My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 20, 2017
10:31
:29
am
joelvandyne
Starter
Re: "It is actually happening on this thread to a degree"
Maybe, but who is it happening to? Your post has more th'ups, so maybe we should reverse positions and I should be crying about a pile-on instead.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
joelvandyne
Bio page
joelvandyne
Joined
Jun 16, 2015
Last login
Nov 10, 2024
Total posts
25,989 (10,980 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
If you could change 1 thing about CB, what would it be? *Asking for Jefe...
Ragnar Danneskjold
This space for rent
10/19/17 2:12pm
I don't think anyone should be able to ignore me.
benny1982
10/19/17 2:13pm
Fewer stupid opinions. Can someone work on that?
Kilgore Trout
10/19/17 2:14pm
Just 1 reply so far?
Ragnar Danneskjold
10/19/17 2:14pm
Yes! RD isn't ignoring me!
Kilgore Trout
10/19/17 2:15pm
Not sure why you'd ignore Kilgore. I never see anything controversial from him.
benny1982
10/19/17 2:15pm
Oh yeah?
Kilgore Trout
10/19/17 2:19pm
Add reciprocal ignore so people I have on ignore can't see my posts.
BYUtka
10/19/17 2:15pm
You already can prevent people from seeing your posts if you don't want them to.
joelvandyne
10/19/17 2:17pm
You can?
CDV
10/19/17 2:26pm
FO posts
spugeddy24
10/19/17 2:27pm
FO?
CDV
10/19/17 2:27pm
I don't think others should have control over what I see on the board
spugeddy24
10/19/17 2:24pm
They already do. This would give you more control of who can or cannot see your
BYUtka
10/19/17 2:38pm
My way of determining who can see my posts is posting FO. Other than that I shouldn't be able to alter other's viewing
spugeddy24
10/19/17 2:39pm
Why are you good with FO but not recip ignore? What's the difference?
Ulysses14
10/19/17 6:44pm
I'm comfortable sharing personal details of my life with my FO.* Not the general
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 7:01pm
I'm saying still have FO but add a recip ignore option too
Ulysses14
10/19/17 7:17pm
Yep, very different purposes.
BYUtka
10/19/17 7:27pm
Yes, reciprocal ignores are meant to control the experiences of others.
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 7:30pm
No, they are to give you more nuanced control over your own posts.
BYUtka
10/19/17 7:40pm
By not allowing certain others to see your posts. Sounds like FO.
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 7:49pm
Then you don’t understand. I suspect you are not understanding on purpose.
BYUtka
10/19/17 8:34pm
Sounds like what Jefe says to me during appeals.
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 10:33pm
LOL....me to
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:51am
He understands. he just has a difference of opinion.
spugeddy24
10/20/17 1:45pm
By controlling other's ability of what they can see.
spugeddy24
10/20/17 1:44pm
That already happens in a bulky way. This makes it more nuanced and potentially
BYUtka
10/20/17 2:26pm
That isn't the point....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:09am
Because I shouldn't be able to control the main board.
spugeddy24
10/20/17 1:44pm
Why do you want to see his posts so badly....
CoachSpeak
10/19/17 10:05pm
General users should not be able to control the CB experience of other users. That power is limited to mods acting in
DapperDan
10/20/17 6:42am
I think GenPop would benefit because fewer people would be pushed "underground"
Ulysses14
10/20/17 6:49am
Two things. First, why do you think general users should be able to control other's CB experience?
DapperDan
10/20/17 6:52am
1) They already can via FO. If more people are comfortable with GenPop
Ulysses14
10/20/17 6:56am
FO is not genpop. FO is your playground to control. Genpop is not yours to control
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:04am
Some trolls just can't admit that it would force them to stop trolling.
Division Bell
10/20/17 8:05am
You weren't even on CB when the feature existed. It didn't do what you think it would do.
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:07am
I still think it's worth a try.
Division Bell
10/20/17 8:19am
It's been tried. It doesn't work the way you or BYUtka think it does.
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:22am
Yes. It does, and it makes CB a better place for non-trolls.
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:38am
By non-trolls, you mean"snowflakes".
Superkid
10/20/17 9:42am
Maybe....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:48am
Why are you harrassing me with your thdowns? Are you a troll?
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:48am
No, I don’t do that. I am disagreeing with your post without having to type a
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:56am
Abusing the feature is considered harrassment
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:57am
As it should be.
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:58am
You probably should disengage. It's embarrassing.
Division Bell
10/20/17 10:16am
I'm starting to feel bad for him too
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:17am
This is a perfect example of the point I am making....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:41am
You mean Division Bell coming to your aid as part of a coordinated group attack?
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:46am
I can see I've hit a nerve...
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:57am
The one that makes me laugh
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:59am
Let me help you....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 11:11am
Funny how those most outspoken against liberal "safe spaces" are the ones most loudly in favor of it on CB.
BYUtiful
10/20/17 8:20am
Reciprocal ignore is about turning your genpop experience into an echo chamber
russkiejedi
10/20/17 9:49am
No. Ignore could accomplish that. Recip refines the experience and removes the
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:55am
But this is not really true....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:04am
haha and the conspiracy theories come out. Glad I've got my tinfoil hat on.
