Winning 10 games in a season is not very troubling though. Cherry picking the

Dec 19, 2024
4:28:49pm

boctabulous All-American

bad can be done for any player. Jake had a great season and was near the top of qb's in the conference.

Also fwiw, every player who has only played the last two years at byu is also 0-4 in those same games.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 19, 2024 at 4:28:49pm

Message modified by boctabulous on Dec 19, 2024 at 4:30:14pm

Report problem with this ad

boctabulous

Bio page: boctabulous
Joined: Aug 20, 2016
Last login: Dec 20, 2024
Total posts: 4,301 (3 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Max Hall’s reign as BYU’s winningest quarterback is in jeopardy

2FarGone No One of Consequence

Dec 19, 12:35pm

With NIL involved the new model will be send a QB to JUCO to develop and then

mudpupper

Dec 19, 12:39pm

Hold on, be real with me: Does Retzlaff really have three more years?

Ham

Dec 19, 12:42pm

Potentially.

dwhitebud

Dec 19, 12:43pm

No, for 2 reasons. It's specific only to Pavia and it's an injunction, not a ruling....but it does raise the possibility

krindorr

Dec 19, 2:40pm

On the contrary - and with reason to be optimistic - NCAA has been on the losing

nybyblue

Dec 19, 2:50pm

True, but that logic is less JUCO based and more on not having any eligibility limits at all

krindorr

Dec 19, 6:59pm

"Potentially"

dwhitebud

Dec 19, 3:11pm

Yeah, was intended to be in response to the comment above yours

krindorr

Dec 19, 5:41pm

Apparently

2FarGone

Dec 19, 12:44pm

RE: Hold on, be real with me: Does Retzlaff really have three more years?

WJCougar

Dec 19, 12:48pm

<< Deleted >>

CocaColaRecovery

Dec 19, 12:49pm

I’m ok with Retzlaff not getting extra years

Big12Yfan

Dec 19, 12:58pm

You would forgo all the in-game experience and development?

2FarGone

Dec 19, 1:05pm

I think what you see is what you get.

WJCougar

Dec 19, 2:06pm

And Oklahoma situational awareness was lacking in all 3 losses

Big12Yfan

Dec 19, 2:17pm

I actually think he played much better in other games. Kansas and ASU showed

boctabulous

Dec 19, 2:19pm

He’s very average and had a pretty good cast around him

Big12Yfan

Dec 19, 2:15pm

In his 1st year as a P4 QB (4 games last year) he was the 3rd best QB in Big12

NYC and Japan

Dec 19, 3:25pm

I love the kid, but the fact he’s played in 4 do or die games and is 0-4

Big12Yfan

Dec 19, 4:00pm

Winning 10 games in a season is not very troubling though. Cherry picking the

boctabulous

Dec 19, 4:28pm

22 players and 11 on defense won 10 games

Big12Yfan

Dec 19, 5:35pm

Lol. Im certain that in those 4 games other players made mistakes as well.

boctabulous

Dec 19, 5:49pm

Let's do this with every BYU QB in games they needed to win to make a BCS or

dfudge

Dec 19, 5:21pm

Please let us know which 4 games someone died because Cougars lost? Your judge

NYC and Japan

Dec 19, 7:37pm

What defines "do or die"

krindorr

8:03am

At least you are consistent!

OldFogey

Dec 19, 2:30pm

Watching guys double down on a bad take is one of the more entertaining parts of CB

MaxxPower

Dec 19, 2:41pm

Yep

2FarGone

Dec 19, 5:56pm

He is the equivalent of having Cooper Rush start your NFL team.

maYbe

Dec 19, 3:10pm

Wait so you think Rush is the 3rd best qb in the nfl? Weird take.

boctabulous

Dec 19, 3:52pm

So you think Jake is a top 10 draft pick behind Sanders and Ward.

maYbe

Dec 19, 4:51pm

Not what I think just what he was rated in the league he plays in.

boctabulous

Dec 19, 5:34pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad