I’m not sure where you are seeing 2021 as rostered year.

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 11, 2024
10:37:50am

BYU '80 Intervention Needed

I’m not sure where you are seeing 2021 as rostered year.

Even if it was, he recorded no playing time. He showed a lot more in his second year than JoJo did in his second. Also jojo had playing time in his first and based on your timeline, chase did not. I count 2022 as Roberts first year because I’m basing it on when each player started getting time

Report problem with this ad

BYU '80

Bio page: BYU '80
Joined: Jan 11, 2006
Last login: Jan 5, 2025
Total posts: 56,251 (151 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU moving in the transfer portal…GOOD! We need to take advantage of momentum

Lombardi

12/11/24 10:04am

Shore up the trenches first, then everything else is gravy

2FarGone

12/11/24 10:06am

We desperately need some proven talent on the DL.

mudpupper

12/11/24 10:27am

Absolutely

TNT

12/11/24 11:14am

Batty, Mangelson and Nelson were tough, rugged guys. B12 RBs going to test us

Lombardi

12/11/24 12:36pm

If we take them from Utah, we get the added benefit of taking them from Utah.

Dryfire

12/11/24 3:15pm

That's the Detroit Lions recipe for success - invested a lot in the lines

CougarGregor

12/11/24 12:54pm

Always. Trenches are the difference between good and great.

Ironhide

12/11/24 2:41pm

The only player I want at this point is Ryder Lyons...

Coug

12/11/24 10:09am

I want DL and OL every year. Plus Lyons.... I want all of it!

Cougar TD

12/11/24 10:11am

RE: I want DL and OL every year. Plus Lyons.... I want all of it!

Cougero

12/11/24 12:34pm

RE: I want DL and OL every year. Plus Lyons.... I want all of it!

OGSuperfan

12/11/24 3:41pm

RE: I want DL and OL every year. Plus Lyons.... I want all of it!

hamaca

12/11/24 4:50pm

+ his brother Walker "Texas Ranger" Lyons!

Captain Stubing

12/11/24 10:13am

We probably don’t have enough money with how much we’re paying Dybantsa

CaliforniaCougar22

12/11/24 10:25am

I think our WR group is in good shape: Marion, JoJo, Parker, Hagen, McKenzie

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:10am

I don’t think any of those are a solid 1 or even 2. They are solid 3s. We need 1-2 alphas.

Haysom Till

12/11/24 10:12am

Chase?

RGGeemer

12/11/24 10:13am

Said he is going to go NFL, but that was a while ago.

Ycrazy

12/11/24 10:15am

Even Chase is a great #2. It would be awesome to have a healthy Puka for example

runnincoug

12/11/24 10:15am

- says every NFL team in history

Gustav

12/11/24 10:24am

true. perhaps unrealistic expectations.

runnincoug

12/11/24 10:34am

Nah. You need to shoot even higher. Prime megatron and prime Randy Moss

Reasonable1

12/11/24 11:56am

If he stayed ya he’d be a great Wr1 but he said he’s out last I heard.

Haysom Till

12/11/24 10:34am

Hes coming back

RGGeemer

12/14/24 7:57am

I think Hagen will develop into a 1. Maybe not next year, but the year after

LifeLongLakerFan

12/11/24 10:14am

No doubt about it Hagen has WR1 written all over him. The problem is this poster sees these guys as they are and not as

kimdaddy35

12/11/24 10:22am

The problem is this poster sees things as they aren’t and lives on hopium and a prayer that dudes will suddenly trans

Haysom Till

12/11/24 10:37am

By "this poster" I assume you're referring to yourself?

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:41am

"This poster" pays attention to what coaches say (raves about Cody and how

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:45am

I know you are really young and don't get it. That is ok. I'm guessing you don't have

kimdaddy35

12/11/24 12:11pm

It's an odd blind spot and some circular logic: "there aren't any 'alphas' bc

oxcoug

12/11/24 12:57pm

People who overuse “Beta” when addressing true alphas are soy boys 100% of the time.

Haysom Till

12/11/24 4:39pm

That post reads like:

kimdaddy35

12/11/24 6:38pm

RE: That post reads like:

Haysom Till

12/11/24 10:44pm

Hagen is literally the most highly recruited / sought after WR commit in our

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:16am

Thank you, that's a good reminder!

runnincoug

12/11/24 10:19am

Obviously they have to show it on the field but Hagen / JoJo are evaluated as

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:24am

Re Jojo, IMO, he needs to put in some serious time with the JUGS machine to

LifeLongLakerFan

12/11/24 10:39am

Your last line is hogwash.

Haysom Till

12/11/24 10:38am

Nah. They are proven to the coaches they play for. The fact that they have five

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:54am

Jojo doesn’t have the hands to be a great WR

I'mBatman

12/11/24 11:12am

JoJo had fewer drops per ten targets this year than Lassiter. And he's not

oxcoug

12/11/24 12:59pm

They both had too many drops

I'mBatman

12/11/24 10:04pm

None of those is a proven alpha though.

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:15am

Neither was Chase entering last season. And he is not as fast as any of them.

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:16am

His numbers from last year to this are very similar.

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:28am

Yeah - he committed in 2019. 2024 is his fourth roster year in the program.

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:31am

I would argue Roberts was an alpha in 2023

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:35am

He was on the 2021 roster. 2023 was his third roster year.

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:42am

Redshirted in 2021 due to surgery

RGGeemer

12/11/24 10:47am

Yes. Like I said, 2023 was his third year in the program. In 2021 he was in the

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:51am

Just saying he's obviously not going to be an alpha if he can't play. Silly

RGGeemer

12/11/24 10:53am

No one is until given the opportunity.

12/11/24 10:20am

You can have a sense. Players don’t go from a few catches to alpha in

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:25am

Like Chase going from 4 catches for 12 yards and zero TDs in 2022 to 42 grabs

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:28am

He had 22 catches and over 400 yards in 2022

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:30am

I was mixing in rushing stats - so in his second roster year in the program he

oxcoug

12/11/24 10:34am

I’m not sure where you are seeing 2021 as rostered year.

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:37am

Yes, playing as a RS freshman coming off major surgery and behind Puka Nacua and

RGGeemer

12/11/24 10:58am

Hagen and Phillips, at least, have

12/11/24 10:40am

How many programs have a proven alpha WR going into each season? Few.

LifeLongLakerFan

12/11/24 10:35am

I would say not a few. A decent number.

BYU '80

12/11/24 10:38am

I think you are over-estimating. And, I see similar potential in Hagen, Phillips

LifeLongLakerFan

12/11/24 11:09am

Parker Kingston too. I think JoJo will be a legit #1 and Marion is a legit #2

boctabulous

12/11/24 10:57am

By the time the spring portal hits, we will have a lot more players enter the portal from BYU than we sign

BYUMizzou

12/11/24 10:30am

yep. We need to sign starters, not depth. That's why Isaac W. doesn't make sense

runnincoug

12/11/24 10:37am

So you don't like any high school recruits? That's basically what Wilson is.

Lance71

12/11/24 11:23am

Except he only has 3 years of eligibility. And except we've seen him play in FBS football, and he wasn't good.

BYUMizzou

12/11/24 11:35am

Yep, he'd have 3 years and no redshirt left. Evidence would indicate he's QB2

runnincoug

12/11/24 11:52am

He does have a redshirt. He has 4 years to play 3.

Lance71

12/11/24 12:09pm

Right, sorry, I mean he wouldn't get to play until after his redshirt.

runnincoug

12/11/24 12:31pm

He was recruited by a lot of really good teams. If he isn't good enough, he

Lance71

12/11/24 12:36pm

So take up a roster spot while rehabbing so we can cut wakely, harper, & others?

runnincoug

12/11/24 12:53pm

If he comes to BYU, that means the coaches disagree with you.

Lance71

12/11/24 12:56pm

A-Rod said on signing day that going forward that the norm would be to have 4 QBs on roster. At the most in an

BYUMizzou

12/11/24 1:07pm

Any, or all of them other than Hillstead and Lugo.

Lance71

12/11/24 1:25pm

I've heard Trey is impressive in camp. Who knows.

runnincoug

12/11/24 3:02pm

I hope we'd keep a spot for Kenny, the guy signed for this year's class.

runnincoug

12/11/24 3:02pm

Obviously. And my posting history would indicate I support the coaches.

runnincoug

12/11/24 3:01pm

Does anyone know exactly how many roster spots we have in light of the new

rockhound

12/11/24 10:32am

I doubt we add another QB. With the new 105 limit we probably stick with 4 or so

arcawley

12/11/24 2:02pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad