The CFP committee use SOS, SOR, and FPI when it suits them

Report problem with this ad

Dec 26, 2024
9:46:48am

Doogal McCougar All-American

Alabama or Miami would have easily reached the CFP over SMU if the committee relied on SOR or FPI.

Report problem with this ad

Doogal McCougar

Previous username: boscatar
Bio page: Doogal McCougar
Joined: Jun 14, 2012
Last login: Dec 27, 2024
Total posts: 16,511 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Drake Toll going after ESPN & 247 for downgrading players transferring to Big12

thewaterboy

Dec 26, 8:17am

<< Deleted >>

2FarGone

Dec 26, 8:18am

He is building a very compelling case of media collusion to prop up SEC and downgrade Big 12

2FarGone

Dec 26, 8:20am

Which makes no sense to me because the Big12 is an ESPN property also

thewaterboy

Dec 26, 8:22am

isn't is a shared property with Fox and don't they pay the SEC much more?

2FarGone

Dec 26, 8:24am

Of course, but it seems like you'd want to drive up viewership for your property

thewaterboy

Dec 26, 8:26am

Stop lol.

TCuz

Dec 26, 8:29am

What's his CB handle?

SJS

Dec 26, 8:21am

TCuz

thewaterboy

Dec 26, 8:29am

I’ve seen this on Twitter this week. This is ridiculous criticism and makes our fans look stupid.

TCuz

Dec 26, 8:21am

What exactly is ridiculous? Do you have data to refute their data ?

Dr MoBYU

Dec 26, 8:23am

Re-rating a transfer seems to make sense to me, and a player that didn't crack the 2 deep in 2 years should drop

Greg Kite's 'stache

Dec 26, 8:35am

That makes more sense, and is possible. The problem is that neither SOR or FPI are open source

TCuz

Dec 26, 8:47am

The CFP committee use SOS, SOR, and FPI when it suits them

Doogal McCougar

Dec 26, 9:46am

It has always been this way to a certain extent with HS recruits. The more blue

LeGrandBleu

Dec 26, 8:35am

The #1 TP class is a Big12 school.

MissouriCoug18

Dec 26, 8:39am

FPI and similar are a joke because of this. Also, transfer rating

88Coug

Dec 26, 8:51am

When kids often make a decision within a day of announcing, you’re not going to

molodyets

Dec 26, 9:33am

This take is so stupid. Of course a player who never plays is rated lower when they transfer.

RealTaysomHill

Dec 26, 8:53am

Did you hear his Gentry example? He played & in regular rotation including in NC team.

Soupie

Dec 26, 8:57am

It’s the same thing. When he was rated out of high school, he rated really highly against other high school players

RealTaysomHill

Dec 26, 9:13am

It matters because multiple ranking systems including FPI include

88Coug

Dec 26, 9:39am

Yeah it’s crazy to think a business is profit maximizing.

chilawcoug

Dec 26, 9:57am

Which business is “profit maximizing” but underrating BYU?

RealTaysomHill

Dec 26, 10:06am

Well, the SEC and B1G dwarf BYU in revenue.

chilawcoug

Dec 26, 4:23pm

Haven't followed ESPN, but 247 seems to have rerated all of them BEFORE they went to the Big 12

krindorr

Dec 26, 8:59am

That way it's easier to prop up certain preseason rankings using recruiting rank

Mitty

Dec 26, 9:36am

Which then carry over to how wins & losses are valued throughout the season. House of cards.

Soupie

Dec 26, 10:44am

Seems pretty blatant, glad someone in the media is going after them!

NonmormonYfan89

Dec 26, 11:00am

I'm only paranoid because everyone is out to get me.

ochobeeguy

Dec 26, 11:01am

I hope Arizona State gets to the title game - just to close the mouths of these manipulators

BYUFootballRocks1

Dec 26, 11:30am

As much as I dislike ASU and like Sark, I want ASU to win by 3 TDs on its

88Coug

Dec 26, 11:39am

Same

NonmormonYfan89

Dec 26, 11:44am

Drake be like…

Posting on CougarBoard