You seem to get upset by facts. He simply stated facts. BTW, I support Coach

Apr 30, 2024
8:34:03pm

Cougarbib Intervention Needed

Whiting, but, year 3 is upon us and the roster just got hammered by graduations and portal defections and an unexpected mission decision. This is BYU. It is a tough job.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Apr 30, 2024 at 8:34:03pm

Message modified by Cougarbib on Apr 30, 2024 at 8:34:53pm

Report problem with this ad

Cougarbib

Bio page: Cougarbib
Joined: Jul 28, 2003
Last login: Sep 21, 2024
Total posts: 40,953 (111 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Easy for negative pundits on CougarBoard to "rate" & "downgrade" Coach Whiting

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:31pm

Coach Whiting and her staff are building this program and they will get the

WallaX2

Apr 29, 6:40pm

Calling out CB for something that isn't happening is reaching. Pls show sources.

Ripliancum

Apr 29, 9:08pm

Amen! The success of the program has nothing to do with the head coach!

RdF3

Apr 29, 6:40pm

That's not what I said & you know it - I don't appreciate you twisting my words

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:43pm

Who are you even arguing against? Everything I've ever seen is almost all positive about her.

RdF3

Apr 29, 6:47pm

There has been some hard criticism about her, especially with her HS background

arcawley

Apr 29, 9:13pm

I admit criticizing her eyelashes and the blue gum she chews. I have been

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:19pm

RE: Amen! The success of the program has nothing to do with the head coach!

TheSpiker

Apr 29, 6:47pm

<< Deleted >>

BYUFootballRocks1

Apr 29, 6:49pm

<< Deleted >>

TheSpiker

Apr 29, 7:03pm

I haven't seen her or the program mentioned in days.

Eddie

Apr 29, 6:42pm

Exactly. Everyone knows she hasn’t met expectations but not all her fault

VirginiaPeanut

Apr 29, 8:19pm

What do you mean that she hasn’t met expectations? They were picked 13th

TempeCoug

Apr 30, 1:33am

Hope she can build it. Hopefully, the 2 new transfers help but their shooting

CougGolf

Apr 29, 6:44pm

Maybe, it was me.

jlhazlewood

Apr 29, 7:32pm

RE: Maybe, it was me.

tjerbear

Apr 29, 11:24pm

Who knows what happened with Falatea? It seems she has hung up the sneakers.

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 1:28am

Transferring to Ore.

Soupie

Apr 30, 7:28am

Is she still engaged to the new KC Chiefs 2nd round draft pick?

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 11:48am

IDK but she was in his draft day video hugging him so I'd assume so.

Soupie

Apr 30, 11:52am

Does anyone know what really went down with Falatea?

CougGolf

Apr 30, 6:58am

If you're all-state and from 3A, I get it.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 1:55pm

Another big who specializes in 3pt shooting!

SinkingQuffa

May 1, 6:44am

Look at season stats for those 2. Those are not the losses that hurt. Gustin,

Cougarbib

May 1, 7:52am

I have supported Whiting since Day 1 & still do. She has struggled some adapting

Forzaitalia

Apr 29, 6:44pm

Do you have a link to reference? Guess I may have missed it.

Soupie

Apr 29, 6:48pm

Wait a minute. I thought CB did not care about women's basketball?

Hoopster

Apr 29, 6:50pm

Posts like this are so strange. ANY coach ANYWHERE is going to have some detractors. I'm sure even SC's coach has some

jacobugath

Apr 29, 7:12pm

Her team is in big trouble next season if they can’t get more and capable bigs.

LeGrandBleu

Apr 29, 7:30pm

So true. Big12 has some big ladies… we don’t need ISU’s big, but Gustin’s build with more height

Cougarpride

Apr 29, 9:55pm

LakeshowCougs

Apr 29, 7:33pm

She's struggled (as expected), but she needs more time. Her recruiting continues to impress.

SinkingQuffa

Apr 29, 7:33pm

She definitely made a splash with her first recruiting class

cajuncoug

Apr 29, 9:09pm

Her claiming of Gibb from the yewts was a pretty big deal. Yewts are legit under Roberts

SinkingQuffa

Apr 29, 11:23pm

Juddy was an excellent coach and usually had the team in contention. Juddy

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 1:30am

No disrespect intended but Juddy was a lazy coach the last two

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 1:58pm

“Admitted as much”, LoL. Link? I would be very interested in his exact words -

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:40am

I like her. Also haven't seen the criticism. Also, why is none of the turnover

Incentivize

Apr 29, 7:37pm

Because she had to start 2 Freshman guards right away because the 2 starters

CMAC38

Apr 29, 7:48pm

It was her job to retain Shaylee, Nani, etc., and replace the no shows. Tough

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:32pm

For Shaylee to stay it could not have been Whiting’s job. 😂

Soupie

Apr 29, 9:37pm

I did not say the odds were slightly good. It was her job. Nobody bats 1.000,

Cougarbib

Apr 29, 9:43pm

You have it wrong.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 8:33am

It was her job to retain and make it work or replace with better. Nobody bats

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 11:55am

My problem with your comment is that the program was already built.

andrewg3

Apr 29, 8:56pm

Are these negative pundits in the room with you now? Haven't heard them.

Ripliancum

Apr 29, 9:02pm

I know nothing about how she'll do here but I have a question for you.

Mitty

Apr 29, 9:22pm

Yes. She often played her starters at the end of blowouts. Made no sense

VirginiaPeanut

Apr 29, 9:35pm

When she did try subbing the other team went on runs.

CMAC38

Apr 30, 8:28am

I feel asleep once I realized you were talking WBB

D.T. Survivor

Apr 29, 9:37pm

When she accepted the BYU Women’s Head Coach she became a public figure.

Bullrider

Apr 29, 10:35pm

In fact, vast majority of us were confused by this post it's been so light. I'm sure she's a big girl & can handle it

Soupie

Apr 29, 11:07pm

I just hope her leading scorer next year can shoot more than 50% FTs.

BW84

Apr 29, 11:49pm

I hope they all improve to the 80's. Seriously improve.

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 2:02pm

you cited the late 3 game win streak as proof of her coaching ability, but we

cwilke1

Apr 30, 4:44pm

Gosh! Aren't you the pessimist? We finished ahead of where

jlhazlewood

Apr 30, 6:42pm

You seem to get upset by facts. He simply stated facts. BTW, I support Coach

Cougarbib

Apr 30, 8:34pm

I think generally I'm pretty fair to her. I'm not overly pessimistic. You can

cwilke1

Apr 30, 9:11pm

Kalani and Pope have both seen large numbers of transfers out at times

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:09pm

I think she ought to be judged by a quite different standard. She inherited a

cwilke1

Apr 30, 10:27pm

Sounds like extreme assumptions embedded there based on very small sample size

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:33pm

assumptions about what? My post didn't include assumptions. We can see the

cwilke1

Apr 30, 10:37pm

It sounds like implications about “can’t get along with players…”

cajuncoug

Apr 30, 10:58pm

Whiting faces the challenge any coach faces when they coach their own kid

Cougarbib

May 1, 1:00am

BYU WBB has as good of support as a typical WBB team - probably better

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:58am

yes but its not comparable to the men. Men are top 25 for home attendance.

cwilke1

May 1, 6:44am

Juddy regularly fielded very competitive teams.

Cougarbib

May 1, 7:54am

and I think Coach Whiting will too given enough time. Judkins by no means had a

cwilke1

May 1, 8:04am

“If”. I would be happy in year 3 with a team comparable to the last 2 Juddy had.

Cougarbib

May 1, 8:09am

When they happen you fix it. We are going into year 3. Will it be fixed?

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:55am

Some if the transfers are not that talented and should be quite replaceable if

Cougarbib

May 1, 12:45am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad