RE: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

kcca

1/28/22 11:04pm

That videos really funny

ByuImaginesDragons

1/29/22 12:24am

Greatest trilogy. Far from greatest movies. That's extreme hyperbole.

777

1/28/22 11:33pm

Greatest movies ever made by far?

Medute

1/28/22 11:41pm

RE: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy

MormonDevil

1/29/22 12:06am

Love them but best movies of all time? I don’t think so. Many Jackson decisions

canofpicante

1/29/22 12:50am

Except for the end of the 1st not matching the book.

Updating...

1/29/22 1:09am

Suck.

Posting on CougarBoard