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:05am
There's no "conspiracy theory" at all....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:13am
You're literally making up a conspiracy theory that isn't true. How can I not laugh about it?
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:15am
What "conspiracy theory" am I "making up"?
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:22am
The entire thing. What is happening is that people who disagree with posts are *gasp* disagreeing with them.
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:28am
Glad I could help you out....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:32am
Have you considered the possiblity that if so many people disagree with you
joelvandyne
10/20/17 10:10am
Or even if it's a subjective opinion, that others legitimately disagreeing with it is not coordinated trolling
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:16am
I normally see this as a “vocal minority and a silent majority” situation. Sometimes your assertion
kalifi
10/20/17 10:18am
Sure...
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:19am
Re: "It is actually happening on this thread to a degree"
joelvandyne
10/20/17 10:31am
If I was "crying" then sure....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:40am
I have considered those points. I think the people making them are wrong.
joelvandyne
10/20/17 10:50am
Hmmm.....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 11:01am
Likewise friend. Glad we could have this civil conversation.
joelvandyne
10/20/17 11:04am
You bet....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 11:12am
If it was simply not seeing people disagreeing the current ignore works just
BYUtka
10/20/17 11:06am
Oh I get it....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 8:26am
I think that's the crux of the matter.
Division Bell
10/20/17 8:31am
That you think this is about any one user's posts shows you don't understand
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:34am
But again, you could have an FO post on here too that I wouldn't be able to see
Ulysses14
10/20/17 8:40am
That's literally the purpose of FO. I don't know why you keep bringing it up.
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:43am
Unfortunately FO is not as "secure" a place as you are trying to pretend it is..
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 8:52am
I've made no claims to FO being secure, so I have no idea why you bring that up.
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:05am
I don't need any "inside knowledge"....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:07am
I'll be honest about accusations that aren't true. Will you?
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:12am
what "accusations" am I making?
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:30am
I really hope you don't believe that nonesense. No one's out to get you, they just don't agree with you
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:35am
Where did I say anyone is out to get "me"?
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 10:45am
You're missing the point. What you see as a coordinated attack is exactly what's happening here. People disagreeing and
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:50am
See you really don't get it....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 11:08am
I get that you imagine this to be the case and honestly it's quite flattering and amusing
DapperDan
10/20/17 11:12am
The lady doth protest too much, methinks. Hamlet Act 3, Scene 2
Division Bell
10/20/17 11:19am
oh no post mocking me and someone piling on with a th'up. Whatever will I do?
DapperDan
10/20/17 11:46am
Maybe you should put us on ignore.
BYUtka
10/20/17 11:51am
No thanks. I've got a great deal on my big boy pants and I'm not about to take them off
DapperDan
10/20/17 11:54am
Let me speak up for CoachSpeak. He’s just trying to get his point across.
IndianaCoug
10/20/17 11:50am
I don't think it is about "any one user's posts"....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 8:40am
If you mean "CB trolling" which means posting opinions that aren't far right or 150% in support of BYU or the Church
DapperDan
10/20/17 8:49am
and for the third or fourth time...
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 8:58am
It's very simple, a general user should not have the power to moderate other's CB experience
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:00am
Why not?
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:09am
Since Jefe has removed the feature, you'd make more sense to present an argument for "why"
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:16am
I'm not trying to make an argument for "why"....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:23am
You are looking at this backward. It is about having more control of your own
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:31am
By controlling others. If you want control, post in the FO that you control. That's what I do.
DapperDan
10/20/17 9:50am
You still have this completely backward. At this point I suspect you are missing
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:58am
You're the one with the twisted logic here.
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:01am
No. I am not.
BYUtka
10/20/17 10:36am
Too many define trolling as, "Has a different opinion/worldview than me and
Byron McNertney
10/20/17 9:07am
Agreed. I'd just rather sensitive people exclude the 1% who annoy them rather
Ulysses14
10/20/17 9:16am
Same. It is sad to me that everyone has retreated to FO.
BYUtka
10/20/17 10:09am
Sure....
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:30am
Yes it did. For those who used it, it was nice, effective and made the board a
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:30am
He is remembering corretly IMO...
CoachSpeak
10/20/17 9:33am
Why do you care who reads your posts (outside of FO), especially if you have
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 2:39pm
Right now there is no downside to getting ignored, so certain posters act in a
BYUtka
10/19/17 2:48pm
Yes, there is a downside. Your overall ignore score goes up, which impacts how many people can see your posts.
spugeddy24
10/19/17 2:52pm
You clearly don't understand how ignores work in this board
unctoothman
10/20/17 5:50am
Besides spugeddy's correct statement above, the downside is that someone else
unctoothman
10/20/17 6:16am
Why do you think it's anyone's businesses if he wants to exclude certain trolls?
Division Bell
10/19/17 9:47pm
He's controlling what users experience on the website. You can't see how that
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 10:32pm
Nope. Unless someone is ignoring a ton of people, the effects would be small but
BYUtka
10/19/17 10:51pm
So, like State-sponsored media?
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 3:04pm
Strongly disagree. You don't want to see my posts, but I sure like being able to see yours.
Superkid
10/19/17 10:22pm
You might end up seeing more. Let's say he simply doesn't want me to see his
Ulysses14
10/20/17 4:50am
If he doesn't feel comfortable posting something in genpop, that's a him
unctoothman
10/20/17 5:52am
Is that what FO is?
Ulysses14
10/20/17 6:09am
You have much more faith in humanity than I do. What I see as a more likely
joelvandyne
10/20/17 8:25am
Oh I get it. You guys are asking for a more safe space to post. That's cute.
Superkid
10/20/17 8:34am
Is that why you use FO? For a safe space?
Ulysses14
10/20/17 8:42am
No. I use FO to post stuff that's not appropriate for the board and personal info.
Superkid
10/20/17 8:48am
BYU’s record on the schedule page.
jakesnake
10/19/17 2:17pm
Not this year though.
Ragnar Danneskjold
10/19/17 2:18pm
<< Deleted >>
AndyDwyer
10/19/17 2:18pm
Rumors should include sourse. No quoting un-named people.
Count Cougar
10/19/17 2:20pm
I vote for indulgences.
Ragnar Danneskjold
10/19/17 2:21pm
Got my shirt off & pants rolled up. At the bottom of the RB stairs ready to go!
mantis mutu
10/19/17 2:28pm
They already exist if you’re liberal.
garyfan
10/19/17 2:28pm
Ideological neutrality. "Yeah right!!!"
mantis mutu
10/19/17 2:26pm
Everyone has to ignore benny1982. His opinions are terrible.
crazY
10/19/17 2:27pm
Reciprocal UNignore
benny1982
10/19/17 2:28pm
Less moderation
GhostofPostersPast
10/19/17 2:31pm
With a reciprocal ignore this would happen naturally. More people would self
BYUtka
10/19/17 2:50pm
Which is just fine. CB is not what it once was because of overmoderation
GhostofPostersPast
10/19/17 2:52pm
It didn't work that way when reciprical ignores existed
DapperDan
10/19/17 2:52pm
Pretty close to it. You are remembering wrong.
BYUtka
10/20/17 9:32am
I can guarantee I am not misremembering. You have a nostalgic view of the past.
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:02am
What type of guarantee? What are you willing to back this with?
BYUtka
10/20/17 10:23am
Since you likely think I was one of these trolls who changed their posting due to being reciprocal ignored I cann tell
DapperDan
10/20/17 10:30am
I don’t think that. Until this thread, I basically don’t remember having any
BYUtka
10/20/17 10:51am
I've been on the board forever, and it was only a couple people who couldn't handle people disgreeing with them
DapperDan
10/20/17 11:11am
Or maybe you just didn’t see it, because it was working well.
BYUtka
10/20/17 11:14am
Need to clarify that. You didn’t see how it impacted the board, because it
BYUtka
10/20/17 11:17am
It was invisible to everyone but one or two people. Not sure how that made the board better.
DapperDan
10/20/17 11:52am
Agreed. I have nobody on ignore but don’t understand why recip ignore was taken
Jericho
10/19/17 2:56pm
5 day wait period before you can post after creating account
Tygger
10/19/17 2:36pm
And 5 additional days if your first post is really stupid.
mantis mutu
10/19/17 2:39pm
Self-serve fountain drink stand, virtual of course...
Frank Castiglione
10/19/17 2:38pm
No more suspensions. Just delete posts if you don’t want them on the board
Jericho
10/19/17 2:41pm
it would be out of control.
smokymountainrain
10/19/17 3:03pm
Adding recip ignores or forcing that between offending parties for
Jericho
10/19/17 3:09pm
I think some suspense is OK, but for something egregious
GhostofPostersPast
10/19/17 4:07pm
jefe would still be CEO, but i would be chief moderation officer
smokymountainrain
10/19/17 2:48pm
Better spelling
Go_Trojans
10/19/17 2:48pm
FRAMES
shimmy
10/19/17 2:59pm
Add an "anything goes" category for subscribers
Twin Roots
10/19/17 3:01pm
that would be hugely popular.
smokymountainrain
10/19/17 3:02pm
There an "Uncivil Politics" group for subscribers that is kind of like that.
El Jefe
10/20/17 9:40am
Great suggestion. I might subscribe for that
jkccoug
10/20/17 10:43am
Everyone would agree with me...always
CBaass
10/19/17 3:06pm
Someone gets voted off the island every week.
Seaward
10/19/17 9:11pm
Pretty sure that becomes the hunger games after a while.
Blue Plate Special
10/19/17 9:18pm
To decrease trolls, before signing up, you have to answer several BYU
Traveshamockery
10/20/17 9:32am
Has to be two things. Level of Drama and Civility. So I would say
DJROSS
10/20/17 10:02am
Are you glad you asked this question?
Ulysses14
10/20/17 3:00pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad