I think there will likely be 3 bids in total for the Big 12 and ACC this year,

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Invalid message

Report problem with this ad

Nov 3, 2024
11:31:29am

Japan Coug Intervention Needed

I think there will likely be 3 bids in total for the Big 12 and ACC this year,

and most years, unless there happen to be 2 truly outstanding teams in each conference. Before yesterday, it appeared that KSU or ISU could fit the bill for the Big 12 (along with BYU), and SMU or Clemson for the ACC (along with Miami). Now, only BYU, Miami, and SMU are realistic candidates for at-large berths between the two conferences.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 3, 2024 at 11:31:29am

Message modified by Japan Coug on Nov 3, 2024 at 11:59:05am

Report problem with this ad

Japan Coug

Bio page: Japan Coug
Joined: Feb 3, 2003
Last login: Nov 6, 2024
Total posts: 39,342 (523 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU, you are our only hope.

Tesla Coug Lord of the Manor

Nov 3, 7:08am

I think if Iowa State wins out to the championship game and loses to BYU, they

Shinshin

Nov 3, 7:11am

Maybe if Texas tech can win out

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:17am

I think this is highly unlikely. I don’t think any 2-loss Big 12 team is going

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:27am

Not sure. But they would be 11-1 going into the CCG. An 11-2 team that only has

Shinshin

Nov 3, 7:32am

It’ll force the committee to show their cards. Do they put 10-2 Clemson who

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:44am

Clemson will end up 8-4 or 9-3

hdx57

Nov 3, 2:24pm

I don’t think Clemson gets an at-large bid with 2 losses. Their only chance now

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 3:04pm

If their loss had been to K-State or Colorado, then I would agree. But ISU lost

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:48am

There is still a lot of football left.

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 7:50am

Tuesday will bring a lot of clarity. Is Iowa state in the 15-18 range? Or 20-25?

CycloneCoug

Nov 3, 7:56am

Historic CFP rankings show 11 win teams basically always in CFP and most 2 loss

NYC and Japan

Nov 3, 8:30am

I think there's also going to be more 11 win and 1-2 lots teams than ever before

Kajdin

Nov 3, 9:09am

But that's 11 win P5 teams. And there's a different environment now

krindorr

Nov 3, 9:20am

Don't buy into the P2 narrative. Big10 and SEC look just as bad/good as the Big

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 10:25am

And yet the B1G has 4 teams higher than any Big 12 team

krindorr

Nov 3, 12:41pm

Overrated. Sagarin has SEC #1, Big12 #2, Big10 #3, ACC #4

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 1:23pm

Sagarin also has BYU #3 in th Big 12

krindorr

Nov 3, 2:07pm

And I'm saying we shouldn't be buying into or furthering that false narrative

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 3:24pm

Fair, I'm trying to estimate what the committee will do, not what I think they should do

krindorr

Nov 3, 4:06pm

I've looked at this before. 11 win P5 teams would've generally always made it.

cougarfan84

Nov 3, 10:16am

I get where he’s coming from but he’s almost at that point where he’s asking

Don Carlton

Nov 3, 7:18am

He didnt ask us to root for a loss....

TheHop

Nov 3, 7:34am

That might be true and honestly I’m a huge conference fan and

Don Carlton

Nov 3, 8:01am

He knows we won’t cheer for a loss - just his way of saying what helps

truecougster

Nov 3, 9:42am

RE: He knows we won’t cheer for a loss - just his way of saying what helps

thirdgencoug

Nov 3, 10:25am

Yeah, he’s not wrong, yesterday was a bad day for the Big 12

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 7:19am

Go BYU!

Dark Forest Green

Nov 3, 7:25am

Having a home game in playoff will not be as good as you think…

BornBlue

Nov 3, 7:34am

It would be epic

RGGeemer

Nov 3, 7:35am

You have never been wronger

JimmyZ

Nov 3, 7:39am

The student section would still be maxed out

palangi

Nov 3, 9:00am

Would they still sell student section seats?

Dark Forest Green

Nov 3, 9:18am

I’m not sure how it works, but whether they sell them or student roc passes get

palangi

Nov 3, 9:58am

my son would absolutely make the 3 and a half hour drive back to Provo for game.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:51am

If only there were other fans in or around Utah that might attend a college FB

tony

Nov 3, 2:29pm

Drake doesn't get the BYU persecution complex yet. The committee would love an

Cheap Seats

Nov 3, 7:51am

To be fair, we haven't had a consistent team in a long time

JupiterJones

Nov 3, 8:43am

This is exactly it. Until we consistently put really good seasons together, then

brazilcoug

Nov 3, 9:35am

Maybe 5 programs that have been consistently good for any length of time.

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:06am

I get your point but you are confusing Vegas odds makers with pollsters

truecougster

Nov 3, 9:44am

Why do people keep saying this?

bythenumbers

Nov 3, 9:51am

Even ignoring BYU, why would you expect this?

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:10am

The CFP has been pretty reasonable in the past

bythenumbers

Nov 3, 10:24am

It gets more political with 12. WAY more money to conferences.

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:35am

How about look and see who is actually on the committee before making broad statements like this

DJROSS

Nov 3, 10:32am

I didn’t read any of that. Sorry

cosmette

Nov 3, 10:35am

I think there will likely be 3 bids in total for the Big 12 and ACC this year,

Japan Coug

Nov 3, 11:31am

we'll find out on Tuesday how the committee views BYU. Top 5-8 good. below bad.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:56am

Tuesday we'll know how they feel about a zero loss BYU. The point was how would

Cheap Seats

Nov 3, 1:55pm

if BYU starts out in the 5-8 range they will weather one loss in CCG.

qwerew

Nov 3, 3:39pm

That was a great segment. I agree 100%

boctabulous

Nov 3, 10:06am

Im pro byu first and B12 second. Byu needs to just win. In this day and age the

Magneto

Nov 3, 10:17am

He’s so wrong. B12 needs byu to win the NC

Dr MoBYU

Nov 3, 11:15am

So he’ll root for us until the championship game and then turn on us so the auto

byuinva

Nov 3, 11:43am

I won't hold that against him. He's a fan and rep of the Big12.

qwerew

Nov 3, 11:54am

WIN THE CONFERENCE

ninja math

Nov 3, 1:43pm

I want to win out. Period.

runningryan

Nov 3, 3:15pm

RE: BYU, you are our only hope.

Cooouuugs

Nov 3, 4:55pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad