My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 25, 2015
4:40
:20
pm
The Dude Abides
No doubt. Bronco has been awful in the rivalry. But it's just not fair to
compare Rose and Bronco and say "Rose beats Utah and Bronco doesn't".
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
The Dude Abides
Previous username
ItsBYU4me
Bio page
The Dude Abides
Joined
Jul 3, 2007
Last login
May 17, 2020
Total posts
48,609 (17,534 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
POLL: Approval Rating: Dave Rose
Art Director
8/24/15 3:28pm
The severe tank we saw from BYU's defense last year is very concerning.
SandYFan
8/24/15 3:31pm
I love Coach Rose, but I don't think we have great assistant coaches.
Zaius
8/24/15 3:33pm
If you're a BYU fan and honestly answered "Strongly Disapprove"
Indy Coug
8/24/15 3:34pm
I didn't answer Strongly Disapprove, but I do find it interesting how different
workindev
8/24/15 3:37pm
No, the results are not similar.
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 4:05pm
How is the S16 = to a NY6 bowl?
ag4cougs
8/24/15 4:28pm
RE: How is the S16 = to a NY6 bowl?
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 4:30pm
That is the most ridiculous compare ever - add 150 UNLVs in football
OC Coug
8/24/15 6:35pm
Do you really think that there are the same number of good teams in
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 7:59pm
I disagree. There is a lot more parity in basketball than there is in Football.
workindev
8/24/15 6:25pm
Its not even close
OC Coug
8/24/15 6:36pm
You're not disagreeing with me then. That's what the facts demonstrate.
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 8:04pm
Having one player stand out is an accomplishment as a coach?
southernfriedcougar
8/24/15 7:46pm
Is that so? You don't think Bronco having a Heisman winner would have made
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 8:05pm
RE: Is that so? You don't think Bronco having a Heisman winner would have made
southernfriedcougar
8/24/15 11:07pm
Preach
ag4cougs
8/25/15 5:43am
This thread is about the approval of Dave Rose.
Gentleman Stan
8/25/15 9:38am
RE: This thread is about the approval of Dave Rose.
southernfriedcougar
8/25/15 5:28pm
First, Rose's peak is 2 years more recent than Bronco's. And Rose's
Gentleman Stan
8/25/15 5:54pm
You know EVERY YEAR Rose's team will choke and under perform. He is exactly
BYUtka
8/24/15 5:57pm
Dude, Worthington started for BYU last year. Just contemplate that for a minute
Big Daddy D
8/24/15 6:09pm
How many "Worthington" or worse players start in FB? If he was the best we have
BYUtka
8/24/15 6:21pm
I like Rose, but like others have stated, I find it odd he escapes the same
ag4cougs
8/24/15 6:41pm
I am not saying he isn't... I am saying that he is the same as Bronco and that I
BYUtka
8/24/15 7:34pm
preach
ag4cougs
8/24/15 6:35pm
Some perspective
wisconsincougs
8/25/15 9:41am
RE: I didn't answer Strongly Disapprove, but I do find it interesting how
southernfriedcougar
8/24/15 7:43pm
Now that's just ridiculous. Why risk damaging a perfectly good garage door???
LeftOfNormal
8/24/15 4:17pm
Seriously. Same even for "disapprove".
tony
8/24/15 5:44pm
Why all the Rose love and the hating on Bronco?
AzCoug1
8/24/15 3:38pm
Rose has one of the 10 highest winning percentages of all active coaches
Indy Coug
8/24/15 3:42pm
I have a patented hashtag that explains it all!
Goatnapper'96
8/24/15 3:44pm
Where does Bronco fall in this area ?
ManicBlue
8/24/15 3:45pm
He's only 13th amongst active coaches
Indy Coug
8/24/15 3:47pm
Wow ... horrible
ManicBlue
8/24/15 3:48pm
How's he doing vs Utah? That's what I thought...
Kerbouchard
8/24/15 3:53pm
<< Deleted >>
Art Director
8/24/15 4:01pm
How did Rose do against mighty Pepperdine last year? San Diego?
workindev
8/24/15 6:48pm
Have to be fair here. Rose has played Utah's worst teams in history and Bronco
The Dude Abides
8/24/15 7:39pm
Couldn't have said it better
southernfriedcougar
8/24/15 11:18pm
That being said, Bronco is terrible at rivalry games. BYU has been favored in
messi
8/25/15 10:05am
No doubt. Bronco has been awful in the rivalry. But it's just not fair to
The Dude Abides
8/25/15 4:40pm
That's true, but I think it is fair to say that Rose does a much better job at
messi
8/25/15 4:57pm
<< Deleted >>
gmj81
8/25/15 5:59pm
Terrible: He's only 26th.
Skipshot
8/24/15 3:47pm
Getting to the Sweet Sixteen is light years beyond what Bronco has
SandYFan
8/24/15 3:45pm
and football's post-season is setup completely differently too
ManicBlue
8/24/15 3:47pm
Easier to make a bowl than make it into the Round of 64.
SandYFan
8/24/15 3:49pm
maybe ...
ManicBlue
8/24/15 4:04pm
You only have to be 6-6 to go to a bowl. Some teams hoops teams don't make the
BearsandBulls
8/24/15 4:03pm
If that was so easy, wouldn't more teams be doing it every year ?
ManicBlue
8/24/15 4:14pm
There are 39 bowl games including the semi-finals and national championship game
BearsandBulls
8/24/15 4:42pm
One more time ...
ManicBlue
8/24/15 5:02pm
I think most P5 programs would have gone to bowl games as consistently as
BearsandBulls
8/24/15 5:16pm
I guess we'll just have to go with what you 'think' rather than any actual facts
ManicBlue
8/24/15 6:11pm
He provided several mathematical facts and you side-stepped them.
swingcat
8/24/15 6:18pm
If you'll note ...
ManicBlue
8/24/15 6:23pm
Actually Bronco has finished in the top 16 three times
PolarisPrime
8/24/15 4:01pm
There aren't a similar number of competitive teams in
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 4:27pm
Some of what you say has merrit
PolarisPrime
8/24/15 5:52pm
Please explain how being one of the Top 12 teams
Gentleman Stan
8/24/15 8:09pm
Curious ..
ManicBlue
8/24/15 8:49pm
Those numbers aren't accurate.
PolarisPrime
8/25/15 12:17am
It depends on what you consider "resources." In any event, it's clear that
Gentleman Stan
8/25/15 9:16am
Thats why I said "similar" numbers
PolarisPrime
8/25/15 2:07pm
Umm... actually, BYU has finished top 16 three times under Bronco
wiscougarfan
8/24/15 4:09pm
Jimmer, Sweet 16, Utah, he's not weird, etc...
Walter Bellhaven
8/24/15 3:50pm
Because Rose is not owned by Yewtah, for starters.
Kerbouchard
8/24/15 3:52pm
the last two years beg to differ
gmj81
8/24/15 5:12pm
Rose has arguably faced easier Utah teams than Bronco.
southernfriedcougar
8/25/15 12:53am
Really?
Gerald-DeGroot
8/24/15 3:59pm
Approve. Strongly Approve is not warranted until NCAA tourney win % increases.
Kerbouchard
8/24/15 3:54pm
^^^ I approve this message ^^^
AzCoug1
8/24/15 4:04pm
I got a thumbs down for this? Good grief...
Kerbouchard
8/24/15 4:33pm
amen. I'm happy with both coaches but certainly each have weaknesses
gmj81
8/24/15 5:14pm
Needs some conference hardware, too.
ag4cougs
8/24/15 6:47pm
yep. His post season play doesn't warrant strongly approve.
southernfriedcougar
8/24/15 7:48pm
Arguably our best coach ever
SonsOfAlvin
8/24/15 8:38pm
come on
AzCoug1
8/24/15 9:28pm
Make an argument for anyone else.
SonsOfAlvin
8/25/15 12:54pm
Stan Watts
AzCoug1
8/25/15 2:00pm
Watts was also at BYU for much longer. 22 seasons I believe.
Gentleman Stan
8/25/15 2:39pm
Coaching Tree...
gmj81
8/25/15 6:00pm
2 D1 head coaches in 10 years is a solid coaching tree. Who has flamed out?
wisconsincougs
8/25/15 6:32pm
Rooese and Rice were the two that I was thinking of.
gmj81
8/25/15 7:01pm
I see where you're coming from. To answer the Rice question, he spent 6 yrs
wisconsincougs
8/25/15 7:13pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad