I wish they'd done a Beren and Luthien story

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 5, 2024
11:52:21am

Elrond Hubbard Contributor

I wish they'd done a Beren and Luthien story

There's the bones there for a classic.

Report problem with this ad

Elrond Hubbard

Previous username: Chapalapticus
Bio page: Elrond Hubbard
Joined: Sep 14, 2023
Last login: Nov 5, 2024
Total posts: 438 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Hot Take: I loved the "Rings of Power"

a priori

11:45am

I haven't read any books, but I liked the series as well

11:45am

I liked it. The last episode seemed kind of like they couldn't figure out what

RGGeemer

11:45am

The last episode did seem rushed — they had to tie together a whole bunch of

a priori

11:46am

Sauron was the best part of the 2nd season by far. Very well done.

RGGeemer

11:47am

Completely agree.

a priori

11:48am

The final episode seemed like they figured out the slow burn from the previous episodes had been too slow

Indy Coug

11:48am

I also disagree on Elrond. That is no elf warrior.

RGGeemer

11:46am

Some of the casting was great. Elrond and Galadriel were terrible. Tolkien makes

oxcoug

12:26pm

Fair points.

a priori

1:49pm

I agree w you overall, BTW - I think it's mostly good. Those two castings kinda

oxcoug

2:27pm

It’s great television. Can’t wait for season three.

Flippy

11:46am

I also really enjoyed the series. I thought Elrond was a little weird and

tony

11:49am

I keep saying it and I stand by it: the actors for Elrond and Celebrimbor would

SalmonOfCapistrano

11:50am

Haha--I can see that.

a priori

11:53am

it's the jaw line I think. The actress for Galadriel is very short but she

SalmonOfCapistrano

11:54am

Celebrimbor was great this season, though. He and Sauron side by side was

RGGeemer

11:53am

I'm not saying anything about the acting ability of either of them

SalmonOfCapistrano

11:56am

I agree on Elrond, I thought Celebrimbor was fine.

oxcoug

12:29pm

It's flawed, but ultimately it's entertaining. My wife and I enjoyed it.

ldssdl

11:51am

I wish they'd done a Beren and Luthien story

11:52am

Abjectly poor production by any standard.

MarylandFan

11:58am

RE: Abjectly poor production by any standard.

claw

12:07pm

It’s a MST3K type of show because of how poorly written it is.

MarylandFan

12:53pm

Season 1 was pretty bad. Season 2 was a lot better.

JuicyJam

11:59am

Tom Bombadil is in season 2?

NGB

12:12pm

Why not?

LifeLongLakerFan

12:18pm

He an exceptionally stupid character

NGB

12:25pm

He was great

RGGeemer

12:30pm

I agree he's the worst part of LOTR - but they do great work with him in RoP.

oxcoug

12:31pm

No problem not having him in the LOTR movies.

JuicyJam

12:37pm

I thought he was an interesting side story in LOTR books. I agree

LifeLongLakerFan

12:38pm

Yup, what we know of Bombadil from LOTR opens up license to treat him as an

oxcoug

12:49pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad