So it’s not weird and aggressive to tell people the version you like is better

Report problem with this ad

Jul 18, 2021
9:42:22am

russkiejedi Intervention Needed

than the other, but it IS weird and aggressive to disagree with that take and say you like the original better?

Report problem with this ad

russkiejedi

Bio page: russkiejedi
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Sep 27, 2024
Total posts: 140,163 (56,406 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

What are your favorite song(s) where the cover was better than the original?

Negative Equity

7/17/21 11:12am

With a Little Help From My Friends, Joe Cocker

BYUHawk

7/17/21 11:15am

Just gave it a listen. Love it.

Negative Equity

7/17/21 11:20am

All along the watchtower — Hendrix

BlackHawkCoug

7/17/21 11:16am

Turn the page- Metallica. Fast car- Jonas blue. Higher Love- Kygo. Holy diver- killswitch engage.

RdF3

7/17/21 11:17am

Johnny Cash —Hurt

Cosmodiar

7/17/21 11:19am

Mmmmnope

Probable Sacko

7/17/21 11:22am

It is so much better than the NIN version.

BYUtka

7/17/21 11:25am

Most of the music sites and experts I see generally consider it one of the top 5

SoCalCoug

7/17/21 12:12pm

That’s because it is a great cover. It just isn’t better than the original.

Probable Sacko

7/17/21 12:33pm

It is infinitely better. The original is not worth listening to. Just like

BYUtka

7/18/21 9:38am

And there you have it. You have a bias against NIN. That’s okay, but you aren’t being impartial here. I like Cash and I

Probable Sacko

7/18/21 9:51am

Elton John's cover of "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds".

RC Vikings

7/17/21 11:25am

You Really Got Me - Van Halen

Belboz

7/17/21 11:19am

At least until Iron Maiden covers Copacabana

Belboz

7/17/21 12:35pm

Not a favorite, but “I Will Always Love You” was iconic Whitney…and better than

Iman23

7/17/21 11:19am

This was the very song I was thinking. Whitney's version is one of the more...

CougaReb

7/19/21 3:12pm

I agree Whitney's is better, but I do really like Dolly's version

A_blue_car

7/23/21 9:14pm

99 Red balloons- Goldfinger, Hurt- Johnny Cash, Mad World- Gary Jules

BYUtka

7/17/21 11:21am

The original Mad World is so much better. That guy gets way too much credit for

russkiejedi

7/17/21 2:19pm

Pete Townshend’s version of “Save it for Later”

BoiseBlue

7/17/21 11:21am

Tool’s cover of Led Zeppelin’s No quarter

Probable Sacko

7/17/21 11:23am

Who’s Lovin’ You - Jackson 5

BGRTHNUMEGO

7/17/21 11:25am

I Heard It Through The Grapevine - Marvin Gaye

BGRTHNUMEGO

7/17/21 11:26am

This Woman’s Work - Maxwell

BGRTHNUMEGO

7/17/21 11:27am

We Can Work It Out - Stevie Wonder

BGRTHNUMEGO

7/17/21 11:29am

Boys of Summer, covered by The Ataris

Greg Kite's 'stache

7/17/21 11:26am

I like the song but I don’t think anything compares to Don Henley’s version.

RdF3

7/17/21 11:36am

That one belongs to Don Henley only

RC Vikings

7/17/21 11:43am

Great cpver that i like,but not "better " 5han henkey

CarolinaCoug

7/17/21 2:39pm

Oh me — Nirvana (unplugged)

BlackHawkCoug

7/17/21 11:28am

A lot of good covers in Unplugged

Probable Sacko

7/18/21 9:52am

You were always on my mind, Pet Shop Boys

Kid_A

7/17/21 11:28am

I remember an SNL skit regarding that

Belboz

7/17/21 11:43am

Sound of Silence - Disturbed

Parabellum

7/17/21 11:29am

😬 You're about to get torched

BYUALWAYSNUM1

7/17/21 12:02pm

Respectfully and completely disagree

Clark Addison

7/17/21 12:16pm

That’s hilarious, but a very Hard and emphatic no.

TeeKaa

7/17/21 12:57pm

To each their own, but no.

Zastava

7/17/21 1:17pm

Seems to have become the cool thing to do on CB to hate Disturbed. But this song

PGVikingDad

7/18/21 7:54am

Oh ah ah ah ah!

Jay Rick

7/18/21 9:35am

So it’s not weird and aggressive to tell people the version you like is better

russkiejedi

7/18/21 9:42am

Where in the world did this question come from? Did I say anything like that?

PGVikingDad

7/18/21 6:43pm

Turn the Page, Breadfan and Whiskey in the Jar - Metallica

BlackBart

7/17/21 11:30am

Metallica is the best cover band ever.

Blue Cat

7/17/21 11:59am

I do like DM but Smashing Pumpkins' Never Let Me Down

Kilgore Trout

7/17/21 11:30am

Aerosmith's cover of Come Together.

John Doe

7/17/21 11:37am

Nothing Compares 2 U. Both Chris Cornell and Sinead O'Connor versions are better

Cougarmayn

7/17/21 11:38am

All 3 are great. Can’t pick a favorite.

BGRTHNUMEGO

7/17/21 11:41am

I'm not a fan of the original. Too much going on.

Cougarmayn

7/17/21 11:44am

SO’s version makes the original unnecessary.

Jay Rick

7/17/21 11:59am

the Sinead O'Connor version is one of my all-time favorites; the best, IMO.

CougaReb

7/19/21 3:14pm

Superstar, Sonic Youth

Kid_A

7/17/21 11:39am

The album If I Were a Carpenter is full of great covers.

bluesloth

7/17/21 1:05pm

Probably not a popular take, but I liked Himesh Patel’s version of…

Zastava

7/17/21 11:39am

People are Strange- Echo and the Bunnymen, Sgt. Pepper- Jimmy Hendrix

BYUtka

7/17/21 11:43am

Like A Rolling Stone — covered by Anberlin

WorfoSAUR

7/17/21 11:44am

Sweet Caroline. covered by Neil, originally I heard it by Elvis

BlueTooth

7/17/21 11:45am

And then finally, this cover was made and the world has a good version of that song

Cru Jones

7/17/21 3:22pm

Smashing Pumpkins - Landslide.

RalphWiggam

7/17/21 11:48am

Fleetwood Mac's version is one of my favorite songs ever, and I still

SoCalCoug

7/17/21 12:13pm

Taylor Swift. Santa Baby.

Cougazul

7/17/21 12:06pm

Pretty much any of the iterations of Hallelujah other than Leonard Cohen’s

Hambone

7/17/21 12:16pm

True. Jeff Buckley and Rufus wainwright both did it better.

Jay Rick

7/17/21 12:25pm

And Buckley's is number 1.

Loon to the Moon

7/17/21 2:47pm

Cinematic Pop ftw

Negative Equity

7/17/21 1:28pm

I love Cohen's version. It's a dirty, gritty version that I think best captures

SoCalCoug

7/18/21 4:35pm

Anthrax - Got the Time

Jeffacka

7/17/21 12:31pm

James Bond Theme. Movie version much better than the original.

UCLACoug

7/17/21 12:32pm

Cum on Feel the Noize and Bette Davis Eyes. Both examples of covers that

hansel

7/17/21 12:44pm

Judas Priest - Diamonds & Rust, Green Manalishi

CougSilver

7/17/21 12:46pm

I’m a total hack, but you nailed it. Good ones.

Probable Sacko

7/19/21 6:30pm

Led Zeppelin’s “In My Time of Dying”

MormonDevil

7/17/21 12:52pm

Take Me to the River - Talking Heads

bluesloth

7/17/21 1:03pm

Venus - Bananarama

BYUBandfan

7/17/21 1:09pm

Eric Clapton’s unplugged version of his own song - Layla

Forest Green

7/17/21 1:28pm

America by Yes

kmcougar

7/17/21 1:29pm

Ritchie Havens - Just Like a Woman

bluesloth

7/17/21 2:32pm

Zombie by bad wolves maybe?

CarolinaCoug

7/17/21 2:40pm

Eva Cassidy fields of Gold.

Cougarclaw

7/17/21 5:08pm

King of Anything - Just Like the Record

Beest

7/18/21 12:56am

Garth Brooks “Calling Baton Rouge”

SpiffCoug

7/18/21 9:40am

Popped up this morning on my shuffle (forgot it was a cover): Diamonds and Rust, Judas priest version (Joan Baez)

Probable Sacko

7/18/21 9:53am

Romeo and Juliet. The Killers version is better than Dire Straits.

BE-WHY-YOU

7/19/21 12:29pm

Train - “Ramble On”

mvtoro

7/19/21 8:00pm

I've heard Train do ramble on in San Diego in a hotel ballroom..

So it goes...

7/19/21 8:11pm

I actually like their version too. It’s a good song. I just wanted to troll a bit, and undervaluing Led Zepplin is a

Posting on CougarBoard