Just because a player is not good

Report problem with this ad

Oct 23, 2017
11:16:46am

Goatnapper'96 All-American

is not proof, nor even an indicator, that the back up is better.

Report problem with this ad

Goatnapper'96

Bio page: Goatnapper'96
Joined: Apr 9, 2001
Last login: Nov 10, 2024
Total posts: 18,641 (144 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Tanner is a headcase BYU needs changes at QB

BLEEDBYUFOOTBALL

10/23/17 11:14am

Worst case Critchlow can stare down his receivers and throw late to covered guys

DapperDan

10/23/17 11:15am

At this point in time we are living a worst case scenario...nothing to lose

TheLoneCougar

10/23/17 11:24am

Just because a player is not good

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 11:16am

Which is a scary truth

Turnpike Lane

10/23/17 11:19am

No but at this point he can't be any worse

IceBlueCoug

10/23/17 11:19am

He could be much worse.

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 11:21am

? 2nd worse offense in all of football...how much worse could anyone be?

Fdnman

10/23/17 1:35pm

Compelling point. But the argument that a player is hurt

QBarrister

10/23/17 2:10pm

You'd think that, but you'd be wrong.

russkiejedi

10/23/17 11:29am

What would be worse losing by 17 points or by 20 points? Losing is losing

IceBlueCoug

10/23/17 11:30am

RE: What would be worse losing by 17 points or by 20 points? Losing is losing

russkiejedi

10/23/17 11:38am

Exactly

IceBlueCoug

10/23/17 11:41am

Losing by 20 points is worse. What’s the point in making a change if it is likely going to be worse?

The Dude Abides

10/23/17 11:43am

It makes fans feel better.....

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 11:53am

At this point in the season, no possibility of a bowl game, no player leadership, I would like to see what

IceBlueCoug

10/23/17 11:58am

I get you want to see that. But coaches do see what he can do. Every day of the week. It’s not good.

The Dude Abides

10/23/17 12:06pm

But fans need to see and know their opinions are shared

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 12:10pm

How do you know, "it's not good"? Some players are gammers. Need to see.

blackshirts

10/23/17 5:55pm

I guess but you've seen him in limited game action. Did it look like he was a gamer? Anyway, where does the

The Dude Abides

10/23/17 6:04pm

I(we) don't know. I do know TM isn't getting it done, next man up.

blackshirts

10/23/17 10:35pm

At what point though do you say every meaningful opportunity has lead us

Bob Vance

10/23/17 11:23am

When Y is ready....

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 11:28am

I agree with this.

Brigham

10/23/17 11:33am

Yep.

CalGTR

10/23/17 12:10pm

The backup isn't better

donnerstag

10/23/17 11:25am

I will say I will be surprised if Mangum is the starter next year.

Goatnapper'96

10/23/17 11:29am

I think it passes test for relevancy.

CosmoK

10/23/17 11:35am

Why aren't BYU's backups ever at least capable of doing anything? Seems a lot

Ash

10/23/17 1:13pm

So. Doesn't mean you should give the back up a try. Why not try and see what he

ColonelMustard

10/23/17 6:55pm

Just like Taysom Hill, right?

MoscowCoug

10/23/17 11:16am

#hottakes

Chareth Cutestory

10/23/17 11:18am

Beau is a better option, I don't understand the reluctance to play him.

Northern Blue

10/23/17 11:21am

Proabably because his head fell off

DapperDan

10/23/17 11:22am

CTE

Fetchin Fetcher

10/23/17 11:22am

Because he can't play without getting a concussion. His playing days arrae

Skeptical Optimist

10/23/17 11:26am

Hoge would be QB right now if able to play. We can only play the guys that are available, and among that group Tanner

CalGTR

10/23/17 12:08pm

Tanner has definitely shown the infamous Johnny Miller yips this year.

TheLoneCougar

10/23/17 11:23am

I don’t like any of our options at QB

youngster

10/23/17 11:48am

Maybe it's time to give Kafentzis a real shot. Not just wildcat.

mcnasty

10/23/17 3:25pm

<< Deleted >>

Cretin

10/23/17 12:00pm

This ^^^

OhioCougFan

10/23/17 12:37pm

No one thinks he’s crazy. But his primary football issues...

canofpicante

10/23/17 1:20pm

Many better phrases could have been used indeed.

Bluedarts

10/23/17 2:18pm

Actually... I have to wonder about having the leader of your team

deljdc

10/23/17 3:49pm

That's right! MAN UP! Don't talk to anybody, and especially don't let the people

SWP

10/23/17 6:42pm

Exactly! We’ve seen this before.

canofpicante

10/23/17 1:16pm

Anyone who thinks we need a different QB have no idea what they are talking abou

joesemenoff

10/23/17 1:45pm

Anyone who thinks the "issues are 100% coaching/scheme related" has no idea .

HighHorse

10/23/17 2:54pm

Please, indulge me. I’d love to hear your explaination about how

joesemenoff

10/23/17 5:04pm

Please explain to me how continuing to use a failing QB who can't

HighHorse

10/23/17 9:55pm

Well you're a bully

Jizosh

10/23/17 2:09pm

You are the person Jarom and Spencer were talking about today on Sports Nation

CT98

10/23/17 3:11pm

RE: Tanner is a headcase BYU needs changes at QB

longtimeYfan

10/23/17 5:56pm

Dead on! If TM fans would actually watch replays using slow/stop, it's ugly. He

blackshirts

10/23/17 6:16pm

So many problems w that take. Re being a TM problem only

Posting on CougarBoard